Snyder's Tavern

4161 NY-28A, West Shokan
(845) 657-8873

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jeffrey Phelan

Just a Bar, no food. But they are always pleasant to sit with. And of course, it looks haunted on the outside, but typical well stocked bar on the inside.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

S 4

Wendigo.....!

Sam Leahy

Pretty unwelcoming environment. We (mid 20’s, clearly from the city but respectful, polite, & smiling, especially because we’re visitors to the town) popped in at 4:30pm on a Saturday after reading positive reviews and everyone immediately turned and stared (like continuous cold stares) at us without so much as a smile or nod when we walked in. The older gentleman who was behind the bar did not show any interest in helping us, even after my female friend and I walked up to the bar and politely smiled after saying hello. He proceeded to offer to help 2 other folks (and finished serving them) and then started to walk to the back— still without even saying hello or asking if we wanted anything.

It actually took another gentleman sat at the bar (Thank you to him! Appreciate his humanity & kindness) to say “Hey, why don’t you help out these folks first” for him to finally turn to us (mind you, we were standing there clearly politely waiting since we had tentatively walked in).

Would not recommend going to Snyder’s if you’re queer, Black, and/or from the city and present in any way as “alternative”. Even if you’re nice, polite, & respectful, you will probably be made to feel uncomfortable and unwelcome, which was too bad. We ended up having an excuse to leave because they don’t have an ATM and are cash only, but honestly would have left anyway because they didn’t want us there and the bartender, at least, made that extremely clear.

Bottom line is we just wanted a drink, to support local, and play a game of pool to celebrate our girl’s bday. Would have been awesome if we could have done that. Don’t worry, old paranoid white men and women of Snyder’s, we won’t be back, no need to lose any sleep at night over it. :)

Edit: We mentioned this experience to a co-worker who lives part time in Phoenicia and she said if we’d told her we were thinking of going she would have said never to step foot in there because the building used to be covered in Trump flags. Honestly, given that the hostility is still the same I don’t know why they took them down, would save a lot of folks time!

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

christine tessitore

A Saturday at 3:00. No one there but bartender and 2 local gentleman. Not much interaction. But we loved being there. Very old and funky and clean. As we left, we talked a little. Great Americans. ??

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Tom Dragna

Very welcoming bartenders and crowd. Felt like home on a cold winter evening. Will find an excuse to come

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

R Worrier (Roadworrier)

No food at this tavern but Beverages and accommodating bar tender. We quite enjoyed going there after years of wanting to go.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 4

Damian gutman

My favorite bar

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Radhy Pena

Want to see an old historical bar that looks scary at night? This is the place. Everyone was nice, but the building itself looks haunted. Check it out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Daan

My favorite

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

A Warner

Classic!

Kevin Brown

Drinks mixed at the 100% perfect ratio. Rum, 5 ice cubes and just enough soda the taint the color. All that for the best price I've had one for in a decade. Can't beat the place in my opinion.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Joseph Pane

Love this place. Don’t let the curb appeal fool you . Chester takes good care of his patrons .

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Grant

If you want to go to a TRUE HOMETOWN JOINT then YOU better stop at Snyder's Tavern. The owner is behind the bar and the Old School Olive Alum are on the stools tipping'em back. Beer is cold and the Pepsi-Cola is in a can?...... a TRUE OLD SCHOOL GREAT DIVE BAR????.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Diesel tech Farm.

If you’re a local, definitely a nice quiet little place to get a drink. Nothing fancy and if you want bar food it’s going to come out of a bag, there’s no kitchen.

Jay

No words can describe how much this place makes me happy!

Loading...