Worst pizza ever absolutely disgusting and staff is so rude and way over priced for pizza that taste like it came out of the microwave
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Oliver Garbacz
Dave Portnoy - you've heard it here first ... it's time to come to Sauly's !Hands down Sauly's Pizza has the best food , the best service , the best prices , and the best overall ambiance. I love a good pizza , and Sauly's nails it! This place has so much more than just outstanding Pizza though , their other options are absolutely delicious as well. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Falafel Balls, Garlic Knots, Spicy Bean Soup, Regular Fries, Fettuccine Alfredo, French Fries, Mac & Cheese, White Pizza, Penne Alla Vodka Pizza 10 Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Vegetable Pizza
Aliza Dalkoff
The owners are the nicest and most honest people in business. Please support this restaurant!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yvonne Gillespie
Ordered eggplant parm as a gift to myself for Christmas because I love eggplant parm. Called the restaurant prior to ordering to ask if the eggplant parm came with pasta. Person on the phone told me that it does I said I am asking because I am on your website and it doesn't say that it comes with pasta. He says it's under the pasta section so it comes with pasta not sure which one it comes with. Place my order via door dash. My food arrives only for me to realize that it does not come with pasta just a tray full of eggplant for $22.00. I contacted the restaurant and said I specially called and asked if the eggplant is served with pasta and was advised that it was I have my food and there's no pasta. Person on the phone was chatting telling me that's how it comes blah blah blah. Nonetheless, I'm never ordering here again.Let's look at the definition of pasta boys and girls:pas·ta/ˈpästə/nouna dish originally from Italy consisting of dough made from durum wheat, extruded or stamped into various shapes and cooked in boiling water, and typically served with a sauce."fresh pasta with pesto, feta cheese, and pine nuts
Eli L.
I went with a friend of mine jeremy perlow, the customer service was so nice, and they let us stay and talk for hours, I ordered 3 regular slices, he orded a onion slice.
Sara Does Life
I jumped off the Southern State, looking for a slice of pizza. I drove past so many fast food options, but I was determined to get a slice of pizza while I was home on Long Island. I got my slice, and it was good, but the star of the night was the sabich and the spicy bean soup. I was so happy!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Jordan Kantor
They have high chairs, and are very kid friendly. Staff is also very friendly.It's not the best slice, but it's a local kosher option, and it's okay.Kid-friendliness: High chairs are available, and the staff makes good accomodations for families.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mike Avulov
Best pizza place I've been to in a long time. The food is fresh and delicious, the atmosphere is very relaxed and homey, and the customer service is incredible. We will definitely be coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ronnie Avivi
Very Good Pizza. Very Nice staff.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Lewyn
Not the best I've ever had, but definitely above average. No complaints!Vegetarian options: Kosher, so you can't have any poultry or beef in restaurant (since kosher rules prohibit cooking meat and dairy together). Not sure I'd anything has fish in it- if not that it's 100 put vegetarian, though of course not vegan.Dietary restrictions: Kosher
Sorry to say but once again another kosher establishment with very poor service. I placed a phone order on the phone and gave them my credit card information. I even gave them the name for the order and they tried to deny that I paid and tried to get my dad to pay again when he picked up the order!! When he asked who took the order, suddenly no-one knew.They also gave my dad an attitude when he questioned who took the order on the phone. I had to get on the phone to confirm my credit card number and let them know I was already charged for the order. The guy tried to tell me I wasn't charged for the order even though they took my credit card information on the phone until he confirmed that I was charged in the system. I am only giving them three stars because the pizza is good but the service is horrible. Its a shame because the owner is a really nice guy and way better than the previous owner when it was Hunki's Pizza. Any other decent establishment would have comped the food or thrown something extra in but because this is a kosher restaurant they don't do that because they don't have competition. This is unreal and embarrassing as a Jewish person myself!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Saul S.
Pizza with black olives and red peppers included a free topping of hair.yuk!regular pizza and fries and soups were fine.
L S
We were in Garden City from Brooklyn and looking for a Kosher Pizza shop,and decided to try Sauly's Pizza. We ordered a spinach and cheese pinwheel and fries. It was the best we ever had. Never had such fresh fries. Prices are like in Brooklyn. Service and staff are superb. We loved Sauly's Pizza so much that we made a 2nd trip from Brooklyn to have Pizza, fries and pinwheel. Highly recommend this place. Keep up the good work SaulyA happy Brooklyn customer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tamtams Rocks
The pizza is really good. It's really cheesy and not to oily. The mozzarella sticks were big and totally worth the money. The cheese was super stretchy and the marinara sauce is better than any I've ever had. Sauly's Pizza is definitely in my top choices of pizza stores and I'm so happy to live so close to one.Vegetarian options: They have a selection of salads plus a salad bar for a make your own salad option.Parking: There is no parking specifically for Sauly's, but there are always a few around the street by them. Either right in front, or around the corner, I can always find one close by.Wheelchair accessibility: There are no stairs leading up to the door and the doorway is wide enough to fit a wheelchair through.
Worst pizza ever absolutely disgusting and staff is so rude and way over priced for pizza that taste like it came out of the microwave
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dave Portnoy - you've heard it here first ... it's time to come to Sauly's !Hands down Sauly's Pizza has the best food , the best service , the best prices , and the best overall ambiance. I love a good pizza , and Sauly's nails it! This place has so much more than just outstanding Pizza though , their other options are absolutely delicious as well. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Falafel Balls, Garlic Knots, Spicy Bean Soup, Regular Fries, Fettuccine Alfredo, French Fries, Mac & Cheese, White Pizza, Penne Alla Vodka Pizza 10 Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Vegetable Pizza
The owners are the nicest and most honest people in business. Please support this restaurant!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered eggplant parm as a gift to myself for Christmas because I love eggplant parm. Called the restaurant prior to ordering to ask if the eggplant parm came with pasta. Person on the phone told me that it does I said I am asking because I am on your website and it doesn't say that it comes with pasta. He says it's under the pasta section so it comes with pasta not sure which one it comes with. Place my order via door dash. My food arrives only for me to realize that it does not come with pasta just a tray full of eggplant for $22.00. I contacted the restaurant and said I specially called and asked if the eggplant is served with pasta and was advised that it was I have my food and there's no pasta. Person on the phone was chatting telling me that's how it comes blah blah blah. Nonetheless, I'm never ordering here again.Let's look at the definition of pasta boys and girls:pas·ta/ˈpästə/nouna dish originally from Italy consisting of dough made from durum wheat, extruded or stamped into various shapes and cooked in boiling water, and typically served with a sauce."fresh pasta with pesto, feta cheese, and pine nuts
I went with a friend of mine jeremy perlow, the customer service was so nice, and they let us stay and talk for hours, I ordered 3 regular slices, he orded a onion slice.
I jumped off the Southern State, looking for a slice of pizza. I drove past so many fast food options, but I was determined to get a slice of pizza while I was home on Long Island. I got my slice, and it was good, but the star of the night was the sabich and the spicy bean soup. I was so happy!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
They have high chairs, and are very kid friendly. Staff is also very friendly.It's not the best slice, but it's a local kosher option, and it's okay.Kid-friendliness: High chairs are available, and the staff makes good accomodations for families.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Best pizza place I've been to in a long time. The food is fresh and delicious, the atmosphere is very relaxed and homey, and the customer service is incredible. We will definitely be coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very Good Pizza. Very Nice staff.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not the best I've ever had, but definitely above average. No complaints!Vegetarian options: Kosher, so you can't have any poultry or beef in restaurant (since kosher rules prohibit cooking meat and dairy together). Not sure I'd anything has fish in it- if not that it's 100 put vegetarian, though of course not vegan.Dietary restrictions: Kosher
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Sorry to say but once again another kosher establishment with very poor service. I placed a phone order on the phone and gave them my credit card information. I even gave them the name for the order and they tried to deny that I paid and tried to get my dad to pay again when he picked up the order!! When he asked who took the order, suddenly no-one knew.They also gave my dad an attitude when he questioned who took the order on the phone. I had to get on the phone to confirm my credit card number and let them know I was already charged for the order. The guy tried to tell me I wasn't charged for the order even though they took my credit card information on the phone until he confirmed that I was charged in the system. I am only giving them three stars because the pizza is good but the service is horrible. Its a shame because the owner is a really nice guy and way better than the previous owner when it was Hunki's Pizza. Any other decent establishment would have comped the food or thrown something extra in but because this is a kosher restaurant they don't do that because they don't have competition. This is unreal and embarrassing as a Jewish person myself!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Pizza with black olives and red peppers included a free topping of hair.yuk!regular pizza and fries and soups were fine.
We were in Garden City from Brooklyn and looking for a Kosher Pizza shop,and decided to try Sauly's Pizza. We ordered a spinach and cheese pinwheel and fries. It was the best we ever had. Never had such fresh fries. Prices are like in Brooklyn. Service and staff are superb. We loved Sauly's Pizza so much that we made a 2nd trip from Brooklyn to have Pizza, fries and pinwheel. Highly recommend this place. Keep up the good work SaulyA happy Brooklyn customer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is really good. It's really cheesy and not to oily. The mozzarella sticks were big and totally worth the money. The cheese was super stretchy and the marinara sauce is better than any I've ever had. Sauly's Pizza is definitely in my top choices of pizza stores and I'm so happy to live so close to one.Vegetarian options: They have a selection of salads plus a salad bar for a make your own salad option.Parking: There is no parking specifically for Sauly's, but there are always a few around the street by them. Either right in front, or around the corner, I can always find one close by.Wheelchair accessibility: There are no stairs leading up to the door and the doorway is wide enough to fit a wheelchair through.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Great place! Recommended!Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5