I moved to west Islip 2 years ago. I’ve tried just about every pizzeria, none were consistent and as good as Classico. I highly recommend the pepperoni slice. The establishment is clean and the owner is very nice. ?♥️
Becky S
Ordered a few trays for a work event and WOW! Everyone is raving about the food! The chicken parm was so delicious, the garlic knots were perfectly soft and buttery, and the penne ala vodka stole the show!Whoever I spoke to on the phone when i ordered was so kind, informative, and helpful.Will definitely be ordering from here again!
Joanne Onorato
The food was delicious, I ordered the chicken classico, the chicken was so tender,I enjoyed it and Vinny was so nice and pleasant, thank you
David S
Local, local local... One less star for credit card fees added to your bill, why? Nice local place, friendly service, lots of choices makes this a great little pizza/restaurant to go to!Oh yeah, the tricolor pesto is great, as is the cherry pepper chicken francese slice are both great choices not to be found anywhere else!
Danielle DiNapoli
Clean, inviting pizzeria with delicious slices. The tri-color grandma and chicken Francese with hot cherry peppers are showstoppers. The crust is soft but crispy. The pizza flavors are delicious. Staff are attentive and friendly also. Slice prices range ~$4-$5.25. it shares a lot with a laundromat, supermarket, and some other shops but there are some parking spaces available in frontDo yourself a favor and order the Classico Hero: chicken Francese, mozzarella and hot cherry peppers. This in pizza form is great, and somehow the hero is even better
Callie Cuff
Wow this place is delicious!!! We got the grandma pizza, the hot honey pepperoni, and vodka sauce. Everything was scrumptious! Highly highly recommend!
Jay Giberson
Class acts at this place. Great food. After being a revolving door for several years, I have a feeling Classico is here to stay. They took the time to make the space their own and really nailed it. Try them out, you won't be disappointed.
Heart Beat
Been looking for some reallllly good pizza spot and found this!! So good
Richie Stack
Excellent Pizza and really nice staff. The Tri-color grandma pie might be my new favorite slice of pizza anywhere. Will definitely be returning!
True Restorations Inc.
We picked up a Classico pie and Tricolor Grandma with grilled chicken for our office luncheon today. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed both pies. We are so excited to have a new local pizzeria to order from for our future company lunches!
My new favorite pizza place… best garlic knots, pizza is great, everything is fresh, the veggie slice is my favorite. Delicious!!!
Julie Day
Just okay garlic knots are very greasy pizza was okay. Nothing great just average.
Gus A.
Great food great service good prices, what else do we need! This is the second grandma pizza with all the vegetables that we ordered and it is fantastic!
Patty C.
Wow. Garlic knots, seriously, the best garlic knots I have ever had. I've had a lot. I'm eating a veggie slice right now, incredibly fresh, the broccoli is crunchy but cooked, the fresh herbs... I mean c'mon. There's more but I'm actually eating so yea, this place has amazing food.
Slappygoober Gooberslappy
This was my first time ordering from Teresa’s. I’m was pleasantly surprised and that’s saying a lot if you know me. The grilled very tasty chicken panini was cooked to perfection! The Garlic doughy knots were covered with garlic and NOT overcooked. The clams tasted great but I only wish they were slightly smaller with less bread crumbs.The sauce was delicious but covered with too many bread crumbs. Overall, I was enjoyed my meal and I will order from Teresa’s again.
I moved to west Islip 2 years ago. I’ve tried just about every pizzeria, none were consistent and as good as Classico. I highly recommend the pepperoni slice. The establishment is clean and the owner is very nice. ?♥️
Ordered a few trays for a work event and WOW! Everyone is raving about the food! The chicken parm was so delicious, the garlic knots were perfectly soft and buttery, and the penne ala vodka stole the show!Whoever I spoke to on the phone when i ordered was so kind, informative, and helpful.Will definitely be ordering from here again!
The food was delicious, I ordered the chicken classico, the chicken was so tender,I enjoyed it and Vinny was so nice and pleasant, thank you
Local, local local... One less star for credit card fees added to your bill, why? Nice local place, friendly service, lots of choices makes this a great little pizza/restaurant to go to!Oh yeah, the tricolor pesto is great, as is the cherry pepper chicken francese slice are both great choices not to be found anywhere else!
Clean, inviting pizzeria with delicious slices. The tri-color grandma and chicken Francese with hot cherry peppers are showstoppers. The crust is soft but crispy. The pizza flavors are delicious. Staff are attentive and friendly also. Slice prices range ~$4-$5.25. it shares a lot with a laundromat, supermarket, and some other shops but there are some parking spaces available in frontDo yourself a favor and order the Classico Hero: chicken Francese, mozzarella and hot cherry peppers. This in pizza form is great, and somehow the hero is even better
Wow this place is delicious!!! We got the grandma pizza, the hot honey pepperoni, and vodka sauce. Everything was scrumptious! Highly highly recommend!
Class acts at this place. Great food. After being a revolving door for several years, I have a feeling Classico is here to stay. They took the time to make the space their own and really nailed it. Try them out, you won't be disappointed.
Been looking for some reallllly good pizza spot and found this!! So good
Excellent Pizza and really nice staff. The Tri-color grandma pie might be my new favorite slice of pizza anywhere. Will definitely be returning!
We picked up a Classico pie and Tricolor Grandma with grilled chicken for our office luncheon today. Everyone thoroughly enjoyed both pies. We are so excited to have a new local pizzeria to order from for our future company lunches!
Restaurantji Recommends
My new favorite pizza place… best garlic knots, pizza is great, everything is fresh, the veggie slice is my favorite. Delicious!!!
Just okay garlic knots are very greasy pizza was okay. Nothing great just average.
Great food great service good prices, what else do we need! This is the second grandma pizza with all the vegetables that we ordered and it is fantastic!
Wow. Garlic knots, seriously, the best garlic knots I have ever had. I've had a lot. I'm eating a veggie slice right now, incredibly fresh, the broccoli is crunchy but cooked, the fresh herbs... I mean c'mon. There's more but I'm actually eating so yea, this place has amazing food.
This was my first time ordering from Teresa’s. I’m was pleasantly surprised and that’s saying a lot if you know me. The grilled very tasty chicken panini was cooked to perfection! The Garlic doughy knots were covered with garlic and NOT overcooked. The clams tasted great but I only wish they were slightly smaller with less bread crumbs.The sauce was delicious but covered with too many bread crumbs. Overall, I was enjoyed my meal and I will order from Teresa’s again.