Low key Italian restaurant. Not fancy, not overpriced. Just delicious food made by people that know what they're doing.
Spencer Wright
The experience was a little different because you order at the counter, when you walk in, then sit down. Overall, it was a more chill Olive Garden. We'll definitely go back.
Jacob Smith
Fantastic classic dishes and spins on classic Italian. If you’re a seafood lover, highly recommend the seafood Antoinette! Excellent catering and an even better family. 10/10 would absolutely trust them to cater any event.
Tammy Leavy
Just called tonight 5/17 at 6:30pm to place and order and they told me they are not taking any more orders tonight. They are open until 8pm. WHAT is going on? Won't be ordering again!
Molly Kearns
Food is always amazing. The Webster Honeyman dish is out of this world good!
Salvatore Tumminelli
This place has easily become a Webster staple. It's hard to go just a few days without craving a meal off their delicious menu. Can't beat the prices too!
Alan White
This place is one of the best italian spots around. The French sauce it unbelievable and my personal favorite is the chicken riggies the house is on the spicy side but if thats what you like definitely give it a try. And the fresh bread with garlic butter can't stress enough how good it is. Can't wait to try everything on the menu!!!!
Korey Corpus
10/10. Great people and even better food! Normally get chicken parm from here but had the g-pit plate tonight. 10/10 would recommend giving it a try!
Christopher Jocolano
Not much of sit down dining. Looks to be mostly take out. But, the food was EXCELLENT! Very nice people working there too.
Debora Goessmann
A wonderful dining experience that everyone should try ! Delicious food exceeding my expectations every time ! ( just like nonni’s) … warm and inviting with impeccable and attentive service ! Will definitely be back !
I just can't say enough about this place. The food was Excellent. Tonia and Tommy you have the best Italian food in Rochester. All homemade and Delicious. I have been there many of times and always the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mallory Czlonka
The food is absolutely authentically delicious! Great portions , thin chicken cutlets! And separated from the ziti - it was perfect definitely recommend - I didn’t know about this place- family owned generationally!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maryann Quirk
We had the Garlic Pit cater for our parents 50th anniversary and every dish we ordered was delicious! From chicken french to cannolis for dessert we enjoyed every bite. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Catering
H Mitchell
Very good food. Awesome sauce!
Ms. Williams
They just opened up their newly remodeled dining room. The whole place has been redone since covid. Anywho, they only have about 5 tables, but it is handicapped friendly! They're food was better than I remember aaand they have this garlic butter for the bread, YOU BETTER LIKE GARLIC!!! ? Lastly, everything is a la carte! So even if you dine in, it's to go.
Low key Italian restaurant. Not fancy, not overpriced. Just delicious food made by people that know what they're doing.
The experience was a little different because you order at the counter, when you walk in, then sit down. Overall, it was a more chill Olive Garden. We'll definitely go back.
Fantastic classic dishes and spins on classic Italian. If you’re a seafood lover, highly recommend the seafood Antoinette! Excellent catering and an even better family. 10/10 would absolutely trust them to cater any event.
Just called tonight 5/17 at 6:30pm to place and order and they told me they are not taking any more orders tonight. They are open until 8pm. WHAT is going on? Won't be ordering again!
Food is always amazing. The Webster Honeyman dish is out of this world good!
This place has easily become a Webster staple. It's hard to go just a few days without craving a meal off their delicious menu. Can't beat the prices too!
This place is one of the best italian spots around. The French sauce it unbelievable and my personal favorite is the chicken riggies the house is on the spicy side but if thats what you like definitely give it a try. And the fresh bread with garlic butter can't stress enough how good it is. Can't wait to try everything on the menu!!!!
10/10. Great people and even better food! Normally get chicken parm from here but had the g-pit plate tonight. 10/10 would recommend giving it a try!
Not much of sit down dining. Looks to be mostly take out. But, the food was EXCELLENT! Very nice people working there too.
A wonderful dining experience that everyone should try ! Delicious food exceeding my expectations every time ! ( just like nonni’s) … warm and inviting with impeccable and attentive service ! Will definitely be back !
Restaurantji Recommends
I just can't say enough about this place. The food was Excellent. Tonia and Tommy you have the best Italian food in Rochester. All homemade and Delicious. I have been there many of times and always the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is absolutely authentically delicious! Great portions , thin chicken cutlets! And separated from the ziti - it was perfect definitely recommend - I didn’t know about this place- family owned generationally!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had the Garlic Pit cater for our parents 50th anniversary and every dish we ordered was delicious! From chicken french to cannolis for dessert we enjoyed every bite. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Catering
Very good food. Awesome sauce!
They just opened up their newly remodeled dining room. The whole place has been redone since covid. Anywho, they only have about 5 tables, but it is handicapped friendly! They're food was better than I remember aaand they have this garlic butter for the bread, YOU BETTER LIKE GARLIC!!! ?
Lastly, everything is a la carte! So even if you dine in, it's to go.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...