Forty Carrots

We had a great waiter, Andy, and wonderful service. He went out of his way to take care of the 3 of us. Food was fresh and good with interesting choices on the limited, but good, menu

I mean for two froyos we paid $35. It tasted like marshmallow and did not taste fresh at all would recommend lulus pleasantville or the reading room Katonah if u want good soft serve

Lipstick on the utensils. When brought up to management they would not comp the full item. Was told “all utensils are double washed, but you know women’s lipstick is hard to get off.” Absolutely unacceptable and disgusting. Women wear lipstick to all sorts of restaurants and this isn’t acceptable anywhere. Wait staff was also coughing without covering their mouths right near utensils and serving. Such a shame and definitely a case for the health department.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Not surprised by the rating or reviews… horrible menu selection and overpriced frozen yogurt.

Finally got to try the famous frozen yogurt and it did not disappoint! Extremely cute cafe, staff was great, very friendly and accommodating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Forty Carrots Chopped Salad

Avocado toast was the worse I have ever had bread wasn’t toasted and the avocado was on the side. I would not recommend ordering this a waste of money.

Food: soup very salty, grilled chicken ok, veggies uncooked. Waitress by a gent did not get his name but he was so nice and very good to his job.
To bad the food was n it great today

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Nice ambiance. The branzino and sides were very fresh. I’m not a frozen yogurt fan but since it’s so popular here, we tried it. I ordered the vanilla yogurt with Melba sauce and it was very creamy and the sauce was a nice touch without being too sweet. Wish that they would have served my frozen yogurt in one of the unique bowls that they had instead of a plastic cup but overall it was nice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Grilled Branzino, Regular Frozen Yogurt

service at forty carrots was absolutely positively inspiringly terrible. We arrived at bloomingdale’s at 3:10. Made our way upstairs to the restaurant to be presented with a 10 minute wait, not their faults there were a bunch of people. The wait staff also had difficulties cleaning off tables but it’s ok. We are seated promptly at 3:20 given menus 2 minutes later. No one comes to take our order until 3:47, which i let slide since a shift change was occurring - that’s not necessarily their faults. Our order was not put in until about 4:02( the receipt never lies) Thus leading to an hour and 27 minute wait (we timed it after a while). Once we were finally able to dig into our meal at 5:03 PM, I am met not only with a the pecans in my salad that i asked to be removed 3 times while the order was taking place, but also my salmon was raw. my waitress is nowhere to be found forcing me to alert the hostess in order to get something done about the raw salmon. THEN it takes another 15 minutes to get a plate of arugula, feta cheese tomatoes and MORE pecans. Insane experience - We literally left at about 6:20.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

First time here with my fiancé and aunt it was absolutely amazing manager Frank was incredible waitress was so sweet and the frozen yogurt was something i will never forget will absolutely come back again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food is awful to be honest we got burnt chicken and a kid burger that smell like fish… It took 1 hr for the food to come to the table and was aside from burnt was cold. If you are in White Plains this is probably the last place you would like to eat in

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Great healthy food

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

I had a wonderful lunch at Forty Carrots. I planned a special event for my teen daughter and a few friends. The girls had a fantastic time. The service was impeccable. The restaurant is glamorous yet cozy. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Roach infested, mice dropping filled cesspool of a kitchen.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

This place is good if you like microwave dinners