I just tried to make it order and the owner was very rude. The website says they close at 11p and I tried to make it order at 9:30. When I said I'd like to make a order for pickup and want a square pizza, he was short and said they were closing in 10 minutes and he's not making a square pizza. Extremely short and rude. Bad
Service: 1
Maddalena Petrillo
I love the village feel of the place. Plus Pete is just a real stand up guy. Food is always hot, not greasy, exceptional value!Just wish he'd make me a calzone ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagon Wheel Pizza, Spaghetti and Meatballs, Round Cheese Pizza Slice, Baked Penne with Melted Cheese, Garlic Bread, Meatball & Peppers Hero, Sausage Hero, Black Olives Pizza, Real Chicken Parmigiana Hero, Cheese Pizza, Side of Sausage, Peppers Pizza, Mixed Cold Cuts, Real Chicken Parmigiana & Spaghetti, Adam Special, Eggplant Parmigiana & Spaghetti, Chicken Pizza, Manicotti Sauce & Melted Cheese, Sausage Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Marisa M.
Old school pizzeria with handmade pizza by the owner. We thoroughly enjoyed our pizza and can't wait to go back.
Marcella A.
This is my 2nd time in here and I absolutely love the pizza. It's very delicious and it's always very tasty. The owner is really nice. From the outside it looks as if it's closed . I would suggest brightening up the windows. If you plan to get pizza here you'll need to pay with cash unless he has a ATM in the restaurant. Other then that very delicious pizza.
Daryl Thorpe
Pleasantly surprised!Discovered the Wagon Wheel on my way to another (unnamed) pizza place. Pizza was flavorful, the crust was nice and crispy.Definitely will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagon Wheel Pizza
Jessica Balascio
Great place!!! I highly recommend. Pete's literally the best human ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sean Motise
The Wagon Wheel restaurant has been in downtown Wappingers Falls for a very long time.This landmark is a classic no frills restaurant that gets straight to the point.The owner Pete makes really good pizza. Simple, not gourmet pizza, the way they used to make it and still do 40 years later. The crust is crispy, not soggy like the other place that's across the street.His pizza sauce has just the right amount of herbs, sweetness and tang. He is not shy with the toppings either. The prices for his pizza are extremely affordable so you'll get more than your monies worth.The Wagon Wheel also makes delicious pastas that you'll need a box to take the rest home. Generous portions from an owner with a generous heart to serve the best pizza and pasta to his loyal and new customers.Pete's mission is to give his customers the best quality food for the best price. Stop in and try the best pizza anywhere. You'll be glad you did.When I'm back in Wappingers Falls I'll be headed to Wagon Wheel pizza for a walk down memory lane.Until next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagon Wheel Pizza, Meatball
Marco Lanzi
I've only had plain pies from here and never anything else on the menu but I would definitely say this place makes some good pizza. Cooked perfectly and the sauce was great. Give this place a try !
Jake Phillips
I don’t know why, but the kids wanted to try Dominos Pizza; I haven’t had it myself in 20 years and said OK. Well, it was a mistake. Everyone agrees Wagon Wheel makes a much better pizza. Love you Pete!!!Parking: The Village of Wappingers Falls, albeit operating with a $25 million dollar deficit, does NOT charge for public parking and shouldn’t.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie Truncali
The pizza is amazing. Crispy with a fluffy crust. No bland pizza sauce here. Flavorful and delicious. The owner Pizza Pete is friendly and has a great sense of humor. Authentic New York style pizza. Best pizza west of Italy!!!!
The staffs were very nice and friendly. I always visited with kids, and the staffs already remembered what we want to order.We like their pizza, best in town. The crust is light and fluffy. The sauce is just right for us, not too sour, not too acidic taste.They talked friendly with customers. It make me feel so warm and friendly when I dine in there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ralph bowman
Actually had the pizza at "Coup" the champagne bar next door. There is a pass thru in the wall for pizza.Great atmosphere.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Elvis Taylor
Excellent pizza it's better than ya grandma's in Italy
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fernando John DaCunha
We ordered a mushroom pie and two meat lover slices, everything was excellent. The sauce isn't acidic and the crust is light and fluffy. Tasted great reheated as well. The owner is friendly and has been in the area for decades. Cash only but there is an ATM on site. I highly recommend this spot.
I just tried to make it order and the owner was very rude. The website says they close at 11p and I tried to make it order at 9:30. When I said I'd like to make a order for pickup and want a square pizza, he was short and said they were closing in 10 minutes and he's not making a square pizza. Extremely short and rude. Bad
Service: 1
I love the village feel of the place. Plus Pete is just a real stand up guy. Food is always hot, not greasy, exceptional value!Just wish he'd make me a calzone ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagon Wheel Pizza, Spaghetti and Meatballs, Round Cheese Pizza Slice, Baked Penne with Melted Cheese, Garlic Bread, Meatball & Peppers Hero, Sausage Hero, Black Olives Pizza, Real Chicken Parmigiana Hero, Cheese Pizza, Side of Sausage, Peppers Pizza, Mixed Cold Cuts, Real Chicken Parmigiana & Spaghetti, Adam Special, Eggplant Parmigiana & Spaghetti, Chicken Pizza, Manicotti Sauce & Melted Cheese, Sausage Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Old school pizzeria with handmade pizza by the owner. We thoroughly enjoyed our pizza and can't wait to go back.
This is my 2nd time in here and I absolutely love the pizza. It's very delicious and it's always very tasty. The owner is really nice. From the outside it looks as if it's closed . I would suggest brightening up the windows. If you plan to get pizza here you'll need to pay with cash unless he has a ATM in the restaurant. Other then that very delicious pizza.
Pleasantly surprised!Discovered the Wagon Wheel on my way to another (unnamed) pizza place. Pizza was flavorful, the crust was nice and crispy.Definitely will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagon Wheel Pizza
Great place!!! I highly recommend. Pete's literally the best human ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Wagon Wheel restaurant has been in downtown Wappingers Falls for a very long time.This landmark is a classic no frills restaurant that gets straight to the point.The owner Pete makes really good pizza. Simple, not gourmet pizza, the way they used to make it and still do 40 years later. The crust is crispy, not soggy like the other place that's across the street.His pizza sauce has just the right amount of herbs, sweetness and tang. He is not shy with the toppings either. The prices for his pizza are extremely affordable so you'll get more than your monies worth.The Wagon Wheel also makes delicious pastas that you'll need a box to take the rest home. Generous portions from an owner with a generous heart to serve the best pizza and pasta to his loyal and new customers.Pete's mission is to give his customers the best quality food for the best price. Stop in and try the best pizza anywhere. You'll be glad you did.When I'm back in Wappingers Falls I'll be headed to Wagon Wheel pizza for a walk down memory lane.Until next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagon Wheel Pizza, Meatball
I've only had plain pies from here and never anything else on the menu but I would definitely say this place makes some good pizza. Cooked perfectly and the sauce was great. Give this place a try !
I don’t know why, but the kids wanted to try Dominos Pizza; I haven’t had it myself in 20 years and said OK. Well, it was a mistake. Everyone agrees Wagon Wheel makes a much better pizza. Love you Pete!!!Parking: The Village of Wappingers Falls, albeit operating with a $25 million dollar deficit, does NOT charge for public parking and shouldn’t.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is amazing. Crispy with a fluffy crust. No bland pizza sauce here. Flavorful and delicious. The owner Pizza Pete is friendly and has a great sense of humor. Authentic New York style pizza. Best pizza west of Italy!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The staffs were very nice and friendly. I always visited with kids, and the staffs already remembered what we want to order.We like their pizza, best in town. The crust is light and fluffy. The sauce is just right for us, not too sour, not too acidic taste.They talked friendly with customers. It make me feel so warm and friendly when I dine in there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Actually had the pizza at "Coup" the champagne bar next door. There is a pass thru in the wall for pizza.Great atmosphere.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Excellent pizza it's better than ya grandma's in Italy
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a mushroom pie and two meat lover slices, everything was excellent. The sauce isn't acidic and the crust is light and fluffy. Tasted great reheated as well. The owner is friendly and has been in the area for decades. Cash only but there is an ATM on site. I highly recommend this spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza! Chicken cutlet pizza, all the way!