Muscarella's Pizza- Main St. Williamsville
5526 Main St, Williamsville
(716) 204-9020
Customers' Favorites
Large Pizza
Onion Rings
Whole submarine: includes lettuce, tomato & cheese. Onions on request
Sub: Steak Supreme
Sub: Chicken Finger
Sub: Steak
Sub: Stinger
Includes chicken fingers, steak & bacon. Lettuce and tomato on request
Sub: Steak & Sausage
Sub: Turkey Bacon Club
Sub: Hamburger
Sub: Salami
Sub: Vincenzo Special
Sub: Turkey
Sub: Sicilian Pizza Sub
Include lettuce tomato and cheese. onions on request. choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.
Sub: Cheese Baked
Sub: Assorted
Sub: Bacon Cheeseburger
Include lettuce tomato and cheese. onions on request. choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.
Sub: Ham Sahlens
Sub: B.L.T
Sub: Cheeseburger
Sub: Chicken Cordon Blue
Sahlen's ham, chicken fingers and Swiss cheese.
Sub: Grilled Chicken
Sub: Grilled CK Supreme
Sub: Italian Sausage Patty
Sub: Musc Melt
Melted cheddar, bbq chicken fingers, bacon, bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes.
Sub: Pizza
Sub: Tuna
Sub: Vegetarian
Half submarine: includes lettuce, tomato & cheese. Onions on request
Sub Half: Cheeseburger
Sub Half: Turkey
Sub Half: Chicken Finger
Sub Half: Ham Sahlens
Sub Half: Assorted
Sub Half: B.L.T
Sub Half: Bacon Cheeseburger
Sub Half: Cheese Baked
Sub Half: Chicken Cordon Blue
Sub Half: Grilled Chicken
Sub Half: Grilled CK Supreme
Sub Half: Hamburger
Sub Half: Italian Sausage Patty
Sub Half: Musc Melt
Melted cheddar, bbq chicken fingers, bacon, bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes.
Sub Half: Pizza
Sub Half: Salami
Sub Half: Steak Supreme
Sub Half: Steak & Sausage
Sub Half: Stinger
Includes chicken fingers, steak & bacon. Lettuce and tomato on request
Sub Half: Tuna
Sub Half: Turkey Bacon Club
Include lettuce tomato and cheese. onions on request. choice of white or wheat costanzo rolls.
Sub Half: Vegetarian
Sub Half: Vincenzo Special
Sub Half: Sicilian Pizza Sub
Sub Half: Steak
Sides
French Fries
Includes bleu cheese.
Pizza Logs: 5pcs
Five pieces.
Jalapeno Poppers: 5pcs
Fried Cauliflower: 15pcs
BBQ French Fries
Includes bleu cheese. bbq sauced then blackened in oven
Bread Sticks w/Cheese
Fried Dough Sticks
Waffle Fries
Bread Sticks
Onion Rings
Garlic Bread w/Cheese
Fried Mushrooms: 15pcs
Mozzarella Sticks: 5pcs
Five pieces.
Fried Zucchini: 15pcs
Cajun French Fries
Bbq sauced then spiced with our cajun rub then blackened in oven
Tator Tots
Garlic Bread No Cheese
Loaded Fries
Includes bacon and cheddar.
Frankie Fries
Bbq dip included. grilled steak (chopped sirloin) cheddar and french fries.
Loaded Garlic Bread
Includes spinach onions tomatoes and mozzarella cheese.
Sweet Potato Fries w/Honey
Cajun Onion Rings
Bbq sauced then spiced with our cajun rub then blackened in oven
Garlic Bread w/Cheese & Tomato
Loaded Tator Tots
Loaded Waffle FF
Salads
Salad Sm: Gr. Steak Caesar
Salad Lg: Caesar
Salad Sm: Antipasto
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions,ham, cappicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives,green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.
Salad Sm: Gr. Chicken Caesar
Salad Sm: Grilled Chicken
Salad Sm: Steak
Salad Lg: Chefs
Salad Sm: Chicken Finger
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & cheddar.
Salad Lg: Julienne
Salad Sm: Julienne
Salad Sm: Tuna
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.
Salad Sm: Caesar
Salad Sm: Chefs
Salad Lg: Antipasto
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, cappicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives,green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni.
Salad Lg: Tuna
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.
Salad Lg: Grilled Chicken
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese.
Salad Lg: Steak
Includes lettuce, tomato, fried onions, mushrooms & cheddar.
Salad Lg: Gr. Steak Caesar
Salad Lg: Gr. Chicken Caesar
Salad Lg: Chicken Finger
Wings & Fingers
Fingers Sm: 5pcs
Wings: 10pcs
Boneless Wings: 10pcs
Fingers Lg: 10pcs
Wings: 30pcs
Wings: 20pcs
Wings: 50pcs
Boneless Wings: 20pcs
Comes with choice of sauce. can be split 1/2 and 1/2. single order served with 2 bleu cheese double order served with 3 bleu cheese triple order served with 3 bleu cheese and bucket order served with 4 bleu cheese.
Boneless Wings: 30pcs
Comes with choice of sauce. can be split 1/2 and 1/2. single order served with 2 bleu cheese double order served with 3 bleu cheese triple order served with 3 bleu cheese and bucket order served with 4 bleu cheese.
Boneless Wings: 50pcs
Comes with choice of sauce. can be split 1/2 and 1/2. single order served with 2 bleu cheese double order served with 3 bleu cheese triple order served with 3 bleu cheese and bucket order served with 4 bleu cheese.
Fingers XL: 15pcs
Wraps & Sandwiches
SW: Cheeseburger
SW: Cheeseburger Bacon
Wrap: Grlld Chicken Caesar
Wrap: Chicken Finger
Wrap: Vegetarian
Wrap: Grlld Steak Supreme
Wrap: Grlld Steak Caesar
Wrap: Grlld Chicken
Wrap: Grlld CK Supreme
Wrap: Turkey
Wrap: Assorted
Wrap: Tuna
Wrap: Grlld Steak
Wrap: Ham
SW: Hamburger
SW: Italian Sausage
SW: The Super Shroom
SW: Italian Stallion
Wrap: Antipasto
Parm Subs & Fish Fry
Parm: Italian Sausage
Parm Half: Steak
Parm Half: Eggplant
Parm Half: Meatball
Parm Half: Italian Sausage
Parm Half: Chicken Finger
Parm: Steak
Parm: Eggplant
Parm: Meatball
Parm: Chicken Finger
Pizza & Calzones
Personal Pizza
Calzone: Cheese & Pepperoni
Large Pizza
Includes cheese add toppings for an additional charge.
Small Pizza
Colossal Pizza
Includes cheese
Calzone: The "Hog"
Sheet Pizza
Calzone: Chicken Finger
Calzone: The Romano
Calzone: The Works
Calzone: Build Your Own
Calzone: Steak
Calzone: The Hawaiian
Calzone: Broccoli & Cheddar
Calzone: Sicilian
Specialty Pie: Per. & Sm
The Works Pizza: Per.
Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.
The Works Pizza: Sm
Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.
Chicken Finger Pizza: Sm
Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).
Steak Pizza: Per.
Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.
Chicken Finger Pizza: Per.
Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Per.
Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.
Steak Pizza: Sm
Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.
Sicilian Pizza: Sm
Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.
Sicilian Pizza: Per.
Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.
The "Hog" Pizza: Per.
Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.
The Romano Pizza: Per.
Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Sm
Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.
The "Hog" Pizza: Sm
Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.
The Romano Pizza: Sm
Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.
Specialty Pie: Lg & Sht. & Col.
The Works Pizza: Lg
Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.
The Works Pizza: Sheet
Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.
Chicken Finger Pizza: Lg
Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).
The Romano Pizza: Lg
Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.
Steak Pizza: Lg
Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.
Colossal Broccoli & Chedder Pizza
Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.
Colossal Works Pizza
Includes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives.
Colossal Chicken Finger Pizza
Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Lg
Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.
Sicilian Pizza: Lg
Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.
The "Hog" Pizza: Lg
Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.
Colossal Steak Pizza
Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.
Colossal Sicilian Pizza
Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.
Colossal Hog Pizza
Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.
Colossal Romano Pizza
Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.
Chicken Finger Pizza: Sheet
Blue cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses ( tomato & lettuce optional).
Broccoli & Cheddar Pizza: Sheet
Olive oil, spices, 2 cheese and broccoli florets.
Steak Pizza: Sheet
Made either red(with sauce) or white (with oil& garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot & sweet peppers.
Sicilian Pizza: Sheet
Made with 100% olive oil,fresh tomatoes,onions, asiago cheese & spices.
The "Hog" Pizza: Sheet
Includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage& ham.
The Romano Pizza: Sheet
Includes romano cheese, sauteed onions & hot peppers.
Beverages
Loganberry: 20oz
Cherry Coke: 2 Liter
Root Beer: 20oz
Cherry Coke: 20oz
Water
Loganberry: 2 Liter
Coke: 20oz
Diet Coke: 20oz
2L Orange
Orange Soda:20oz
Sprite: 20oz
Diet Coke: 2 Liter
Sprite: 2 Liter
Coke: 2 Liter
Fusion Iced Tea: 20oz
Dasani: 20oz
Lemonade: 20oz
Pink Lemonade: 20oz
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best Buffalo style Pizza in WNY! Hands down! I have had tons of Buffalo pizza and this place is my favorite. It has the most flavor in a pizza. I also love the crispy pepperonis. It’s a hidden gem of a place and a must try! This place is my favorite and Picasso’s is my second. All other Buffalo pizza is tied for third.
June 2025
Was really surprised by how good the pizza and wings were. We are normally a fan of Picasso's and I am not from Buffalo New York I grew up about an hour and a half outside of Buffalo. I moved to the Buffalo area like five or six years ago and have tried a lot of pizza places around here. Muscarellas is up there in like top five. Also it was $20 cheaper to get pizza and wings here then it would have been to get it from Picasso's you can't go wrong with that.
January 2025
Our favorite local shop. Not much seating for dining in, but that doesn't bother us since we always pick up. Great all around Buffalo pizza, and seriously, try the garlic/parm crust!
October 2024
You May Also Like
overwinter coffee - williamsville - 5548 Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee Roasteries, Coffee, Pet Friendly
Chef Marco - 5500 Main St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Italian
Glen Park Tavern - 5507 Main St
![]()
American, Beer Bar, Bar, Pubs