Food was delicious, service was great ! Nice atmosphere, we were there for 2hours with friends and never felt rushed .. great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer Cronin (Jen)
Excellent and amazing food!! The decor is absolutely beautiful and the servers were polite and professional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
amanda phillips
Went to Brody’s for the first time last night. All of the staff was very friendly. The food was absolutely amazing! Everything was cooked perfectly, the desserts were delicious! Brody’s will be our new date night restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiffany Labarbera
The food was pretty good.Appetizers and dinners came out at scattered times. Some people had their whole meal already when others didn’t even have their appetizers yet.The atmosphere was uncomfortable enough to mention it on here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Wade Braman
We love Brody's on the Bay! Its so close to us and the food is always great! We mostly get takeout but when we dine in, our favorite thing to do is sit by the windows facing Irondequoit bay. The views are awesome!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wade Braman
We love Brody’s on the Bay! It’s so close to us and the food is always great. We mostly get takeout but when we dine in, our favorite thing to do is sit by the windows facing I bay. The views are awesome! We love the fish fry’s!
jen jansen
Went here tonight with a friend for a few cocktails and either apps or dinner. It's a Saturday night at 630 and the place is dead. (Good and bad). Good for us to be seated quickly, bad because...well, it's a Saturday night and its not busy which makes me wonder what the deal is. Anyways, waitress was pretty quick to come over and take our drink order. We both ordered the "Pomegranate smash" drink. ($12). It tasted like they forgot the alcohol in it. We both decided to get the chicken quesadilla which came with sour cream and guacamole. The food came out pretty quickly. No guacamole. Told the waitress when she came back. She said she was sorry and went back to get some. Came back and said they were out. No big deal. Ordered a margarita next. Oddly enough had pretty much the same ingredients in it, except for the liquor that the "Pomegranate smash" had.The drinks were just ok, the quesadillas were pretty good but it's pretty hard to mess those up. We spend almost $100 on quesadillas and 2 mediocre drinks. Really nice atmosphere but unfortunately I don't think I will be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Jamie Catalano
We had our Vital Signs company holiday party for the second year in a row this past weekend at Brody's and it was excellent!! Samantha and Tyler took great care of us, the food was delicious, and everyone had such a great time! Thank you Brodys on the Bay for everything!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Bradley
Great beer selection & the prime rib melt is AWESOME!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bot Macarthur
I have tried this place before and it always has the same slow service and mediocre, yet pricey menu options. I am unsure how this establishment survives with a nearly empty parking lot most nights. I think it's time to give it up already...
First time here! Came to celebrate my SO's birthday. The portions were large and the food was fantastic! Our waitress recommended the Prime Rib and my eyes lit up when it came out... now I can't move. Thank you for a wonderful dinner. We will be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Crawford
A group of seven were seated where we had a great view of the Lake Ontario Bay. Our waiter, Mike, did an excellent job of attending to details. The food was very tasty and made to order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lovely Rotten
Relaxed atmosphere, great staff, gorgeous views, great food. Prepare for a long wait once seated, allowing you to relax with drinks and friends, take in the great vistas of the bay, or cheer your sporting squadron on huge flat-screens.The brick bread is a must! Brunch is a great treat on the weekend. Busy nights are bustling with activity and great energy.
We drove from about 40 minutes away. First time there. We went on a Sunday. First of all, they didn’t have the majority of plates listed on menu. Not to mention they gave us plastic cups. That was the first in our family. We paid over $120 + for food. We ordered the fried calamari for appetizer, and it was tough and it seems like it was done the day before. I ordered a pizza and it was so burnt I couldn’t even taste it. The pizza also had lemon pieces, and was so flat it looked like someone sat on it. Didn’t eat it. My son had a pasta with shrimp and calamari and it looked as they dumped half of a canned sauce on his pasta with no flavor. Weirdly enough, it still managed to have water in it. My son didn’t eat his food either. My daughter ordered a pasta with meat balls and she initially requested it be warmed because it was cold. She also explained it to have hard pasta. She took it home only because she was starving. Only ate the meat balls. Don’t waste your money here. We left hungry and needed to stop for additional food. Next time we try the other place down the road. See the picture below of my daughters dump of sauce in her order. This place was beautiful and nicely decorated but that’s where it ends. The server tried to keep up but they are clearly understaffed. The server was nice and apologized for the mistakes. I wish they would have tried to rectify the issue but they didn’t. We didn’t eat and yet they charged us the $$$ bill. This is the time where you trust the bad reviews…save your money and do NOT come here.
Tee K
Just ok. Beautiful space, but lack of staff. Beer selection sub par and taps not fresh. We didn't eat.
Food was delicious, service was great ! Nice atmosphere, we were there for 2hours with friends and never felt rushed .. great experience
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent and amazing food!! The decor is absolutely beautiful and the servers were polite and professional.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went to Brody’s for the first time last night. All of the staff was very friendly. The food was absolutely amazing! Everything was cooked perfectly, the desserts were delicious! Brody’s will be our new date night restaurant.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was pretty good.Appetizers and dinners came out at scattered times. Some people had their whole meal already when others didn’t even have their appetizers yet.The atmosphere was uncomfortable enough to mention it on here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
We love Brody's on the Bay! Its so close to us and the food is always great! We mostly get takeout but when we dine in, our favorite thing to do is sit by the windows facing Irondequoit bay. The views are awesome!
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love Brody’s on the Bay! It’s so close to us and the food is always great. We mostly get takeout but when we dine in, our favorite thing to do is sit by the windows facing I bay. The views are awesome! We love the fish fry’s!
Went here tonight with a friend for a few cocktails and either apps or dinner. It's a Saturday night at 630 and the place is dead. (Good and bad). Good for us to be seated quickly, bad because...well, it's a Saturday night and its not busy which makes me wonder what the deal is. Anyways, waitress was pretty quick to come over and take our drink order. We both ordered the "Pomegranate smash" drink. ($12). It tasted like they forgot the alcohol in it. We both decided to get the chicken quesadilla which came with sour cream and guacamole. The food came out pretty quickly. No guacamole. Told the waitress when she came back. She said she was sorry and went back to get some. Came back and said they were out. No big deal. Ordered a margarita next. Oddly enough had pretty much the same ingredients in it, except for the liquor that the "Pomegranate smash" had.The drinks were just ok, the quesadillas were pretty good but it's pretty hard to mess those up. We spend almost $100 on quesadillas and 2 mediocre drinks. Really nice atmosphere but unfortunately I don't think I will be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
We had our Vital Signs company holiday party for the second year in a row this past weekend at Brody's and it was excellent!! Samantha and Tyler took great care of us, the food was delicious, and everyone had such a great time! Thank you Brodys on the Bay for everything!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great beer selection & the prime rib melt is AWESOME!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have tried this place before and it always has the same slow service and mediocre, yet pricey menu options. I am unsure how this establishment survives with a nearly empty parking lot most nights. I think it's time to give it up already...
Restaurantji Recommends
First time here! Came to celebrate my SO's birthday. The portions were large and the food was fantastic! Our waitress recommended the Prime Rib and my eyes lit up when it came out... now I can't move. Thank you for a wonderful dinner. We will be back soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A group of seven were seated where we had a great view of the Lake Ontario Bay. Our waiter, Mike, did an excellent job of attending to details. The food was very tasty and made to order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Relaxed atmosphere, great staff, gorgeous views, great food. Prepare for a long wait once seated, allowing you to relax with drinks and friends, take in the great vistas of the bay, or cheer your sporting squadron on huge flat-screens.The brick bread is a must! Brunch is a great treat on the weekend. Busy nights are bustling with activity and great energy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brick Bread, Brick Oven Wings, Cheeseburger
We drove from about 40 minutes away. First time there. We went on a Sunday. First of all, they didn’t have the majority of plates listed on menu. Not to mention they gave us plastic cups. That was the first in our family. We paid over $120 + for food. We ordered the fried calamari for appetizer, and it was tough and it seems like it was done the day before. I ordered a pizza and it was so burnt I couldn’t even taste it. The pizza also had lemon pieces, and was so flat it looked like someone sat on it. Didn’t eat it. My son had a pasta with shrimp and calamari and it looked as they dumped half of a canned sauce on his pasta with no flavor. Weirdly enough, it still managed to have water in it. My son didn’t eat his food either. My daughter ordered a pasta with meat balls and she initially requested it be warmed because it was cold. She also explained it to have hard pasta. She took it home only because she was starving. Only ate the meat balls. Don’t waste your money here. We left hungry and needed to stop for additional food. Next time we try the other place down the road. See the picture below of my daughters dump of sauce in her order. This place was beautiful and nicely decorated but that’s where it ends. The server tried to keep up but they are clearly understaffed. The server was nice and apologized for the mistakes. I wish they would have tried to rectify the issue but they didn’t. We didn’t eat and yet they charged us the $$$ bill. This is the time where you trust the bad reviews…save your money and do NOT come here.
Just ok. Beautiful space, but lack of staff. Beer selection sub par and taps not fresh. We didn't eat.
Atmosphere: 2
Service: 2