Wagon Wheel Pizza

$ • Pizza, Wine Bars

Hours today·

About Wagon Wheel Pizza

The Wagon Wheel Pizza is a well-known, no-frills restaurant that has been a landmark in downtown Wappingers Falls for many years. The owner is celebrated for his exceptional pizza, which is always hot, not greasy, and offers great value. The crust is crispy, and the pizza sauce has a perfect balance of herbs, sweetness, and tang. The owner is generous with the toppings, and the prices are very affordable, making sure customers get more than their money's worth.

The restaurant also serves up delicious pastas with generous portions. Customers have praised the multi-generation quality of the pizza, noting that it tastes amazing and is a return to the old-style, authentic pizza. The owner makes his own dough and sauce each morning, avoiding the oily, cardboard-like pizza that many have learned to accept elsewhere. His pizza has a unique style with lots of good toppings, and the favorite is pepperoni, which is described as really good and delicious.

The Wagon Wheel has a friendly, village-like atmosphere, and the owner is known to be very welcoming and friendly to both loyal and new customers. Customers also praise the crispy crust, flavorful sauce, good cheese, and great prices. Overall, the Wagon Wheel Pizza is a beloved local spot that offers a classic, no-frills dining experience with great food and exceptional value.

Menu

Add a Menu
Wagon Wheel Pizza Menu
Wagon Wheel Pizza Menu

Customers' Favorites

Photos

Add a Photo
Wagon Wheel Pizza
Wagon Wheel Pizza
View All Photos

Wagon Wheel Pizza Reviews

4.8
111 ratings
5
94%
4
3%
1
3%
Food
4.9
Atmosphere
4.7
Service
4.8

Share your opinion about Wagon Wheel Pizza

Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Hot and delicious with a crispy crust
Excellent slice of pizza highly recommend
The owner is there and always making sure things are good. Will return very soon!!
Great pizza and the owner is a character and I mean that as a compliment. He's no BS makes good food, no frills just quality stuff. Reminds me of the good old days when I step inside this place and I enjoy that vibe!

Read All Reviews(102)

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 4 - 10PM
Wednesday 4 - 10PM
Thursday 4 - 10PM
Friday 3 - 11PM
Saturday 11AM - 11PM
Sunday 4 - 10PM
Updated on: