The wings were amazing. The pizza was good, although not quite what I was expecting. Would go back and dine in as the atmosphere was cool and they serve beer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Marie Jude Hathaway
Stellar service and delicious pizza pies. Finally a healthy alternative to all of the ordinary pizza places around that use subpar flour and ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eric I
amazing pizza! ordered the upside pie (its like an l & b spumoni style pizza) with a utica twist (its a detroit style not a sicilian but similar not as thick) and it was incredible. the sauce was on point, the crust chewy and delicious and the grated cheese on top was perfect…. the owner is incredibly nice and friendly which makes me want to support this pizzeria even more…. do yourself a favor and stop by this place…. you will be happy that you did…. thanks westchester foodies facebook group for highlighting this place… so glad i tried it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pie
John Connor
The metro area has pizzeria loyalists of every slice:, Sicilian, wood-fired, coal-fired, and the traditional round pie. How can you top those heated passions? Now you will try an altogether different ‘za: Utica Pie in White Plains. These pies have the sauce, the toppings below the cheese on top of a sort of Sicilian round pie. It’s cut in squares. This pizza has flavorful cheese that stands up to the toppings. The toppings underneath the cheese come together vastly differently for a much more identifiable ingredient taste. Five of us split the large Caesar salad, the terrific wings, but we couldn’t finish the two large pies: one was pepperoni and the other was sausage, pepper and onions. We were given the reheat directions from owner Sal Torchia. The pizza tastes amazing reheated. Utica Club beer and other upstate brews are ice cold and there’s a decent affordable wine list. Also, there's no Coke or Pepsi - only Boylan sodas on tap. This is a different take on pizza, but an unforgettable performance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Elisabet Perez
My favorite pizza! I recently found this spot is so cozy and customer service is exceptional! Totally recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brett Silverstein
Pizza is consistent (so far - had it twice). Delicious both times. I've had the wings (very solid), South Street Pie (Excellent) and Upside Down pie (better than excellent). Far from a local jaunt as it's about 15-20min away so that should help validate any concerns for people about the quality.I'd love to dine in but a little one at home prevents that but it seems quiet and nice enough for those who can/care to. Beer and such available.Anyways, I hope more people go so they can open on Monday since that's the day of the week i'm less inclined to cook.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christian Pena
Comfort food at its finest. And that extends to the service. The owner clearly takes pride in providing an excellent experience for the people who come to visit.Thank you for making us feel welcome each and every time we go.Kid-friendliness: My kids love going there. The environment is kid friendly with place settings they love to draw on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large 1 Topping Pie, Upside Down Pie, Utica Pie Small
Anne-Marie G.
One star because the hours stated are noon - 10, and there's a sign on the door saying pick up orders by appointment only until 4pm. I SO want to try their pizza and riggies and greens, but I work in WP until noon and no one's ever there. I mean, a pizza place that doesn't do lunch? Ohhh welllll... at least we've got Colony Grill!!
Michael Milano
So glad we ordered from here! Visiting from Rochester NY last weekend, Utica Pie certainly felt like home?The pizza is divine. Restaurant is so clean and beautiful. The attention to detail is strong here. The gentleman who cooked and handed me the pizzas (i can only assume was the owner or GM at the very least) was so sweet and thoughtful. Offered me a beverage while i waited and even made sure i had flat space in my car to store the boxes. He knows what he's doing⭐
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Albany Street
juan jaramillo
These are hands down the best chicken wings I’ve ever had, a truly hidden gem in WP!
A hidden gem of pizza place. The crust is soft but not floppy. It's a little thicker so you can really taste the dough. The seasoning in the sause was amazing. I also got the white pie and it had to be one of the best I've ever had. There are a few tables inside so eating in might be a issue at a busy time. The service was top notch. Very friendly and the place was very clean. They have a selection of beers if you want one. The Utica beer was good. Parking is in the garage behind so you have to walk around the building to get to the front door. They said they deliver to New Rochelle and parts of Larchmont as well so if you are looking to have delivery, definitely hit them up for a pie.Parking: Parking is behind the place in the garage. Got to pay 24/7. Plenty of spots when I went for dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pie
Chris B
Awesome cheese pizza and spicy bbq wings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christy Felice
We first tried this place in November 2022,and we haven't orderd from another pizza place since. It's that good ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keith K.
My wife and I were looking for a deep dish pizza place that we could sit and enjoy an easy dinner. This place was perfect. The interior is done nicely with a semi rustic feel with a few tables. Everything was made fresh to order. The wings were a nice size and could tell they were cooked at the time of ordering and were NOT precooked then refried. Juicy and not dry at all. The Upside Down was exactly what we were looking for. Fresh with a crisp crust and soft inside. The sauce was fresh and not acidic or sweet. The staff and owner could not have been nicer. We will definitely return.
Danielle R.
This pizza isn't your average slice or pie. The cheese pizza has subtle hints of rosemary that make it oh so delightful. The pepperoni is thick cut and artisanal quality. The sauce has a nice balance and you can taste how fresh it is, while still offering a wonderful depth of flavor. The crust though! Run don't walk. It's as if a focaccia and pizza had a crispy doughy love child. It is exquisite! I live close to many places that are supposedly the "best pizza." Utica pie gives them all a run for their money. There isn't anything else like this around and it's worth the journey. I can't wait to try the specialty Utica style upside down pie I've been hearing about! There is a municipal parking lot behind the restaurant, if you can't find a spot right in front.
The wings were amazing. The pizza was good, although not quite what I was expecting. Would go back and dine in as the atmosphere was cool and they serve beer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Stellar service and delicious pizza pies. Finally a healthy alternative to all of the ordinary pizza places around that use subpar flour and ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
amazing pizza! ordered the upside pie (its like an l & b spumoni style pizza) with a utica twist (its a detroit style not a sicilian but similar not as thick) and it was incredible. the sauce was on point, the crust chewy and delicious and the grated cheese on top was perfect…. the owner is incredibly nice and friendly which makes me want to support this pizzeria even more…. do yourself a favor and stop by this place…. you will be happy that you did…. thanks westchester foodies facebook group for highlighting this place… so glad i tried it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pie
The metro area has pizzeria loyalists of every slice:, Sicilian, wood-fired, coal-fired, and the traditional round pie. How can you top those heated passions? Now you will try an altogether different ‘za: Utica Pie in White Plains. These pies have the sauce, the toppings below the cheese on top of a sort of Sicilian round pie. It’s cut in squares. This pizza has flavorful cheese that stands up to the toppings. The toppings underneath the cheese come together vastly differently for a much more identifiable ingredient taste. Five of us split the large Caesar salad, the terrific wings, but we couldn’t finish the two large pies: one was pepperoni and the other was sausage, pepper and onions. We were given the reheat directions from owner Sal Torchia. The pizza tastes amazing reheated. Utica Club beer and other upstate brews are ice cold and there’s a decent affordable wine list. Also, there's no Coke or Pepsi - only Boylan sodas on tap. This is a different take on pizza, but an unforgettable performance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
My favorite pizza! I recently found this spot is so cozy and customer service is exceptional! Totally recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is consistent (so far - had it twice). Delicious both times. I've had the wings (very solid), South Street Pie (Excellent) and Upside Down pie (better than excellent). Far from a local jaunt as it's about 15-20min away so that should help validate any concerns for people about the quality.I'd love to dine in but a little one at home prevents that but it seems quiet and nice enough for those who can/care to. Beer and such available.Anyways, I hope more people go so they can open on Monday since that's the day of the week i'm less inclined to cook.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Comfort food at its finest. And that extends to the service. The owner clearly takes pride in providing an excellent experience for the people who come to visit.Thank you for making us feel welcome each and every time we go.Kid-friendliness: My kids love going there. The environment is kid friendly with place settings they love to draw on.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large 1 Topping Pie, Upside Down Pie, Utica Pie Small
One star because the hours stated are noon - 10, and there's a sign on the door saying pick up orders by appointment only until 4pm. I SO want to try their pizza and riggies and greens, but I work in WP until noon and no one's ever there. I mean, a pizza place that doesn't do lunch? Ohhh welllll... at least we've got Colony Grill!!
So glad we ordered from here! Visiting from Rochester NY last weekend, Utica Pie certainly felt like home?The pizza is divine. Restaurant is so clean and beautiful. The attention to detail is strong here. The gentleman who cooked and handed me the pizzas (i can only assume was the owner or GM at the very least) was so sweet and thoughtful. Offered me a beverage while i waited and even made sure i had flat space in my car to store the boxes. He knows what he's doing⭐
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Albany Street
These are hands down the best chicken wings I’ve ever had, a truly hidden gem in WP!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A hidden gem of pizza place. The crust is soft but not floppy. It's a little thicker so you can really taste the dough. The seasoning in the sause was amazing. I also got the white pie and it had to be one of the best I've ever had. There are a few tables inside so eating in might be a issue at a busy time. The service was top notch. Very friendly and the place was very clean. They have a selection of beers if you want one. The Utica beer was good. Parking is in the garage behind so you have to walk around the building to get to the front door. They said they deliver to New Rochelle and parts of Larchmont as well so if you are looking to have delivery, definitely hit them up for a pie.Parking: Parking is behind the place in the garage. Got to pay 24/7. Plenty of spots when I went for dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Upside Down Pie
Awesome cheese pizza and spicy bbq wings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We first tried this place in November 2022,and we haven't orderd from another pizza place since. It's that good ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I were looking for a deep dish pizza place that we could sit and enjoy an easy dinner. This place was perfect. The interior is done nicely with a semi rustic feel with a few tables. Everything was made fresh to order. The wings were a nice size and could tell they were cooked at the time of ordering and were NOT precooked then refried. Juicy and not dry at all. The Upside Down was exactly what we were looking for. Fresh with a crisp crust and soft inside. The sauce was fresh and not acidic or sweet. The staff and owner could not have been nicer. We will definitely return.
This pizza isn't your average slice or pie. The cheese pizza has subtle hints of rosemary that make it oh so delightful. The pepperoni is thick cut and artisanal quality. The sauce has a nice balance and you can taste how fresh it is, while still offering a wonderful depth of flavor. The crust though! Run don't walk. It's as if a focaccia and pizza had a crispy doughy love child. It is exquisite! I live close to many places that are supposedly the "best pizza." Utica pie gives them all a run for their money. There isn't anything else like this around and it's worth the journey. I can't wait to try the specialty Utica style upside down pie I've been hearing about! There is a municipal parking lot behind the restaurant, if you can't find a spot right in front.