FIRST TIME THIS FRIDAY, BROUGHT HOME A FULL SICILIAN PIE, WITH GARLIC!! FANTASTIC!!IT WAS LIKE A CAKE! CHEESY. FLAVORFUL, CRUNCHY EDGES.GOOD
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Ali G
Great new Pizza spot in West Islip that I've been going to more & more compared to other Pizza spots in the area. I've only ordered the regular Cheese Pizza Pies there & it's the closest thing to something you would get at some of the well-known Pizza places in Manhattan or Brooklyn. ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Mark McKeon
I've only order twice from here so far but, I will say the food that I ordered was great! I can't say much for atmosphere or service because it was quick takeout transactions, not much to base an opinion from. I will say the place appeared to be clean and inviting. On Valentine's Day I ordered a heart shaped cheese pie for the kids and they loved it. Pizza had great flavor, quality cheese as well. Garlic knots were perfect with a ton of flavor. We ordered a couple of vodka slices and I will say certainly the best vodka slice I've had yet ! They have a bunch of other pies that look not only interesting but delicious. Check out the website and social media pages to see the line up, they even have personal pies! This review was not paid for, I don't know them, I'm not affiliated in any way. Just go try the pizza it speaks for itself!
I went here based off of google reviews. I think I’ve finally decided Suffolk county has the worst taste buds, especially when it comes to pizza.I got a regular slice and a Sicilian with Pepperoni. I didn’t realize this had hot honey on it. Overly greasy, the sauce has no flavor, and it completely has kept me in the bathroom for the last hour.The regular had so much grease dripping off of it. A sloppy mess when you try to eat it.The hot honey Sicilian w/ pepperoni is just a bad idea. The cheese wasn’t fully cooked on it, tiny pepperonis with again grease puddles sitting in each one.I was bummed out I had to finish that food.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
LongIsland Foodtastic
This is our favorite pizzeria, the food is great! I swear, we are here on a bi-weekly basis!Our first visit was for the Eggplant Ala Vodka rolls (ask for extra Vodka sauce for dipping on the side), since then, we got HOOKED! We also tried their individual pizzas (absolutely amazing, go for the ala vodka and eggplant rolatini). They have so many great pizza options honestly. For dessert, we tried their bombolinis, Nutella pizza, and sugar knots, all are so addictive!Staff is friendly and always do a great job, very fast/efficient.They have a few tables inside, so there is an option for dining in if you please.
Called the order in and they told us they never received our call even though the number was in the phone and it was pretty apparent the woman behind the counter knew she messed up. That would have been fine if they apologized or had any sort of accountability but that seemed to not be a priority. Luckily we have 12 other options in town lol. Can’t tell you if the food is any good if they don’t give you any.
Service: 1
Kerri B.
This is our favorite pizzeria, the food is great! I swear, we are here on a bi-weekly basis! Our first visit was for the Eggplant Ala Vodka rolls (ask for extra Vodka sauce for dipping on the side), since then, we got HOOKED! We also tried their individual pizzas (absolutely amazing, go for the ala vodka and eggplant rolatini). They have so many great pizza options honestly. For dessert, we tried their bombolinis, Nutella pizza, and sugar knots, all are so addictive! Staff is friendly and always do a great job, very fast/efficient.They have a few tables inside, so there is an option for dining in if you please.
Evelyn Nowak
Best pizza. Cauliflower pizza is really good!Dietary restrictions: Cauliflower pizza is really good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Meghan R.
We have ordered take out from here a bunch of times. We typically order their personal pizzas and add sesame crust which is great. This time we have ordered a chicken francese entree that came with pasta, both were generous servings and delicious. We also got a pasta fagioli soup which was very tasty. Will order again!
Jessica S.
Amazing food and service at Classico.Very reminiscent of pizza from Brooklyn!We've had their regular Neapolitan, the tri color grandma with meatball (amazing), and the upside down vodka Sicilian with fried chicken. You can't go wrong ordering anything here!
Been living in west islip for over 10 years have tried all the pizza spots around, new and old. By far our favorite! Especially for my picky family. They go all out and do any pies, calzones, dinners etc that I ask for! Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Courtney Sacks
amazing staff and food! The nutella donuts are a must try! will be ordering again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Noelle Perugini
Food and service are amazing! BEST Penne Alla Vodka I’ve ever had! Make sure you order the tri color grandma pie- delicious! ✨
FIRST TIME THIS FRIDAY, BROUGHT HOME A FULL SICILIAN PIE, WITH GARLIC!! FANTASTIC!!IT WAS LIKE A CAKE! CHEESY. FLAVORFUL, CRUNCHY EDGES.GOOD
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Great new Pizza spot in West Islip that I've been going to more & more compared to other Pizza spots in the area. I've only ordered the regular Cheese Pizza Pies there & it's the closest thing to something you would get at some of the well-known Pizza places in Manhattan or Brooklyn. ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
I've only order twice from here so far but, I will say the food that I ordered was great! I can't say much for atmosphere or service because it was quick takeout transactions, not much to base an opinion from. I will say the place appeared to be clean and inviting. On Valentine's Day I ordered a heart shaped cheese pie for the kids and they loved it. Pizza had great flavor, quality cheese as well. Garlic knots were perfect with a ton of flavor. We ordered a couple of vodka slices and I will say certainly the best vodka slice I've had yet ! They have a bunch of other pies that look not only interesting but delicious. Check out the website and social media pages to see the line up, they even have personal pies! This review was not paid for, I don't know them, I'm not affiliated in any way. Just go try the pizza it speaks for itself!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Penne Vodka Slice, Vodka Sauce, Cheese Slice
I went here based off of google reviews. I think I’ve finally decided Suffolk county has the worst taste buds, especially when it comes to pizza.I got a regular slice and a Sicilian with Pepperoni. I didn’t realize this had hot honey on it. Overly greasy, the sauce has no flavor, and it completely has kept me in the bathroom for the last hour.The regular had so much grease dripping off of it. A sloppy mess when you try to eat it.The hot honey Sicilian w/ pepperoni is just a bad idea. The cheese wasn’t fully cooked on it, tiny pepperonis with again grease puddles sitting in each one.I was bummed out I had to finish that food.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
This is our favorite pizzeria, the food is great! I swear, we are here on a bi-weekly basis!Our first visit was for the Eggplant Ala Vodka rolls (ask for extra Vodka sauce for dipping on the side), since then, we got HOOKED! We also tried their individual pizzas (absolutely amazing, go for the ala vodka and eggplant rolatini). They have so many great pizza options honestly. For dessert, we tried their bombolinis, Nutella pizza, and sugar knots, all are so addictive!Staff is friendly and always do a great job, very fast/efficient.They have a few tables inside, so there is an option for dining in if you please.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Grilled Chicken, Eggplant Rollatini, Chicken Francese, Chicken Classico, Grandma Slice, Peppers, Pie, Grandma Pie, Chicken Parmigiana, Penne Vodka Slice, Tricolor Grandma Slice, Chicken Parmigiana Hero, Vodka Sauce, Grandma Pizza, Meat Lover Slice, Hot Honey & Pepperoni Slice, White Pizza, Classico Hero
Called the order in and they told us they never received our call even though the number was in the phone and it was pretty apparent the woman behind the counter knew she messed up. That would have been fine if they apologized or had any sort of accountability but that seemed to not be a priority. Luckily we have 12 other options in town lol. Can’t tell you if the food is any good if they don’t give you any.
Service: 1
This is our favorite pizzeria, the food is great! I swear, we are here on a bi-weekly basis! Our first visit was for the Eggplant Ala Vodka rolls (ask for extra Vodka sauce for dipping on the side), since then, we got HOOKED! We also tried their individual pizzas (absolutely amazing, go for the ala vodka and eggplant rolatini). They have so many great pizza options honestly. For dessert, we tried their bombolinis, Nutella pizza, and sugar knots, all are so addictive! Staff is friendly and always do a great job, very fast/efficient.They have a few tables inside, so there is an option for dining in if you please.
Best pizza. Cauliflower pizza is really good!Dietary restrictions: Cauliflower pizza is really good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
We have ordered take out from here a bunch of times. We typically order their personal pizzas and add sesame crust which is great. This time we have ordered a chicken francese entree that came with pasta, both were generous servings and delicious. We also got a pasta fagioli soup which was very tasty. Will order again!
Amazing food and service at Classico.Very reminiscent of pizza from Brooklyn!We've had their regular Neapolitan, the tri color grandma with meatball (amazing), and the upside down vodka Sicilian with fried chicken. You can't go wrong ordering anything here!
Restaurantji Recommends
Check them out. Good stuff!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was not bad nor good it was okay at
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Been living in west islip for over 10 years have tried all the pizza spots around, new and old. By far our favorite! Especially for my picky family. They go all out and do any pies, calzones, dinners etc that I ask for! Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
amazing staff and food! The nutella donuts are a must try! will be ordering again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food and service are amazing! BEST Penne Alla Vodka I’ve ever had! Make sure you order the tri color grandma pie- delicious! ✨