Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta

I used to love coming here but today was my last time. The pizza was luke warm and the cheese was like plastic. The white slice had caked on ricotta cheese...Last few times, the pizza has been cold, and just not good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dee-liscious!! Very good food, I highly recommend i had the pinwheels & spinach artichoke pizza💋🤌❣️

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

We had an appetizer that was out of this world. We ordered mussels with marinara sauce, this is the third time I've ordered this - I've never been let down. The mussels were perfect, soft not rubbery combined with garlic infused sauce. Superb! Highly recommended. We also had the lunch special . Good portions, baked ziti and stuffed shells. Very satisfying and not saturated with enormous cheese nor salt.

Food: 5

I’ve only had their Sicilian pie, but it was good and priced fairly

Atmosphere: 5

Dependable food, business and all atound good vibe i this place. Best Pizza in West Islip.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Delicious Pizza! Many varieties and none disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

From start to finish our experience with Our little Italy was perfect. John was so great to work with for all our catering needs. The food was out of this world. So many comments on how amazing the meatballs were. Love using people from our home town. Thanks for everything!!!

Delicious!! Got the margarita pizza and meatballs which are both now new favourites for me 🤤 Got it delivered and it came 15 minutes earlier than expected!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

We’re longtime fans of Our Little Italy—the food is always fresh and consistently delicious. We recently had them cater our son’s graduation party, and our guests are still raving about how amazing ev

Food is basic do not taste no real Italian

Ordered an hour ago, called 20 minutes in they said it’s on its way, called 40 minutes in and they said that it was actually on its way and the first person i called was wrong. It arrived after an hour (it’s 1 mile away) and it’s missing an item. Unbelievable.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

LOVE THE FOOD. Service is amazing. Tons of choices.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I used to be a big fan of this place — their salad slices and regular slices were always a go-to for me. But unfortunately, my experience today left me really disappointed.

We ordered five slices from the window, only to watch the customers who ordered after us not only get their food first, but actually receive the exact slices we had requested. When we asked about our order, we were told they no longer had those slices available. To make matters worse, our food wasn’t even put in the oven until about 15 minutes after we had placed our order — after others had already been served fresh, hot slices from the oven.

It felt like our order was forgotten or deprioritized, and the lack of communication made it even more frustrating. I’ve always recommended this spot to others, but after today, I’m not sure I’ll be back anytime soon.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Been going here for decades. Followed his relocation from the prior site. Highly recommended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5