The Bakery at ML Cakes and Catering

11461 State Rte 21, Wayland
(585) 213-4274

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Wendy S

(This is for off-site catering so there is no rating for atmosphere . . .)

In April 2026 we had a need for an indoor venue and catering for a post-funeral services event in Wayland. Although a native, I had left long ago and I was coordinating this from 600 miles away. Melissa and her catering business were recommended to us by the venue, and it was a perfect match. We were impressed every step of the way as we looked to serve about 50 people.

Procuring / providing services in small town America can be challenging (for clients and for the businesses) so I'm pleased to give 5 STARS + to our catering experience. Melissa is a solid communicator and was timely in her responses. Her culinary education and experience shown through on the day of the event. The variety of her offerings was impressive. She is easy to work with; she was flexible and creative and is extremely hard working. No attitude, no drama. Her prices were VERY reasonable/fair. She was very generous in that I know she provided more food than we ordered. We and the attendees were extremely impressed with the notable offerings. The food and the desserts were perfect and the day came off without a hitch despite a big rain she had to work with. Thank you Melissa!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda Howe

Absolutely beautiful cake, well done, on theme and delicious. Would recommend and use again.

Mama Paige. USA

A great little place to stop in and grab something before jumping on the highway or heading to the park.
We picked up breakfast.We picked up snacks and we picked up dessert for the holiday!! YUM!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer S. Shearer

My husband was working in the area and found this wonderful bakery. He brought home some cupcakes. They were all delicious but the raspberry ones were fabulous.

benjamin noble

Grabbed some fresh bread ๐Ÿž and coffee โ˜• was great little spot!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

P H

Only reason I gave 4 stars is they were almost out of food so I did get something I wouldnโ€™t have gotten so we could have a bigger breakfast. Two of the four pastries were amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Penny Votypka

Great cupcakes for Daves birthday. Marble swirl filled with raspberry filling! Always a great experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katie Onderdonk

Best cake tasting ever! Melissa is a wonderful baker and her bakery is so cute. She was friendly, and made it very easy to talk to her about my needs for my specific diet needs. She answered every question we had and helped us with our menu for catering our wedding. She became our number one pick for cake and catering all in one! She will always be our go to for our bakery/ catering needs! Well done Melissa!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Casey Wright

A small unassuming placd with a diner vibe in the best way, the best French toast I've had in a while-possibly ever- made with their own in house bread. Also tried the home fries and bacon, all perfectly cooked. Molasses cookie was good too, bought a selection of baked goods to take home for later too. Owner was running the register and greeted several customers by name, just a really good small town place. I was just passing through but I'll definitely stop if I come this way again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Campbell Williams

I had never been here before and ordered the Father's Day package. We celebrated today ( Sat.). The food was amazing! The brisket was melt in your mouth tender and had amazing flavor, the pork was also so tender and the bbq sauce they sent very tasty. They sent amazing rolls. The baked beans and Mac and cheese were great! And let's not forget get the brownies...delightful! Reasonable price! Highly recommend!

Theresa Schettine McIntyre

Finally tried the shrimp tacos! Beyond good, EXCEPTIONAL! Loved the combination of flavors. Thank you!

Susan Cosgriff

Delicious homemade food and bakery items. A real gem.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Marie GoldenGurl

I just ate Breakfast here. The food was amazing. The restaurant was very clean and amazing customer service.

Mary Johnson

This is an awesome place. Food is always fresh and very good. A definite place to stop.

Jar Head USMC

This lovely place is a gem the woman that runs it is incredible,get over there ...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...

The Bakery at ML Cakes and Catering

11461 State Rte 21, Wayland, NY 14572
(585) 213-4274