Primi Italian Steakhouse

999 Montauk Hwy, West Islip
(631) 526-9779

Recent Reviews

joe bulzacchelli

After spending over $600 the manager comes over to us and says we need to leave someone with a reservation was getting upset. We had a reservation and our desert just arrived. This Manager has no class and should not be working in hospitality.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

John Paul P

Food is absolutely delicious. Some of the best food you can get on Long Island. I highly recommend their steak. Their service is also exceptional. One thing they can improve on is the spacing in between tables. My wife and I were arms length from another couple and it was easy to overhear their conversation even with the live music. I understand it's a business and they want to serve as many people as possible but for a high end restaurant I would expect a little bit more personal space while eating.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gnocchi, Tuscan Fries

Miggs Gonzo

One of the best steakhouse I've been too. I must say the service was excellent, and the food was amazing. Great atmosphere but most of all our server Katelyn was top notch. Thank you for great service and great food. Looking forward to come to restaurant again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grilled Octopus, Porterhouse for Two, Calamari, Creamed Spinach

steak

Another INCREDIBLE Date nite dinner. I cannot thank the staff enough for being the most pleasant, energetic, fun, friendly and tentative to my wife and I. The food is so Consistent and Delicious every time. I cant wait to be back for dinner next week. ?

George Berry

Great atmosphere. Holly and Gerber wete great. Food was delicious

Brady Patruno

What a great restaurant food is top notch, service is spot on, and drinks are made to perfection ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Grilled Octopus, Porterhouse for Two, Creamed Spinach

Ray Palma

Everything was so, so GOOD! The FOOD, the SERVICE, the VIBE! Way to go!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

AJ Lombarski

The food was delicious and the desserts were some of the best I’ve had anywhere, but the service and hospitality from both Mandi and Diego were above and beyond what any other restaurant offers. They were knowledgeable, extremely friendly, and clearly passionate about what they do. That man Diego is a rockstar and I will definitely be back soon (especially for the apple bread pudding)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rob Butler

Atmosphere and food is amazing, a must try!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Calamari

Carolynne Sehn

Love this place. Comfortable surroundings. Excellent food. Been here a few times and have never been disappointed. Service is top shelf. Desserts incredible. Absolutely a must try..

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gnocchi, Tiramisu, Cheesecake, Tuscan Fries, Chicken Franchese, Clams Oreganata, Beef Wellington, Porterhouse for Two

DavidP

Excellent veal chop was the best chop I had Moist and so tender well seasoned with broccoli rabe that was seasoned so well with no bitterness , a perfect combo Scallops were perfectly cooked , very tasty Dine at many restaurants NYC , LI and Europe This restaurant is near the top of my list

steak

Wow! wow! wow! What an incredible experience. Zack is an Excellent GM very tentative to me and my guests. Our server Amanda was very accommodating to us and on top of us just enough..Even Diego the busman was Incredible and kept everything neat and clean and offering suggestions of all of the different items on the menu. My Porterhouse for 2 was cooked perfectly, tender and delicious. The grilled octopus was so tasty, fresh, and a beautiful presentation. The drinks were to perfection. I am sorry I have not been here before, but I will be back again very soon. Thank you Brady

Mike G

Dined here the other night and the food was pretty good nothing special but I felt it was a tad overpriced for the sized portions. I got the feeling they want to make you think you’re in a fancy restaurant with how it’s decorated and the valet parking but it’s located on montauk highway in the middle of nowhere.With so many great Italian places on Long Island I don’t really see a reason to return. I can get superior food at lesser expense elsewhere. To reiterate it’s not bad it’s just nothing that makes it stand out in a crowded field.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

We had a wonderful experience. Our waiter Brian was fantastic and his helper Diego went above and beyond. The music was a perfect vibe and the food was absolutely to die for. Every time we come back it gets better and better.

Joseph Schwaner

food was not good at all very salty and i like saltservice was greatplace is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Load More