Prince Umberto Pizzeria
1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh
(516) 221-7823
Customers' Favorites
Garlic Knots
Regular
Pie
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Day 2 back in NY looking for the right pizza. Yesterday was disappointing. Today we went to Prince Umberto. Note:Last time we were at this place was about 20 years ago. My take on the pizza was that is was a step up from yesterday's. The crust is nice, thin and good. However, too much oil on the pizza. Needs less oil. I would compair this pizza to Little Charlie's in Williamsburg, VA. Great for Virginia, not up to expectations for NY pizza. It's the plain truth,...
Undercooked pizza with raw dough on the thicker square slices. Too much cheese resulting in a greasy slice. Why do pizza shops undercook their slice pies? Reheating is not going to help cook them any further. Not coming back.
My favorite pizza place. I live in Seaford, but will go here, or have them deliver when its my turn to order pizza. The guys who work here are all very. Prices are very reasonable. Delivery is always, accurate, on-time or sometimes a little early. I highly recommend their grandma pie...hate to admit it, but I could probably eat an entire pie myself...the slices are light and go down easy. Im also a fan of their regular and Sicilian pies. My daughter likes their white pie and the...
You May Also Like
Otto's Delicatessen - 1908 Wantagh Ave
![]()
Deli, Salad, Soup
Vincent's Steakhouse - 1919 Wantagh Ave
![]()
Salad, Mediterranean