Food was phenomenal.. we had a large group and everyone agreed..food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Marie Coscia
Toto's!!!! If you know, you know!!! This small gem in Wantagh gets packed! The food is excellent and we leave FULL!!!! 5 star steaks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Grilled Octopus, Prime Steak and Sides, Creamed Spinach
Here to celebrate a birthday. What a hidden gem! The ambiance was beautiful and intimate, the food absolutely delicious and the service was attentive without being intrusive. Everyone was sooo nice. Although we were the last ones to leave on a Thursday evening we were never pressured in any way. Thank you for a lovely evening. We will definitely be back!
Princezzstylesssssss
The restaurant is located in back of Jone Beach Hotel. We were greeted and seated as we made reservations. The drinks were good as well as food. The sharing portion is for more than two people. The waitress was nice and attentive to our table. Will definitely be going again as it was a great experience.
Not a good valentine's dinner...I was looking for something a little pricey and nice to take my wife and I got all excited about this place totos...first it took us 45 minutes b4 we got a drink...finally ordered our food and wasn't very happy with it and asked for steak sauce...they said a1 or homemade we said home made...i guess they're still making it...we asked for 2 more drinks...guess what.. never got them...not just us by the time the people sitting next to us got their food the lady said just wrap it up were leaving...I am a very good tipper, sometimes to a fault..but I love good food and good service...on a 214 dollar dinner last night I could only bring myself to leaving a 20 dollar tip and believe me when I say that was 15 too much
Diner
Met friends for dinner and were seated in the back room. The service was great, very professional and welcoming. We all really enjoyed our food and the standout dish was the chicken tre fungi. We had a great evening!
Singman
Toto's has become our favorite go to restaurant on Long Island. The food is amazing. We were there just yesterday for a double birthday celebration. We got there at the correct time and were welcomed by the owner who is a very lovely gentleman. Our table was being set up and he waited with us until it was ready. I asked him with a straight face if anything was good tonight. He stared at me for a second and then just belly laughed! The place was packed probably because of Restaurant Week. We had warm bread as we waited for our waiter. We ordered baked clams, the best, shrimp cocktail as apps. Our mains were grilled Bronzino, grilled Lamb Chops and Osso Bucco (always on my list of best dishes here). As a treat for the table I added a beautiful Ribeye cut up for everyone to sample. After dinner drinks were on the house. Toto's isn't inexpensive but I can guarantee you great service and incredible food.
RalphA
Quiet little restaurant off the beaten path. Dining there last night and the onion soup was lukewarm, our two dinners were ok, service was really slow as they were probably short-handed. The worst thing was the chairs are wood, covered with a thin cloth and I couldn't wait to leave. If we go back I will need to take a cushion for the chair. By the way the coffee was also lukewarm.
BobC
We had 2:45 reservations on a Saturday afternoon, so their were only a few tables occupied. The food was delicious and the waiter was excellent. It is a nicely decorated comfortable place with a nice bar as you come in. We will be going back as we were looking for place like this on the South Shore. Try it they are very welcoming.
DianeA
Service was excellent and food very good! Just a little too noisy with the one man band in a small area. If he was in the bar area he still Would have been heard but not as loud. He was great; played good songs.
Totos Restaurant is my favorite restaurant. Tom, the owner always greets and welcomes us and Shimmy, Raul and the rest of the staff always goes above and beyond to ensure that our dining experience is pleasurable. The menu offers a variety of delicious foods that would tempt any palate. Highly recommended.
Gina Scarda
Hidden gem in wantagh! Came tonight for dinner because we are staying in the Jones beach hotel Everything was excellent. The food , the ambiance and the service were all amazing. Highly recommend the grilled octopus with broccoli rabe! And the tiramisu is outstanding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Octopus, Caesar Salad, Tiramisu, Broccoli Rabe
After coming here for several years, the place has vastly changed. Horrible bad weeding music by a keyboard player shouting out people in the dining rm, kids crawling on the floor, bas noise level, waiter spilling our food on us several times, waiter too busy and disappearing for 15 minutes, telling us we cant order appetizers before diner order because the cook wont allow it, etc etc. wont be returning as as good as the food is, the value for ambience and service now stinks. Truly disappointed.
HILDY TEPLITZ
My husband and I just had our 35th wedding anniversary party here last night. What an amazing time we had with all our guests in their party room.Everything was fabulous starting with the initial planning to the execution. Everything went smoothly and the service and food were over the top !The entire staff did everything to make our guests feel welcome. Our guests were truly blown away by it all.The room was beautiful and comfortable with enough space for a dj.I can’t say enough how easy they made it for us to have such a memorable celebration.We highly recommend it - You can’t go wrong here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CAT1
Food is pretty good, small room would be pleasantly intimate if not for the singer who is far too loud for a small room. Service was ok except for waiter buying 2 drinks for other couple but not for us.
Food was phenomenal.. we had a large group and everyone agreed..food was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Toto's!!!! If you know, you know!!! This small gem in Wantagh gets packed! The food is excellent and we leave FULL!!!! 5 star steaks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Grilled Octopus, Prime Steak and Sides, Creamed Spinach
Here to celebrate a birthday. What a hidden gem! The ambiance was beautiful and intimate, the food absolutely delicious and the service was attentive without being intrusive. Everyone was sooo nice. Although we were the last ones to leave on a Thursday evening we were never pressured in any way. Thank you for a lovely evening. We will definitely be back!
The restaurant is located in back of Jone Beach Hotel. We were greeted and seated as we made reservations. The drinks were good as well as food. The sharing portion is for more than two people. The waitress was nice and attentive to our table. Will definitely be going again as it was a great experience.
Not a good valentine's dinner...I was looking for something a little pricey and nice to take my wife and I got all excited about this place totos...first it took us 45 minutes b4 we got a drink...finally ordered our food and wasn't very happy with it and asked for steak sauce...they said a1 or homemade we said home made...i guess they're still making it...we asked for 2 more drinks...guess what.. never got them...not just us by the time the people sitting next to us got their food the lady said just wrap it up were leaving...I am a very good tipper, sometimes to a fault..but I love good food and good service...on a 214 dollar dinner last night I could only bring myself to leaving a 20 dollar tip and believe me when I say that was 15 too much
Met friends for dinner and were seated in the back room. The service was great, very professional and welcoming. We all really enjoyed our food and the standout dish was the chicken tre fungi. We had a great evening!
Toto's has become our favorite go to restaurant on Long Island. The food is amazing. We were there just yesterday for a double birthday celebration. We got there at the correct time and were welcomed by the owner who is a very lovely gentleman. Our table was being set up and he waited with us until it was ready. I asked him with a straight face if anything was good tonight. He stared at me for a second and then just belly laughed! The place was packed probably because of Restaurant Week. We had warm bread as we waited for our waiter. We ordered baked clams, the best, shrimp cocktail as apps. Our mains were grilled Bronzino, grilled Lamb Chops and Osso Bucco (always on my list of best dishes here). As a treat for the table I added a beautiful Ribeye cut up for everyone to sample. After dinner drinks were on the house. Toto's isn't inexpensive but I can guarantee you great service and incredible food.
Quiet little restaurant off the beaten path. Dining there last night and the onion soup was lukewarm, our two dinners were ok, service was really slow as they were probably short-handed. The worst thing was the chairs are wood, covered with a thin cloth and I couldn't wait to leave. If we go back I will need to take a cushion for the chair. By the way the coffee was also lukewarm.
We had 2:45 reservations on a Saturday afternoon, so their were only a few tables occupied. The food was delicious and the waiter was excellent. It is a nicely decorated comfortable place with a nice bar as you come in. We will be going back as we were looking for place like this on the South Shore. Try it they are very welcoming.
Service was excellent and food very good! Just a little too noisy with the one man band in a small area. If he was in the bar area he still Would have been heard but not as loud. He was great; played good songs.
Restaurantji Recommends
Totos Restaurant is my favorite restaurant. Tom, the owner always greets and welcomes us and Shimmy, Raul and the rest of the staff always goes above and beyond to ensure that our dining experience is pleasurable. The menu offers a variety of delicious foods that would tempt any palate. Highly recommended.
Hidden gem in wantagh! Came tonight for dinner because we are staying in the Jones beach hotel Everything was excellent. The food , the ambiance and the service were all amazing. Highly recommend the grilled octopus with broccoli rabe! And the tiramisu is outstanding!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Octopus, Caesar Salad, Tiramisu, Broccoli Rabe
After coming here for several years, the place has vastly changed. Horrible bad weeding music by a keyboard player shouting out people in the dining rm, kids crawling on the floor, bas noise level, waiter spilling our food on us several times, waiter too busy and disappearing for 15 minutes, telling us we cant order appetizers before diner order because the cook wont allow it, etc etc. wont be returning as as good as the food is, the value for ambience and service now stinks. Truly disappointed.
My husband and I just had our 35th wedding anniversary party here last night. What an amazing time we had with all our guests in their party room.Everything was fabulous starting with the initial planning to the execution. Everything went smoothly and the service and food were over the top !The entire staff did everything to make our guests feel welcome. Our guests were truly blown away by it all.The room was beautiful and comfortable with enough space for a dj.I can’t say enough how easy they made it for us to have such a memorable celebration.We highly recommend it - You can’t go wrong here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is pretty good, small room would be pleasantly intimate if not for the singer who is far too loud for a small room. Service was ok except for waiter buying 2 drinks for other couple but not for us.