One of the best bagels I have eaten so far . Very soft with great quality and taste ?
Christian Ortiz
First and foremost it was an amazing experience the bagels were so fresh and warm and tasted wonderful they were hand rolled bagels that looked delicious. Ayisha helped me at the front counter with some great suggestions to order off of the menu, she also told me about the variety of food they had. She made my bacon egg and cheese sandwich taste absolutely amazing I mean the bacon was crispy the eggs were cooked to perfection and the cheese was melted perfectly it reminded me of a real city bacon egg and cheese I highly recommend wantagh bagels to everyone whether ur new to the area or not you should visit wantagh bagels and ask for ayisha at the counter. With her she will give u amazing service and make ur experience there a 10 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagel
Moe Wahab
They have delicious new hand-rolled bagels. They taste amazing, bagels are fresh and they are nice to look at as well! Thank you to Ayisha at the front counter for the excellent customer service. Recommending this spot to all my family and friends.
I got the special bagel and coffee this morning. The food was great and service was excellent…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BG E
Bagels are soft and delicious, great customer service. They have sweets as well as coffee, iced. A little bit of everything
Corey Nahman
Bagels are good, yes. It’s a little run down. Could use a spiffing up.
Rod Falace
I love getting my breakfast there and bagels there great service, food and price. Love this place ?
Sue M
So my brother's go to bagel place closed recently in Wantagh so with my visit, he bought bagels from Wantagh Bagels. He was the only customer on a Sunday AM which is odd. The bagels were really large but not chewy enough, too soft. Also pricey, much more expensive than what the last TripAdvisor reviewer said was the pricing in March 2022, closer to double the price mentioned. We won't be back.
Salman Hamirani
Great place. Super reasonable. Everything Cream cheese bagel with a coffee in under $4.50!! Unreal!And it was delicious too! Highly recommended.
Jake B
Awesome bagel store. Lots of options to choose from
I don’t know where to start other than I will never go here again. I’ll stick with town bagel or seaford bagel. Placed an online order 3hrs before I was to pickup. They had zero macaroni salad and not even a hamburger. Paid in advance so they had to refund me the cash which they did. Ordered a cheese danish and when I got home this danish must’ve been at least 1-2 weeks old. Could’ve broken a window with it. For a modern bagel store with a half way decent menu to not have half of what I ordered and stale danish this is completely unacceptable.Plenty of better bagel stores in the areaSave your money and go elsewhere or you’ll be disappointed!!!!!They’re response, come back and we’ll refund u the moneyCompletely unacceptableWill never return
Ayaan Khan
I love the bagels at that place! They're always fresh and delicious. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the service is quick. Ayisha and Nicole are very friendly and quick with your orders. The store is clean and well-organized. I highly recommend trying the everything bagel with cream cheese.
A A
Love the bagels there! If you don't like bagels, they also have dessert, muffins, brownies and cookies which are equally as delectable and fresh. All-inclusive breakfast business with excellent customer service; when I go in, Ayisha and Nicole already have my order ready. Overall, the food is delicious. Would suggest to all of my family and friends.
Samantha Nobile
This is our go to spot! It's cheaper than a lot of the bagel stores in the area and the quality is just as good. You can order ahead online or by phone. I had to order bagels, cut and individually wrapped for an event and they did it in 30 minutes. Reliable!
Nick F.
Good bagels. Quick counter service. Friendly. Clean. Conveniently located close to the parkway and across from Causeway Tackle.Great breakfast stop when picking up supplies before fishing.
One of the best bagels I have eaten so far . Very soft with great quality and taste ?
First and foremost it was an amazing experience the bagels were so fresh and warm and tasted wonderful they were hand rolled bagels that looked delicious. Ayisha helped me at the front counter with some great suggestions to order off of the menu, she also told me about the variety of food they had. She made my bacon egg and cheese sandwich taste absolutely amazing I mean the bacon was crispy the eggs were cooked to perfection and the cheese was melted perfectly it reminded me of a real city bacon egg and cheese I highly recommend wantagh bagels to everyone whether ur new to the area or not you should visit wantagh bagels and ask for ayisha at the counter. With her she will give u amazing service and make ur experience there a 10 out of 10.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bagel
They have delicious new hand-rolled bagels. They taste amazing, bagels are fresh and they are nice to look at as well! Thank you to Ayisha at the front counter for the excellent customer service. Recommending this spot to all my family and friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels, Muffin, Cheese Danish, blt Croissant, Bagel
I got the special bagel and coffee this morning. The food was great and service was excellent…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bagels are soft and delicious, great customer service. They have sweets as well as coffee, iced. A little bit of everything
Bagels are good, yes. It’s a little run down. Could use a spiffing up.
I love getting my breakfast there and bagels there great service, food and price. Love this place ?
So my brother's go to bagel place closed recently in Wantagh so with my visit, he bought bagels from Wantagh Bagels. He was the only customer on a Sunday AM which is odd. The bagels were really large but not chewy enough, too soft. Also pricey, much more expensive than what the last TripAdvisor reviewer said was the pricing in March 2022, closer to double the price mentioned. We won't be back.
Great place. Super reasonable. Everything Cream cheese bagel with a coffee in under $4.50!! Unreal!And it was delicious too! Highly recommended.
Awesome bagel store. Lots of options to choose from
Restaurantji Recommends
I don’t know where to start other than I will never go here again. I’ll stick with town bagel or seaford bagel. Placed an online order 3hrs before I was to pickup. They had zero macaroni salad and not even a hamburger. Paid in advance so they had to refund me the cash which they did. Ordered a cheese danish and when I got home this danish must’ve been at least 1-2 weeks old. Could’ve broken a window with it. For a modern bagel store with a half way decent menu to not have half of what I ordered and stale danish this is completely unacceptable.Plenty of better bagel stores in the areaSave your money and go elsewhere or you’ll be disappointed!!!!!They’re response, come back and we’ll refund u the moneyCompletely unacceptableWill never return
I love the bagels at that place! They're always fresh and delicious. The staff is friendly and helpful, and the service is quick. Ayisha and Nicole are very friendly and quick with your orders. The store is clean and well-organized. I highly recommend trying the everything bagel with cream cheese.
Love the bagels there! If you don't like bagels, they also have dessert, muffins, brownies and cookies which are equally as delectable and fresh. All-inclusive breakfast business with excellent customer service; when I go in, Ayisha and Nicole already have my order ready. Overall, the food is delicious. Would suggest to all of my family and friends.
This is our go to spot! It's cheaper than a lot of the bagel stores in the area and the quality is just as good. You can order ahead online or by phone. I had to order bagels, cut and individually wrapped for an event and they did it in 30 minutes. Reliable!
Good bagels. Quick counter service. Friendly. Clean. Conveniently located close to the parkway and across from Causeway Tackle.Great breakfast stop when picking up supplies before fishing.