This place is a total rip off. This place used have the best big slices out there. Now the slices shrinked so much in size thanks to inflation I asked them why did your slices shrink so much. He lied and said it’s always been the same size thinking I was dumb. They have rude owners who only care about money and like to scam the customers. Don’t go here
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Madelyn
I received a gross pizza from this place never ordering from there again they refused to refund me
Rose Barbagli
Very attentive to the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
J Lee
Great pizza on the go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Algernon H.
I say, I decided to stop in and try this local eatery and, to my delight, it was quite crowded. This is typically the sign of a quality eatery! That said, it did take the man behind the counter several minutes to take my order. The litmus test for any pizzeria: a plain and a Sicilian, came out to a whopping $7.75. Even the still-quite-expensive Famiglia down the street is cheaper. My order was ready shortly after placing it but the man yelled for my attention and quite rudely left my order as far as humanely possible away so I had to cross a room, a crowd, and reach over the counter to gather my food. The Sicilian was, I must admit, quite good... but not good enough to justify a price tag of $4.50. The plain was as the name suggests; quite saggy, and nothing to write home about. Poor form, not very sporting Fare: 3/5 Price: $$
Mar Johnson
Pizza is good, but expensive. Delivery driver was very rude because I didn't speak Spanish and I'm pretty sure I heard him call me a derogatory term over the phone.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Emma Formanly
Best buffalo and plain slice in white plains.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
J. Ford
Really good slice. Last time I grabbed a pie and it was fresh and hot. Really nice taste. The folks are consistent and the price is on par with everyone else in the area. Have been here couple of different times would recommend this
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan M.
I've lived in white plains all my life and have come to Mario's pizzeria daily. I've never had an issue and throughout the years I've noticed it's the same workers. I cherish them for their hard work but just last night a few hours ago, one of the main workers was being rude towards a customer and scurried him off. I myself did not tolerate that disrespect and allowed him to talk to me in that manner, the worker then proceeded to come outside initiated he wanted to fight and he claimed I didn't know who I was messing with. Luckily my good pal was there to stop me to tell him to ignore him before I beat him badly but I demand a refund and I will go there tomorrow for it!
Marie G.
Great food and prices. I just had to have some NY pizza so my second day in NY it was happening! I was in town for my neice's wedding and my family was busy with preparations for the wedding the following morning so I was on my own for the day. Believe me, I know how to entertain myself! I had delivery from Mario's brought to my hotel as I got caught up on emails and my Yelp reviews! Pizza and Yelp Make a great combo
I've tried alot of pizza all around the U.S. and this one is still my favorite. I try to get it anytime I pass thru the state of New York. My favorite slices are the Buffalo chicken and The chicken marsala.
Food: 5
Peter Iannace
Owners and staff are great and polite. They appear to appreciate your business especially given the choices we have in WP.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian, Regular Slice
Lisa D.
Mario's is consistent. I have ordered the Mario's special pizza pie and the custom fried calzones (OMG!). All delicious! The cannolis and cheese cake are yummy too! I can't wait to try their pastas and sandwiches too! They don't disappoint.
Ari X.
Yuck, not good pizza. Taste like hot dough, would only go if no other options at all. Other places around are much better
Juan Andres Peralta
Best pizza in WP area, also best service at the store, they just gotta make sure they have enough staff for the amount of calls the receive at the day, the guy in the front can’t do it all.
This place is a total rip off. This place used have the best big slices out there. Now the slices shrinked so much in size thanks to inflation I asked them why did your slices shrink so much. He lied and said it’s always been the same size thinking I was dumb. They have rude owners who only care about money and like to scam the customers. Don’t go here
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
I received a gross pizza from this place never ordering from there again they refused to refund me
Very attentive to the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great pizza on the go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I say, I decided to stop in and try this local eatery and, to my delight, it was quite crowded. This is typically the sign of a quality eatery! That said, it did take the man behind the counter several minutes to take my order. The litmus test for any pizzeria: a plain and a Sicilian, came out to a whopping $7.75. Even the still-quite-expensive Famiglia down the street is cheaper. My order was ready shortly after placing it but the man yelled for my attention and quite rudely left my order as far as humanely possible away so I had to cross a room, a crowd, and reach over the counter to gather my food. The Sicilian was, I must admit, quite good... but not good enough to justify a price tag of $4.50. The plain was as the name suggests; quite saggy, and nothing to write home about. Poor form, not very sporting Fare: 3/5 Price: $$
Pizza is good, but expensive. Delivery driver was very rude because I didn't speak Spanish and I'm pretty sure I heard him call me a derogatory term over the phone.
Food: 4
Service: 1
Best buffalo and plain slice in white plains.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really good slice. Last time I grabbed a pie and it was fresh and hot. Really nice taste. The folks are consistent and the price is on par with everyone else in the area. Have been here couple of different times would recommend this
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've lived in white plains all my life and have come to Mario's pizzeria daily. I've never had an issue and throughout the years I've noticed it's the same workers. I cherish them for their hard work but just last night a few hours ago, one of the main workers was being rude towards a customer and scurried him off. I myself did not tolerate that disrespect and allowed him to talk to me in that manner, the worker then proceeded to come outside initiated he wanted to fight and he claimed I didn't know who I was messing with. Luckily my good pal was there to stop me to tell him to ignore him before I beat him badly but I demand a refund and I will go there tomorrow for it!
Great food and prices. I just had to have some NY pizza so my second day in NY it was happening! I was in town for my neice's wedding and my family was busy with preparations for the wedding the following morning so I was on my own for the day. Believe me, I know how to entertain myself! I had delivery from Mario's brought to my hotel as I got caught up on emails and my Yelp reviews! Pizza and Yelp Make a great combo
Restaurantji Recommends
I've tried alot of pizza all around the U.S. and this one is still my favorite. I try to get it anytime I pass thru the state of New York. My favorite slices are the Buffalo chicken and The chicken marsala.
Food: 5
Owners and staff are great and polite. They appear to appreciate your business especially given the choices we have in WP.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian, Regular Slice
Mario's is consistent. I have ordered the Mario's special pizza pie and the custom fried calzones (OMG!). All delicious! The cannolis and cheese cake are yummy too! I can't wait to try their pastas and sandwiches too! They don't disappoint.
Yuck, not good pizza. Taste like hot dough, would only go if no other options at all. Other places around are much better
Best pizza in WP area, also best service at the store, they just gotta make sure they have enough staff for the amount of calls the receive at the day, the guy in the front can’t do it all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4