Fantastic neighbourhood bagel spot! Wantagh Bagel is hands down one of the best places to grab a fresh, delicious breakfast on Long Island. The bagels are always perfectly chewy on the inside with just the right amount of crisp on the outside. I especially love their bacon egg & cheese on an everything bagel — absolutely hits the spot every time. The staff is friendly, fast, and they keep the line moving even during busy mornings. Prices are fair, and they have a wide variety of cream cheeses and sandwich options. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Friedman
January 2025: I absolutely love Wantagh Bagels, and one of the main reasons I keep coming back is because of Genesis! She knows my order by heart and always gets it ready so quickly. Not only is she efficient, but she’s also incredibly friendly, always greeting me with a smile. It’s rare to find such great service along with delicious bagels, but Wantagh Bagels delivers on both fronts every time. Highly recommend!
Edit: April 2025 This place really has gone down hill since genesis is no longer there. Always running out of things to mix into your tea/coffee. I’ve been coming here every day for years and I think I’ll need to change where I get my breakfast before work every morning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
John Militello
Tried Wantagh Bagels after not going for a couple of years. It used to be great and would go all the time. Used to be great food and service and coffee at great prices. It has gone down over the years. The person taking my order had to write it down 3x for a bagel with butter, cream cheese and peanut butter. Waited 25 minutes for 3 bagels when there was only 1 person ahead of us for a simple order. The TV screens are still not hooked and are fogged up and look dirty and the place looks like it not being kept up. Will not be going again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Rachael Brite
I went in around 1240. Ish told me they were closed even though they close at 2 PM very mad.
Service: 2
Lisamarie Arnold
I called to place an order to send someone and the girl on the phone was so patient, helpful and kind. I don't live over there but when I'm in the area I plan to stop by. Thank you so much!
Service: 5
kae
The bagels are so delicious and fresh. They recently started selling donuts and they are SO good. The staff there are very friendly, especially Ayisha and Nicole in the front. Their customer service is excellent. Recommend everyone to go here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
sravan dhulipala
Excellent breakfast option in Wantagh. Pretty close to awesome
Vegetarian options: There are decent vegetarian options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffin, Pastries, Bagel
Ellen Claire
Almost impossible to get someone to help you….Even if you are the ONLY person waiting. This has happened to me multiple times. Today, I was told twice by the same woman that she would be right with me as she walked away from the counter to do something else. I walked out after that. How about having a person specifically assigned to work the counter? And honestly the variety of bagels and spreads is quite mediocre compared to Town Bagel located a half mile away. This business has truly gone downhill
Andrew Wiese
Wantagh Bagels has amazing bagels/food and I highly recommend them.
Maheen Anjum
Vegetarian options: should have vegan products too.
The bagels are great but let me tell you about the SALADS. Tasty, fresh and I just love the flavor!!! Coffee is good just all around outstanding! Definitely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rizwan Safdsr
One of the best bagels I have eaten so far . Very soft with great quality and taste ?
Christian Ortiz
First and foremost it was an amazing experience the bagels were so fresh and warm and tasted wonderful they were hand rolled bagels that looked delicious. Ayisha helped me at the front counter with some great suggestions to order off of the menu, she also told me about the variety of food they had. She made my bacon egg and cheese sandwich taste absolutely amazing I mean the bacon was crispy the eggs were cooked to perfection and the cheese was melted perfectly it reminded me of a real city bacon egg and cheese I highly recommend wantagh bagels to everyone whether ur new to the area or not you should visit wantagh bagels and ask for ayisha at the counter. With her she will give u amazing service and make ur experience there a 10 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagel
Moe Wahab
They have delicious new hand-rolled bagels. They taste amazing, bagels are fresh and they are nice to look at as well! Thank you to Ayisha at the front counter for the excellent customer service. Recommending this spot to all my family and friends.
Fantastic neighbourhood bagel spot!
Wantagh Bagel is hands down one of the best places to grab a fresh, delicious breakfast on Long Island. The bagels are always perfectly chewy on the inside with just the right amount of crisp on the outside. I especially love their bacon egg & cheese on an everything bagel — absolutely hits the spot every time. The staff is friendly, fast, and they keep the line moving even during busy mornings. Prices are fair, and they have a wide variety of cream cheeses and sandwich options. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
January 2025: I absolutely love Wantagh Bagels, and one of the main reasons I keep coming back is because of Genesis! She knows my order by heart and always gets it ready so quickly. Not only is she efficient, but she’s also incredibly friendly, always greeting me with a smile. It’s rare to find such great service along with delicious bagels, but Wantagh Bagels delivers on both fronts every time. Highly recommend!
Edit: April 2025
This place really has gone down hill since genesis is no longer there. Always running out of things to mix into your tea/coffee. I’ve been coming here every day for years and I think I’ll need to change where I get my breakfast before work every morning.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tried Wantagh Bagels after not going for a couple of years. It used to be great and would go all the time. Used to be great food and service and coffee at great prices. It has gone down over the years. The person taking my order had to write it down 3x for a bagel with butter, cream cheese and peanut butter. Waited 25 minutes for 3 bagels when there was only 1 person ahead of us for a simple order. The TV screens are still not hooked and are fogged up and look dirty and the place looks like it not being kept up. Will not be going again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
I went in around 1240. Ish told me they were closed even though they close at 2 PM very mad.
Service: 2
I called to place an order to send someone and the girl on the phone was so patient, helpful and kind. I don't live over there but when I'm in the area I plan to stop by. Thank you so much!
Service: 5
The bagels are so delicious and fresh. They recently started selling donuts and they are SO good. The staff there are very friendly, especially Ayisha and Nicole in the front. Their customer service is excellent. Recommend everyone to go here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent breakfast option in Wantagh. Pretty close to awesome
Vegetarian options: There are decent vegetarian options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Muffin, Pastries, Bagel
Almost impossible to get someone to help you….Even if you are the ONLY person waiting. This has happened to me multiple times. Today, I was told twice by the same woman that she would be right with me as she walked away from the counter to do something else. I walked out after that. How about having a person specifically assigned to work the counter? And honestly the variety of bagels and spreads is quite mediocre compared to Town Bagel located a half mile away. This business has truly gone downhill
Wantagh Bagels has amazing bagels/food and I highly recommend them.
Vegetarian options: should have vegan products too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagel
Restaurantji Recommends
The bagels are great but let me tell you about the SALADS. Tasty, fresh and I just love the flavor!!! Coffee is good just all around outstanding! Definitely recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best bagels I have eaten so far . Very soft with great quality and taste ?
First and foremost it was an amazing experience the bagels were so fresh and warm and tasted wonderful they were hand rolled bagels that looked delicious. Ayisha helped me at the front counter with some great suggestions to order off of the menu, she also told me about the variety of food they had. She made my bacon egg and cheese sandwich taste absolutely amazing I mean the bacon was crispy the eggs were cooked to perfection and the cheese was melted perfectly it reminded me of a real city bacon egg and cheese I highly recommend wantagh bagels to everyone whether ur new to the area or not you should visit wantagh bagels and ask for ayisha at the counter. With her she will give u amazing service and make ur experience there a 10 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagel
They have delicious new hand-rolled bagels. They taste amazing, bagels are fresh and they are nice to look at as well! Thank you to Ayisha at the front counter for the excellent customer service. Recommending this spot to all my family and friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels, Muffin, Cheese Danish, blt Croissant, Bagel
I got the special bagel and coffee this morning. The food was great and service was excellent…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...