Benjamin Steakhouse
610 Hartsdale Rd, White Plains
(914) 428-6868
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Service from Vincenzo and the entire staff was outstanding! Our steaks were cooked perfect and sides were delicious
Excellent food. Staff was not attentive between serving courses. We had to call someone over several times with a fuss on our part. But the food all arrived together with each course and was magnificent.
Best SteakHouse in Westchester. Everything was amazing from Service to staff and food ! Our favorite place to go.
Our food was horrible I've been coming to Benjamin's for years it was my worst experience.
Came for New Year's Eve. Overall food was amazing as usual. They had a more limited menu for the holiday which was fine because they kept all the classics. The service was a little on the slow side but expected due to the holiday and the volume of people.
This is the third time we have gone to Benjamin's on NYE. Festive environment, great food and service.
My wife and I had gone to Benjamin's in July and it wasn't at the level we'd experienced in earlier visits. Not expecting a response, I wrote a review that wasn't harsh but described our letdown. So I was pleasantly surprised when it didn't take long to get a response from Benjamin's. Michael at Benjamin's asked us to contact him and I did. Without going into detail, they went above and beyond what I would have expected and when we went there a couple of months later we had a fantastic dinner - the steaks were perfect as was everything else. I was delighted to experience a restaurant standing behind its reputation and this is one of those rare instances where I'd give more than 5 stars if this site made that possible. My wife and I were both extremely appreciative and impressed!
We always enjoy dining here because the service is top notch and the food is consistently good. It was nicely decorated with lights for the holidays. My steak this time was overly salty though, which was kind of strange for this place. The desserts could use some improvement, they were good but not excellent. Finally, I specifically ordered a decaf cappuccino, it was served too hot with hardly any froth and I suspect was not decaf. Overall we had a fantastic experience, but possibly these small critiques will reach the management at the restaurant and will be rectified for future guests.
Our experience was just average. The parties ordered petite filet mignon medium well, and it came to us cooked medium. Although the waiter was polite, he was hovering over us which made us feel rushed throughout our experience. There are too many servers, but they congregated by the entrance to the restaurant and it is a bad look. I do want to send my thanks for a birthday treat that was on the house from the manager.
We had Restaurant Week menu and it was very good. The Service was a little disorganized and they did not have enough desserts when they served our table.
Restaurantji Recommends
Im a fan of Benjamins Steakhouse. 1st experience was in Manhattan. Liked it soo much...went back 5 days later This is my 2nd time Patronizing the hartadale venue. 1st time I walked away as a true fan & would be back. However...this time..not sure if it were due to restaurant week....but I left feeling ... ill never return again. I had a party of 12 & five experienced stomach woes. For one patron....they did not like the pasta. It was said...too much diary was used. Even the dinner rolls....did not taste fresh Ill try the manhattan location one more time. But doubt ill ever return to Hartsdale
Remains one of our family's favorite restaurants. The food (particularly the steaks and sides) are outstanding, and the servers are always on point.
My rib eye steak was tough and tastless. Mashed potatoes tasted like a box mix variety. The filet mignon was good.
It was an amazing experience. The Valet was on point. We were greeted warmly and welcomed. Our waiter was patient and attentive. He met our needs and made us feel welcomed. The food was better than I anticipated. My Steak was cooked to perfection. The brunch offerings were not at all what I expected, there were no eggs and mimosas. But nonetheless it was perfect. The brunch menu had delicious offerings. The LOBSTER BISQUE was EVERYTHING.!! Great experience.!
Steak is amazing. Not cheap but it's really good steak. Service is excellent. And it's always consistent. We would rather come back here than risk trying another steak place and being disappointed.
Loading...