The food was great and the wait staff was awesome. Brussels sprouts and carpaccio for an appetizer were delicious. The flavor of the steaks were very good and the sides were delicious and plentiful. The place is a bit run down and needs some love. Otherwise we had a great experience though. Really nice evening out. It's like a throw back restaurant which was charming. Live music was also really good.
Rosanna
Great food and amazing customer service. 5 * place. The owner and staff really care about their customers
Veronica
We love Toto's! We were celebrating a birthday! Everyone enjoyed their meals and most of us took home some leftovers!! The owner is a gem! All the servers were amazing!! We were not rushed which is very important to us!!
Pamela
Made a reservation for last Tuesday not knowing it was a Surf and Turf special menu night. A friend recommended this restaurant and he always knows the best places to dine on Long Island. We walked in and were delighted with the beautiful decor. Our server was named Simi and he was exceptional!; kind, professional, attentive. We ordered the steak and lobster and the steak and shrimp. Our appetizer; pumpkin soup and pasta fagioli were delicious! The service was great and so was the food! A great find and definitely going on our list of favorite places!
Christine
First time back in over 30 years. The bar and restaurant are beautiful. The staff (especially Raul) were friendly - their service, recommendations and courtesy made you feel special. The brussels sprouts appetizer and short rib entree were OUTSTANDING! I cannot wait to go back !
Christa
A wonderful surprise to find this gem. The food was excellent and the service was top notch.
Debbie
I loved the classic ambiance of this dining room. The service was outstanding and the staff was warm and welcoming and even anticipated our needs. The Caesar and Toto salads were delicious and so fresh. The steaks were cooked perfectly. The ribeye was served on a sizzling platter and the filet was so tender I could cut it with a butter knife. The broccoli was the best I've ever tasted!
Erika
It's a great experience. The ambiance is charming. Amazing drinks, food and service. Staff are extremely knowledgeable and make great recommendations. We will go back!
John
Best food and service. Such a welcoming staff. Great weekend music/entertainment: loud enough to hear, but quiet enough for table conversation. Can't wait to return!
Juan
Great food and service. A wonderful local gem. The steak is always on point; flavorful and perfectly cooked.
Guillermo and Rahul fantastic servers. I'm in the food and beverage business. Hands down best experience in a long time. Hidden gem. Fantastic / flavorful/ clean/ fresh food. Owner came by to say hello. Gentleman. Made our special occasion memorable
Darlene
Toto's is an old school Long Island restaurant that has great food and service. Highly recommend!
Michael Spiro
The food was absolutely fantastic. I could not have eaten better that evening if I could think about it twice; where I would have wanted to go for dinner. I thought that the outside was nice and freshened up, considering that the hotel was rundown on the inside; however we were thrilled to have a pleasant stay. I enjoyed two glasses of chianti on top of my meal (surf & turf), and the waiter left an extra drip of wine in the serving glass at the table for me after my second order of wine, which was really generous of him. The fried zucchini was delicious as well and came with a really interesting tasting dipping sauce that looked like thousand island; far from it though, it was really great. Thank you so much.
Vincent Ricci
Just go i promise you love it
Terry
Our reservation was for 6:30 and we were seated promptly. Our table was probably not the best location, as we were positioned next to a pole, but that was not an issue. Our server Raul was a classic waiter, very attentive without being intrusive. Anything we asked for was brought to us immediately. (I would definitely ask for him next time!) Of course, the food was the star of the parade. One dish was better than the next. For appetizers, we shared the burrata salad and the grilled octopus. Both dishes were outstanding! Time was given before the entrees were brought out; I really like that! For the entrees we had lobster ravioli, which had a lot of lobster in them, the halibut, which was cooked perfectly and the spinach fettuccine which was super tasty and enjoyable accompanied by a good amount of shelled fish. We shared a bottle of the Vermentino which enhanced our meals well. (Also the price of their wine was extremely fair.) We opted for no dessert since we were full. Raul then asked us if we would like an after dinner digestive ( which was on the house) and we all opted for sambuca, which was a pleasant surprise. All in all, we loved the experience and are MOST definitely looking forward to returning!
The food was great and the wait staff was awesome. Brussels sprouts and carpaccio for an appetizer were delicious. The flavor of the steaks were very good and the sides were delicious and plentiful. The place is a bit run down and needs some love. Otherwise we had a great experience though. Really nice evening out. It's like a throw back restaurant which was charming. Live music was also really good.
Great food and amazing customer service. 5 * place. The owner and staff really care about their customers
We love Toto's! We were celebrating a birthday! Everyone enjoyed their meals and most of us took home some leftovers!! The owner is a gem! All the servers were amazing!! We were not rushed which is very important to us!!
Made a reservation for last Tuesday not knowing it was a Surf and Turf special menu night. A friend recommended this restaurant and he always knows the best places to dine on Long Island. We walked in and were delighted with the beautiful decor. Our server was named Simi and he was exceptional!; kind, professional, attentive. We ordered the steak and lobster and the steak and shrimp. Our appetizer; pumpkin soup and pasta fagioli were delicious! The service was great and so was the food! A great find and definitely going on our list of favorite places!
First time back in over 30 years. The bar and restaurant are beautiful. The staff (especially Raul) were friendly - their service, recommendations and courtesy made you feel special. The brussels sprouts appetizer and short rib entree were OUTSTANDING! I cannot wait to go back !
A wonderful surprise to find this gem. The food was excellent and the service was top notch.
I loved the classic ambiance of this dining room. The service was outstanding and the staff was warm and welcoming and even anticipated our needs. The Caesar and Toto salads were delicious and so fresh. The steaks were cooked perfectly. The ribeye was served on a sizzling platter and the filet was so tender I could cut it with a butter knife. The broccoli was the best I've ever tasted!
It's a great experience. The ambiance is charming. Amazing drinks, food and service. Staff are extremely knowledgeable and make great recommendations. We will go back!
Best food and service. Such a welcoming staff. Great weekend music/entertainment: loud enough to hear, but quiet enough for table conversation. Can't wait to return!
Great food and service. A wonderful local gem. The steak is always on point; flavorful and perfectly cooked.
Restaurantji Recommends
Guillermo and Rahul fantastic servers. I'm in the food and beverage business. Hands down best experience in a long time. Hidden gem. Fantastic / flavorful/ clean/ fresh food. Owner came by to say hello. Gentleman. Made our special occasion memorable
Toto's is an old school Long Island restaurant that has great food and service. Highly recommend!
The food was absolutely fantastic. I could not have eaten better that evening if I could think about it twice; where I would have wanted to go for dinner. I thought that the outside was nice and freshened up, considering that the hotel was rundown on the inside; however we were thrilled to have a pleasant stay. I enjoyed two glasses of chianti on top of my meal (surf & turf), and the waiter left an extra drip of wine in the serving glass at the table for me after my second order of wine, which was really generous of him. The fried zucchini was delicious as well and came with a really interesting tasting dipping sauce that looked like thousand island; far from it though, it was really great. Thank you so much.
Just go i promise you love it
Our reservation was for 6:30 and we were seated promptly. Our table was probably not the best location, as we were positioned next to a pole, but that was not an issue. Our server Raul was a classic waiter, very attentive without being intrusive. Anything we asked for was brought to us immediately. (I would definitely ask for him next time!) Of course, the food was the star of the parade. One dish was better than the next. For appetizers, we shared the burrata salad and the grilled octopus. Both dishes were outstanding! Time was given before the entrees were brought out; I really like that! For the entrees we had lobster ravioli, which had a lot of lobster in them, the halibut, which was cooked perfectly and the spinach fettuccine which was super tasty and enjoyable accompanied by a good amount of shelled fish. We shared a bottle of the Vermentino which enhanced our meals well. (Also the price of their wine was extremely fair.) We opted for no dessert since we were full. Raul then asked us if we would like an after dinner digestive ( which was on the house) and we all opted for sambuca, which was a pleasant surprise. All in all, we loved the experience and are MOST definitely looking forward to returning!
Loading...