Stuff-A-Bagel

425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip
(631) 661-7646

Recent Reviews

Jerrod Pitts

This bagel shop is a staple of the neighborhood. When I go to Good Sam hospital, I have to stop in for a bag of bagels. They're big and delicious. The staff is also very nice and courteous.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Dozen Bagels

Bill Paz

My doctor is down the street from this place, I love 1 hour away, anyway I stopped in,ordered my food,and didn't eat it until I was on the southern state parkway miles away. The food was so good I almost turned around to go for seconds ?, ? great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erin Bell

good food, prices and service!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex Giovanniello

Nothing special. The egg sandwich I ordered had one egg on it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 4

Kimberly Dougherty

Worst bagel store Originally ordered a toasted onion bagel with olive cream cheese Half of the bagel didn't have the cream cheese on it when I called them and told them that they gave me the wrong cream cheese. His answer was well I didn't charge you for Olive cream cheese and I said I didn't want reg cream cheese and I ask for credit for next time and he told me he couldn't give me credit. Oh not to mention they didnt toasted the bagel as well smh stay away from this store horrible customer service ..

Patricia K.

$71.19 is an absurd amount to pay for 6 simple breakfast items: 2 bagels w/ CC, 1 BEC egg sandwich, 2 OJs, and 1lb of CC.PLEASE fix your options. When you try to order a bagel with cream cheese it requires you to choose add-ons (tomato $0.25 or bacon $3.00). You're also charging an automatic $0.25 for the bagel to be toasted?! That is absurd. A bagel with cream cheese should not cost $5.85 ($7.85 w/ extra CC), and a simple bacon egg and cheese $12.45, even on Uber eats!!That's not business, it's pure greed.Unfortunately I am sick and can't leave the house, otherwise I wouldn't have ever paid this much for such a small amount of food.

Jenna Lenihan

didn’t toast my bagel and put no cream cheese. mad expensive for what???

James Sweeney

They literally mess up the Oder every time done with this place

Kayla R.

Young girl ,who looks like a mouse, touches the food without gloves using the same hand she uses to handle money and cleaning products. Absolutely disgusting and appalling. The bagels she touched have a metallic taste clearly from her dirty hands.

S Gries

Located on the main road, convenient. Bagel was good, sandwich could have had a bit more "substance", but times are tough and things are expensive I suppose

D HAHA

Great place to stop by and pick up some freshly made bagels before hitting the water to fish

ShawtyAspen

Gone downhill over 5 years. Today was last time I’ll ever go there. Asked for chicken salad on bagel and got tuna salad. My order is wrong half the time I go.

Robert Ricciardi

A little to expensive for me very clean and efficient. But I can get an egg sandwich for almost half the price at j&g deli in copaiuge

Majestic Contracting

Total RIP OFF. 14 bucks for 2 bagels, one with light tuna and a small coffee. GTFOH. I'll never come back here again. Good luck to the new owners. You'll need it

Lima

The bagels are ok , not the best spot in town , some shady characters have worked here , one younger man attempted to trick me on my change charging me over 20$ for 2 bagels with cream cheese , then when i called him out on it he goes " oh yeah i knew i made a mistake " , but he had no problem letting me leave ?

Load More