Stefano's Pizzeria (New York Style)
12 N Main St, Warsaw
(585) 228-1246
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pizza and Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Finger
NY Style Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Chicken Wings
10 Wings
Roll
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
If your going threw warsaw ny and your looking for pizza, Stefano's is the place! Their pizza is light and airy, with a nice crisp crust. With slight reminiscence of the chef boyardee pizza momma used to make in the 70's . The best pizza I had in year's. I highly recommend them. Thank you Stefano's!
Not sure if it was the time we came in which was around 1-2pm but it was empty. Bathroom was a bit iffy, maybe someone came before us and had an issue. The place is very old Timey style. Lots of antiques to show the history of New York. Pizza was really delicious straight out of the oven. A bit pricey so we opted for a small size ‘12 and I got pepperoni on it. Only one man working and he ran the whole restaurant himself. Very kind man.
I’m from NYC and pizza...
I’m from NYC and pizza...
Have been waiting 5 yrs to get the family special. Best pizza, wings and antipasto salad. First thing on the list once we moved back to NY. Wish there was one in Rochester had to have it picked up and delivered.
You May Also Like
Amber Lantern Brewing Company - 44 N Main St
![]()
Brewery, Pubs, American, New American, Pet Friendly
Laurie's Restaurant - 46 N Main St
![]()
American
Vertical Cafe - 18 W Buffalo St
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Wraps