Southdown Marketplace - West Islip, NY

460 Montauk Hwy, West Islip
(631) 620-3744

Recent Reviews

Emily Ladau

Came here to pick up some produce and some cookies. Struggled to find tomatoes because most of the packages were moldy. Managed to find a decent package but the quality wasn't great. Had a similar issue with strawberries. And I came home with chocolate rugelach and discovered the whole package was moldy. I should've looked more closely! Check all your purchases carefully if you do shop here. Food clearly doesn't move quickly off the shelves and they seemingly can't be bothered to sort through what's expired. Absolutely will not be returning.

Busbq Bill

Great store clean organized, and great workers/cashiers.

Jeannette M

What a great market!

Bruce D'Henin

I love the concept of this place, the food is good but not great. I think if they were busier it would be better. Lots of choices but a couple times I got food that was chewy or slightly out dated. I keep trying though.

Maurizio Coccia

Good supermarket, someone speaks a little Italian, good for those who don't speak English

Vicky Cianci

Very nice and good selection.. just a little expensive

Susan Casaburri

Great store to pop into for quick shopping trip. Meats are very good quality. Fruits and Veggies are good too.

AJ Buquicchio

Quality food (esp the meats), quality service & friendly, helpful staff. Great addition to the West Islip community

Richard Cheek

Meat selection is good for a small grocery store. Produce is in good shape too. But pricey! You pay for the convenience!

Joni Miale

I go there and get my vegetable tuna salad it's always fresh and so is everything else

Ted Mosser

Great Deli, Meats, Fresh Vegetables, nice staff, plenty of ready-made heat and eat, great for the lazy or infirm group ? ?

Lawrence Greb

Really a great store.Fresh stuff, helpful people, and easy relaxing experience

Peter G.

I bought what I thought was PRIME MEAT definitely not prime! Paid Prime price.I don't want to fight with my steak. I won't be back.

Gary Gisonda

Convenient pre-made products with better than average meats and produce.

Verinder ny

Very good location if store enough parking, front parking . Prices are much better than other places . Amazing variety food ?

Load More

Southdown Marketplace - West Islip, NY

460 Montauk Hwy, West Islip, NY 11795
(631) 620-3744