The place has gone significantly down hill. I miss the old hometown heroes, recently the staff has been terrible. The food is still pretty good. Don’t think I’ll be coming back here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Rae D.
My go to before a day at the beach!! Best sandwiches!! Great service. Worker are very polite.
Michael Z.
Got the Papa Georgio. Great tasting but the chicken was pathetic. So thin, dry and hard around the edges. Need some quality control. No respectable business would serve chicken in this shape. I wanted to get your opinion.
Brittney B.
Got the spicy chicken and there was not bbq sauce. Sandwich was so dry. Also it wasn't busy so idk how they messed that up
Aleksander N
Amazing heroes! I was so blown away how good they are, I’m glad I found a good hero place here in the islip area where I’m close by to, most good hero spots I have to travel throughout Suffolk county, i highly recommend hometown heroes most especially the Mac Attack or Good Sam hero’s!! Will be back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Suzanne E.
First off - I LOVE sandwiches, so naturally I needed to try this place! Everything I've tried here is soooo delicious!!! Very hefty portions and fresh ingredients. I usually order the Mama Georgio which is perfection on a sandwich! Also love the hot pastrami and the curveball. Service is fast and efficient. Great spot to stop in quick, grab some heros and hit the beach.
Richie Kajetanowicz
Ordered on your online app from Hometown heroes never received the order and when called in we referred to Kol Chow, *Now had no idea where our order was now I’m stuck with no food and no refund at this time. I would recommend never ordering from this establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Caleb Kim
Love these heroes. Saw one of their promoted items, the "Mac Attack," and I decided to order it on a whim. Looked great, tasted even better. Tried their other sandwiches too, which are also fantastic. Huge portions and tastes great. I come here
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac Attack
jake delprete
walked in and ordered the Brando and the mac attack the pictures looked amazing...... Don't be fooled by the delicious-looking photos.......... finished sandwiches didn't look as good as advertised and weren't amazing wasn't disgusting but were not tasty or good and very bland both heroes.... two heroes were over 30 dollars way too pricey for something I could have made better myself.... Please Stay Away You have been warned.
Glen Peterson
I recently ordered a 3 foot hero (American and Chicken/Bacon) and it was fantastic! I've ordered hero for years from other stores and there is no comparison. I would HIGHLY recommend ordering from Hometown Heroes as you will not be disappointed.
Very disappointing. I have been a customer for about 9 years now and it's all been down hill. The prices are insane and the quality has become poor. I'm charged 20$ last night for just a sandwich and fries, the meat was clearly low grade, the hot sandwich was so cold, my cheese didn't even melt and the only things in the bag were the fries and sandwich. No napkins, no ketchup, nothing. The Manhattan with Dijon sauce used to be my favorite sandwich, it's sad that I can't get the same sandwich anymore, it was my comfort food.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Keith Osback
That sandwich was amazing (papa Geiorgo w/bacon , Ive Been in west islip 7 years , why have I not tried this place.. Wow! so good ..
Jake Mieczkowski
I’ve never had a bad meal here. Everything from the sides to the sandwiches is always top quality and the portions are huge.I HIGHLY RECOMMEND the Mac and cheese bites. They are off the charts with the dipping sauce.I am a sucker for the nor’easter, chicken cutlets mozzarella bacon and bbq sauce. There’s more chicken cutlet and bacon on there than two sandwiches of any other deli.This is one of my favorite delis on Long Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Cutlets, Macaroni and Cheese, Waffle Fries
Susan Lombardi
Clean establishment friendly abundant staff..great heroesParking: Sometimes filled
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Bridey Launonen
great heroes & good portion sizes. we go all the time and definitely will be back. favorite thing is the loaded waffle fries
The place has gone significantly down hill. I miss the old hometown heroes, recently the staff has been terrible. The food is still pretty good. Don’t think I’ll be coming back here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
My go to before a day at the beach!! Best sandwiches!! Great service. Worker are very polite.
Got the Papa Georgio. Great tasting but the chicken was pathetic. So thin, dry and hard around the edges. Need some quality control. No respectable business would serve chicken in this shape. I wanted to get your opinion.
Got the spicy chicken and there was not bbq sauce. Sandwich was so dry. Also it wasn't busy so idk how they messed that up
Amazing heroes! I was so blown away how good they are, I’m glad I found a good hero place here in the islip area where I’m close by to, most good hero spots I have to travel throughout Suffolk county, i highly recommend hometown heroes most especially the Mac Attack or Good Sam hero’s!! Will be back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First off - I LOVE sandwiches, so naturally I needed to try this place! Everything I've tried here is soooo delicious!!! Very hefty portions and fresh ingredients. I usually order the Mama Georgio which is perfection on a sandwich! Also love the hot pastrami and the curveball. Service is fast and efficient. Great spot to stop in quick, grab some heros and hit the beach.
Ordered on your online app from Hometown heroes never received the order and when called in we referred to Kol Chow, *Now had no idea where our order was now I’m stuck with no food and no refund at this time. I would recommend never ordering from this establishment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
Love these heroes. Saw one of their promoted items, the "Mac Attack," and I decided to order it on a whim. Looked great, tasted even better. Tried their other sandwiches too, which are also fantastic. Huge portions and tastes great. I come here
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Mac Attack
walked in and ordered the Brando and the mac attack the pictures looked amazing...... Don't be fooled by the delicious-looking photos.......... finished sandwiches didn't look as good as advertised and weren't amazing wasn't disgusting but were not tasty or good and very bland both heroes.... two heroes were over 30 dollars way too pricey for something I could have made better myself.... Please Stay Away You have been warned.
I recently ordered a 3 foot hero (American and Chicken/Bacon) and it was fantastic! I've ordered hero for years from other stores and there is no comparison. I would HIGHLY recommend ordering from Hometown Heroes as you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Very disappointing. I have been a customer for about 9 years now and it's all been down hill. The prices are insane and the quality has become poor. I'm charged 20$ last night for just a sandwich and fries, the meat was clearly low grade, the hot sandwich was so cold, my cheese didn't even melt and the only things in the bag were the fries and sandwich. No napkins, no ketchup, nothing. The Manhattan with Dijon sauce used to be my favorite sandwich, it's sad that I can't get the same sandwich anymore, it was my comfort food.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
That sandwich was amazing (papa Geiorgo w/bacon , Ive Been in west islip 7 years , why have I not tried this place.. Wow! so good ..
I’ve never had a bad meal here. Everything from the sides to the sandwiches is always top quality and the portions are huge.I HIGHLY RECOMMEND the Mac and cheese bites. They are off the charts with the dipping sauce.I am a sucker for the nor’easter, chicken cutlets mozzarella bacon and bbq sauce. There’s more chicken cutlet and bacon on there than two sandwiches of any other deli.This is one of my favorite delis on Long Island.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Cutlets, Macaroni and Cheese, Waffle Fries
Clean establishment friendly abundant staff..great heroesParking: Sometimes filled
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich
great heroes & good portion sizes. we go all the time and definitely will be back. favorite thing is the loaded waffle fries
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries, Sandwich