Rusty Nickel Brewing Co.

4350 Seneca St, West Seneca
(716) 608-6155

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Kellie Gordon

Very unprofessional and employees are disposable to them. Owners are unprofessional. I’d rate 0 stars if I could.

David N

This is a very nice semi-outdoor venue. On special occasions there's live music all day, rotating acts entertain. Food available. Craft Beers. Full Bar. Can't help but enjoy yourself here.

Jason Harris

First, I want to highlight how varied the tap list is. A few IPA, a few sours, 3 different cream ales, a wit, an Irish, a Mexican, a dark lager, a mead.. what a wonderful array of choices! We did a few flights and tried most of the options and they are all really well made and tasty. The bartenders were really friendly guys and the patio is amazing. Had a great time and really enjoyed getting away from the typical 12 IPAs we've been seeing on typical tap lists

Michelle Buttry

Family friendly and very good beers ? The outside beer garden is relaxing.

Sandra Taylor

Popped in tonight for a pint and tried the Rustifico Mexican Lager. Light and refreshing! Great pub and patio!

Selena Borek

Great location with a gorgeous patio! They also have wine tastings which was a pleasant surprise for me.

Just being Honest

The beer selection is great! I love the fact they have darker, more robust brews , not all that IPA stuff! But the back yard seating area looked like well, let’s just say , not good… all the tables were dirty, the patio is uneven so the chairs aren’t flush. The views back there look like a junkyard. Might come back for a 6 pack of beer, but will not stay.

Eric Sauers

Rusty Nickel has a great variety of beers. Not 80% IPAs like most places now days. The outdoor space out back is really laid back and a cool place to hang out with friends. Was just there yesterday since the weather was nice. Highly recommend if you like good beer and a cool environment.

TG Fitch (VA Renaissance Man)

Great setting with tasty beer choices. The indoor space is perfect for a party atmosphere or meander to the covered and open spaces out back. We visited during the 2024 eclipse and despite being packed service was good. The clearly marked place to order at the bar is a simple common-sense step that every bar should take. There are flat-screen TVs everywhere and I could imagine enjoying a televised sporting event here. The interesting features in the open-air areas add visual stimulation to the park-like setting, like a back yard done by a TV home renovation show. The nacho orders are gigantic, like a cafeteria tray barely supporting an eight-inch mound of chips and toppings. Oddly for a "Brewing Co.," the "Our Beers" part of their web site goes to a food menu. I enjoyed the Ms. Brown's Porter and the unique Vanilla Chai Tea Milk Stout. Thankfully they seem to offer a few darker beers year-round. Adding to the local flavor (literally) is their array of local and regional spirits, which will be sampled next time I visit. I live hours away, but if I lived in the area, I could see this place becoming a go-to local hangout. Definitely worth checking out. Slainte!

Jen Lane

Such a great place for good beer, an amazing staff and an overall great time with friends. I can't wait to go back!

Elizabeth Iverson

So cozy with the holiday lights. Good beer selection and the staff was wonderful.

Mark Sulzbach

Great place, great beer selection, been coming here since it opened.

Jillian Cole

Good brews, great vibes.

Francis Koziolek

Great staff and awesome brews!
Love their parties.
Always a good time

Joe Grimaldi

Great patio! Great beer.

Loading...