Carl's Pizza Kitchen

9 South Ave, Webster
(585) 236-1819

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Wade Braman

I don’t know how else to put it, other than they make really damn good food. Large portions, excellent taste. To give you an example, there buffalo chicken pizza is by far the best version of it, my family or friends have ever had. The calzones are HUGE and full of toppings. I could go on and on. Just know you’re getting a really high quality product, that tastes damn good, and is made by some great people, that really are passionate about what they do!

Vivian Roseto

I was at Burke's having a cocktail, I went next door to order a sheet pizza for the Superbowl.... 1/2 meat and 1/2 veg....the owner was so nice and they even delivered the pizza next door to the bar for me! It was yummy!!! I was impressed and will be going back for sure!!! :)

Freddie Smith

The wings were good, but they had zero spice. We got 4 pizzas and they all tasted very doughy. The chicken buffalo was not spicy at all.

Keenan Keenan R

This place is legit…country sweet chicken pizza one of my favorites. Same with their garlic parm traditional wings/boneless. Good boneless wings too, not the normal cheap junk at other places. Good app’s and desert items I saw on there too. Stopped in there once, nice people who work there and their delivery drivers are very kind.I hope to see this place thrive for a long time.

Brooke Mayne

I wish I could give them 10 stars I ordered a pizza dinner last night it was hot it was president was actually delicious and the bread doubt it it’s just like I just came out of the oven lots of cheese that’s a green peppers and onions like I wanted llama I will be ordering again and the service is very friendly

William Spicer

I order from Florida to deliver to my sister in Webster. Carl is always very accommodating and friendly, she loves the food, delicious soups and Mac and cheese. Highly recommend!Sgtusmc

Emily B

The food is always so tasty and fresh! AND their fries are the best fries I’ve ever had in my life, so crispy and perfect

Gianna Giudice

I called to ask about last minute catering for the next day and didn’t realize they were closed on Mondays. The owner was still more than happy to go in and fulfill this order for me! Not only was I impressed by the excellent service, but the food was absolutely incredible! Every single person at the event I hosted commented on how amazing the food was. This place will definitely not disappoint, and I’d highly recommend to anyone looking to get some food catered!

Vegetarian options: Eggplant parm was DELICIOUS!

Dan Cignarale

They didnt put sausage on my one pizza and they didnt cook it it well done. I usually wouldnt make a stink because the pizza is pretty good, but 55 bucks for a large and a medium pizza is a bit pricey and for those prices you better not screw up.

emily

This is our favorite pizza place in Webster. If you’re looking for a delicious thin crust NY style pizza—look no further! We’ve been here several times and the pizza has been perfect every single time. I can tell the owners really care about what they do!My father passed away recently and this was his favorite place too. We just ordered a pizza from here tonight to share and although it was weird to eat it without him, it was just as delicious as usual!

Anthony Trimboli

Great pizza shop. Family owned, reasonable prices and amazing food. I haven't had one food item from here that I haven't disliked. Staff is always super friendly and accommodating. Always my go to pizza shop when I'm craving pizza

Dan K

This place is great! Made a breakfast pizza for us and HOLY MOLY. Didn't skimp on anything. Good prices and friendly service. Will be a customer again

CJ Derby Whalen

Found a hidden pizza and wing gem in Webster NY. Carl's Pizza Kitchen is delcious. Best crust ever. Wings cooked to perfection. Homemade blue cheese. Yum. 5 ? ? ⭐️ ? ?

Robert Schrack

Hands down, the best shop on the east side. Awesome pizza, love the Cajun wings, great delivery. This place is the best!

Peter Pankiw

The owner is awesome. Best steak sub my wife has ever had. Meatball sub was great. Pizza was on point. The $20 sub they have was delicious and u can only eat half. This is my new place to get food! #supportlocal

Loading...