Papi’ Italian Street Food
19 Bank St, White Plains
(914) 328-6535
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
To say I didn’t see this business closing would be a lie. They were breaking even as far as I could remember. Food was good but was not as fast pace as they claimed. They’re overpriced because they didn’t have as much business as they thought they would. Their pizza dough is frozen as well, decent quality for frozen dough. Not all pastas were made in house and the owner Alessandro is extremely unprofessional along with his baby mother and her terrible attitude . They treat their cook like a pack mule. A majority of their reviews are fake as well because of how slow business was. Terrible location, it was dark and mopey. A ton of better italian places in White Plains. Good sauces as well.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Was very sad to hear that they will be closing the doors. Always had amazing service, delicious food, and has been a go-to lunch spot. The owner and staff are extremely kind and care about the customers.
Wishing them the best of luck and it surely will be missed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gnocchi Pesto, Pepperoni Pizza, Focaccia Gourmet Pizza, Chicken Milano Wrap, Carbonara
This place has really good food. The pizza and the piadine were both excellent, far beyond what I was expecting. The place has been empty both times I went though. I think they could refine the concept a bit and do a better job aiming it at the office lunch crowd. Maybe a few more piadine or other lunch items that aren’t pasta or pizza, eg a salad with chicken. I also think they need to make it look more inviting from the outside - it looked closed until I got up to the window and saw someone behind the counter. Better lighting maybe? Also, a minor thing but it’s annoying that the menu is behind you when you are facing the counter. In any case, the food is great and I’ll be back for more.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Food is soooo good!! We tried the pinsa - their version of pizza and it's delicious!! Also the prosciutto buratta piadine (wrap) is my favorite! Definitely recommend! The spot is great and parking is right across the street makes it super easy to get to! My boys loved it too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a very dark and gloomy restaurant. Atmosphere is uninteresting and quiet as this establishment does not generate much business. Food is okay at best but not worth the prices they charge. Most importantly this establishment has signs on their doors staying “No Public Restroom” which is a violation of NY state law. However, they do have an on sight bathroom that they actively try to discourage patrons from using. I have sent appropriate reports to the white plains zoning office as well as Albany and have been informed an inquiry will be conducted regarding this matter.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Meatballs are amazing. Love the pizza. I order from here often and always get two dinners just for myself.
This place is massively underrated; they secretly have the best pasta in White Plains
Pizza was incredible! Staff very friendly
I work around the area and I stopped by to get an iced coffee on my way to catch the train, I didn’t see it on the menu but the lady told me what would I like so I asked if she had iced caramel coffee she said yes she can make it, when she brought it, it had only 2 cubes of ice and it was a very strong black coffee she put a little bit of milk didn’t stir it and didn’t add any sugar cause it was very bitter, also no whipped cream.. I told her it was very bitter and she went and add more milk but still was bad I asked for my money back and she said she couldn’t give me a refund so I spent almost $6 for something I didn’t get… the worst part is that she said that never happened there and made me feel like that place wasn’t for me.. I have tattoos and 2 piercings one on my nose and one on my eyebrow.. Anyway that’s how she made me feel. Worst service I ever had.
Parking: Hard to find
Restaurantji Recommends
Although quite expensive, the pizza is so good, i recommend getting the large size since you would want more after eating. In my honest opinion, i paid 7-8$ on a small pizza which was quite literally small, but so savery and good. I recommend eating here if your in White Plains, NY
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Really good authentic Italian food. The lentil pasta was amazing. The chef recommended it and it was really good. The food was very well seasoned ( we asked for spicy!). The pizza was really good too.
Delicious pizza. Uniquely textured crust which was far superior to the other “pinsa” style pizza which I had earlier this year in Ferrara Italy.
I ordered a Caesar salad. It was completely covered by dressing. That’s a disaster as I usually eat salad with no dressing or just a little bit to be healthy. The amount of dressing should be the customer’s choice. Besides, the croutons are so soggy that they just taste like stale bread. The positive is that when I asked to add more lettuce because it tastes too salty, the waitress happily helped me.
Meh food overcooked pasta with 'dry' sauce. peperroni Margherita pizza that tasted good but dough was too doughy. For 50$ I hopes it would've been MUCH better. Would not recommend.
Dietary restrictions: Vegan and gluten free although we did not try
Loading...