Really poor service by these guys,Walked into the diner at 9:19 PM on Friday 3/8/2024, and some old guy folding boxes just stared at me. I walked up to the counter and said "Hi, how are you" No response. I shrugged and continued "can I order a personal Pepperoni with--" he cut me off and said "No we're not making any more pizzas". I asked why the Neon "Open" sign was still lit in the front window, but received no response. I chuckled partly in amusement, partly in disbelief, and walked out.I guess their store hours (Open til 10pm) don't apply anymore. Definitely avoiding this place for good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ole J.
No matter what you order owner Mike and his staff put their hearts into your dish or pie. I have been ordering pies from them for more than twenty years now and all my kids are hooked too. Two of my boys moved to the west coast and the first thing they want when they get back is Nonna's pizza. It's just as good if not better than any boro or NYC pizza and that's why we love it. Mike keep at it, you make many families happy!!!!
amy
It’s not what it used to be. A loss for the neighborhood. Food not flavorful. Sadly won’t be going back.
Mike and the boys are great! Their pizza is the BEST!! I can't say enough good things about their food and service. They are so accommodating, not just for that slice of pizza you're craving, but also when you want to cater a party! Go see them if you haven't already!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Cheese Pizza
Itsme I.
Good food, reasonable prices and sweet staff. Ideal pizza place. Love the grandmas slice
Sharlette Carey
Awesome spot with friendly service and good prices. The best part about the pizza was the crust in my opinion. It tastes almost like sourdough and is the perfect crunch on the outside and light and chewy on the inside. The Livia salad was also really impressive and I loved how many people came in happy to see the folks behind the counter during our quick visit. You can tell Nonna’s is a critical key to the community they serve.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bradley Katz
Damn fine spot for Slices and Salad with great prices.
Ren V.
The people who take the orders are absolutely terrible. They make a lot of mistakes and then try to make your customers pay. The gentleman who answers the phone, told me never to call back because I tried to confront him about an overcharge. No customer should ever be treated like that All of this for $10. Food is not as good anyway
Food was delivered 1/2 earlier than requested. They overcharged me, then told me I ordered something I did not. The counter man was nasty and told me not to ever call back because I called him out on his mistake. Food has gone down hill. Obviously, the counter man was not the owner because I do not think any owner of any restaurant would speak to a customer in that manner. After seeing YELP I could not believe so many other people were treated the same way. Very unprofessional!
Jill Goldstein
Fantastic pizza, salads, ziti, chicken Parm, eggplant... We are huge fans & have been for many years. We always get it to go or delivery. Highly recommend!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
M G
Pizza is delicious, my favorite around here and the food in general is so good !!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicole G
Pizza is delicious, my favorite around here and the food in general is so good !!!!
Really poor service by these guys,Walked into the diner at 9:19 PM on Friday 3/8/2024, and some old guy folding boxes just stared at me. I walked up to the counter and said "Hi, how are you" No response. I shrugged and continued "can I order a personal Pepperoni with--" he cut me off and said "No we're not making any more pizzas". I asked why the Neon "Open" sign was still lit in the front window, but received no response. I chuckled partly in amusement, partly in disbelief, and walked out.I guess their store hours (Open til 10pm) don't apply anymore. Definitely avoiding this place for good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
No matter what you order owner Mike and his staff put their hearts into your dish or pie. I have been ordering pies from them for more than twenty years now and all my kids are hooked too. Two of my boys moved to the west coast and the first thing they want when they get back is Nonna's pizza. It's just as good if not better than any boro or NYC pizza and that's why we love it. Mike keep at it, you make many families happy!!!!
It’s not what it used to be. A loss for the neighborhood. Food not flavorful. Sadly won’t be going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Best pizza and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Meat Lovers Pizza
Mike and the boys are great! Their pizza is the BEST!! I can't say enough good things about their food and service. They are so accommodating, not just for that slice of pizza you're craving, but also when you want to cater a party! Go see them if you haven't already!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Cheese Pizza
Good food, reasonable prices and sweet staff. Ideal pizza place. Love the grandmas slice
Awesome spot with friendly service and good prices. The best part about the pizza was the crust in my opinion. It tastes almost like sourdough and is the perfect crunch on the outside and light and chewy on the inside. The Livia salad was also really impressive and I loved how many people came in happy to see the folks behind the counter during our quick visit. You can tell Nonna’s is a critical key to the community they serve.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Damn fine spot for Slices and Salad with great prices.
The people who take the orders are absolutely terrible. They make a lot of mistakes and then try to make your customers pay. The gentleman who answers the phone, told me never to call back because I tried to confront him about an overcharge. No customer should ever be treated like that All of this for $10. Food is not as good anyway
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was delivered 1/2 earlier than requested. They overcharged me, then told me I ordered something I did not. The counter man was nasty and told me not to ever call back because I called him out on his mistake. Food has gone down hill. Obviously, the counter man was not the owner because I do not think any owner of any restaurant would speak to a customer in that manner. After seeing YELP I could not believe so many other people were treated the same way. Very unprofessional!
Fantastic pizza, salads, ziti, chicken Parm, eggplant... We are huge fans & have been for many years. We always get it to go or delivery. Highly recommend!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is delicious, my favorite around here and the food in general is so good !!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is delicious, my favorite around here and the food in general is so good !!!!
They have really good burgers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5