Rusty Nickel Brewing Co.

4350 Seneca St, West Seneca
(716) 608-6155

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brother Howard

Sausage Fest 2026 was a blast. Food was delicious, band very good, and atmosphere Winter's finest.

Matthew Strachan

Absolutely love this place, everytime I come in here it's a great experience! Mercedes and Evan were fantastic. Great food, great drinks and excellent service.

Mike Gagliardo

Tasty beers, great service. Evan and Mercedes were fantastic, good conversations, fast service.

Kevin Conway

Good drinks, Evan is a cool bartender and is fun to chat with.

Thomas Wlodarczyk

This place is elite. Such a hidden gem. First time being here is the Eve to Christmas Eve. Absolutely electric. Good beers too

Elizabeth Czarnecki

Great place for beer and cocktails

John

This is a nice place to go have a good beer, a bite to eat and enjoy a nice place to sit and enjoy even when it's cold out because of their 2 outside heaters. Parker is awesome, and adds a special touch with his knowledge and Brooke is awesome as well! Highly recommend. Just pay cash to avoid a 3% fee.

Richard DePalma

Mercedes the bartender was very pleasant and friendly. Bar food was good! Beers were good! Bar had an old type tavern feel to it

christopher Berry

Go Bills!

Matt Russell

My Wife and I had a fall wedding at Rusty Nickel Brewing September 14.

Food- 10 out of 10
Location- 10 out of 10
Service- 10 out of 10
Staff- 10 out of 10
Spirits- 10 out of 10
Price- Very Affordable. They are up front about all the costs and very quick with invoices. Lots of places to save or up-sell your event.

Out original location fell through. Lexi and the whole crew at Rusty Nickel Brewing were top shelf from the planning stage, through our entire event. We wanted a simple ceremony that turned into a party to watch the Bills game. At no time did we feel overwhelmed or unsure about how the day would play out. We paid extra for them to setup my wife's decorations exactly as she wanted them. Well worth it. I cannot wait to come in the next time and every September 14th to celebrate and reminisce with my Wife! Thanks Rusty Nickel Brewing Crew!

Maureen Wilhelm

Always great service, amazing beers and Bloody Marys! Stunning patio and dog friendly!

Abe Bailon

As always best place to go! Brooke, Sadie, and Tyler were awesome!! The service was great and timely. The music was great and most importantly, not too loud! The beer was A+
Much recommend for a great night out!!

wilfredo ramos

Great experience beer testing n Jeff bartender amazing guy explained the drinks.

Kristy Cornell

Our family just made a visit there for Halloween, we saw online that there was some family stuff scheduled for the afternoon. The grounds are beautiful, the drink selection was fantastic, and their menu was also impressive. We had a pretzel which was yummy... they had some fun family stuff setup and goodie bags for the kiddos too. The only reason I couldn't rate 5 stars is because the staff was not friendly-- no greetings upon arrival or thank you when we left, even after spending $160.... I wasn't sure if they wanted us there, but otherwise- it was great!

Kaitlin Fisher

I held my rehearsal dinner here on 10/9 under the heated pergola and it was such a great event! The space in the evening with all of the lights in the back area was so pretty! All my guests were remarking how cute, cozy and perfect the space was! Drink selection was great and Lexi helped with any and everything during the event. Communication prior was simple and easy! the heated pergola was also an amazing touch for a fall night! definitely recommend hosting your event here!

Loading...