Stonehedge Restaurant

1694 Rte 9W, West Park
(845) 384-6555

Recent Reviews

Kyle L

Sadly disappointed. Food wasn't good at all. Leg of lamb was a few pieces of well-done meat. Shrimp risotto had bad shrimp, taste, and smell. Overwhelmed staff and understaffed for Easter. Wouldn't go again personally.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

guymard

Small Wedding venue.DJ was fantastic! Definitely he deserves to be mentioned!Dinner and service, great job ladies!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Tony F.

The Food was very good.. However, it was quite uncomfortable when our waitress was frantically running around the dining room. it was quite scary and distracting. Then we received our bill, and there was no line item for the tax. The tax was included in the total number. (like, was she hoping for a tip based on that total number?) Also, my party decided to stay a bit after we paid. It was late, but still not closing time, and there were other people there still. We started getting the looks and comments from the wait staff that they wanted us to leave.. "if you stay longer we're gonna charge you rent", one of them said. We were not happy. Overall, it was not a very good experience. I will not go back there.

John M.

We have had an early (4:30pm) dinner this past weekend. We have been there several times before but over 15 years ago. No specific reason for the lapse. just never got back. Our past experience was: Food and service 5 stars, Atmosphere: upscale (dressy), Prices: reasonable for the quality and portions. The steak Au Poivre was the best I have ever had. New experience: The atmosphere, is more casual -(almost "rustic"), The host wearing a flannel shirt, and the waitress wearing a down vest. After other guests arrived, I thought it was a bit noisy but then realized there wasn't a person dining under 80 (guessing hearing problems, LOL), I'm 65 and felt like a kid, LOL. No worries, it didn't affect my food! LOL!. Food and service: The calamari was skimpy but cooked perfectly. The French onion soup was VERY VERY good!! The Steak Au Poivre... is STILL the best I have ever had! The fries, well I like the crisp-crisp-crisp, but did not specify.. They came out perfect to my liking. The bourbon list, only Knob Creek and Bullitt, drinkable but it would have been nice to see some eagle rare, Blantins, etc. The "house" wine was yummy too. No dessert, we were very full. SummaryL We would absolutely go back again and not wait 15 years! 5 stars from us. Note; we liked the casual dress... I dont mind wearing a shirt and tie but we did feel more relaxed in casual attire.

Chris Finnegan

We're in the area a couple of times a year and always make it a point to eat here. Food and service are both always great. My wife has celiac disease and they are very accommodating and have a lot of gluten free options.

George Geisler

Great food and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Glassey

We recently attended a large luncheon at Stonehedge- and the food was excellent. Their seafood appetizers, including shrimp, bacon wrapped scallops, puff pastry crab, clams, etc were particularly tasty as were the brie bites. Very accommodating staff and the banquet room is open, light and airy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vic Collazo

OK so I know when I'm getting a great dining experience. Stonehenge has been doing this constantly for over the 20 years that I've been going there. Just unbelievable, delicious food and service 2nd to none. Please I'm telling you, if you haven't been, do yourself a favor and go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Zuppa De Clams, Traditional French Onion Soup Gratinee, Eggplant Lasagna

Gloria Cottrell

Oh my God we love this place the food is great the service is great we have been coming here for years we always order three orders of baked clams for an appetizer for two people they are the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael G.

Restaurant out of the Blue which you probably pass many times. Quaint and comfortable setting with Great Effort Service and Excellent Food! If you're in the area a definite visit destination.

katie mercurio

They are SO good with food allergies! The waitresses made sure I got something flavorful and good even with all my restrictions. (Gluten, dairy, eggs, and shellfish)I usually feel slightly sick after eating at places from cross contamination but this place left me feeling hungry for more.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lloyd Fruhschien

First time there...excellent food and service.

Tom Richichi

Delicious dinner, great service, and atmosphere ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Geiger

Great food, delicious! We will be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Peyton J.

I've been driving past this wonderful looking place for decades with never the time to stop and dine. We finally had that chance. We ordered chilled Cucumber soup for starters. expecting the typical green lemony herb summer treat. We received a cold white creamy soup that tasted like the base for clam chowder. I didn't finish it. My friend who said this was her Aunt's favorite restaurant for decades, ordered the char with couscous which was blended with fresh corn which was tasty. I tried the broiled seafood platter which was presented beautifully with wonderfully steamed broccoli but tasted bland and old. Our waitress was absolutely lovely and we will try again.

Load More