Too much going on there. Stuff all over the counter. Subs were expensive and both had a funny taste. We could not quite describe? (Pepper?old oil in dressing?) Dining area needs to be cleaned out, old and dusty. Garbage cans outside were overflowing, open and smelled awful walking up to the place. Maybe a smaller menu will help them with quality food. Wasn’t good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Tim Rydzewski
1st timer trying Matty's. Called in for a large pep, fresh mushroom, and garlic pie. We'll be back again soon. The pizza was absolutely amazing. From the dough and crust to the perfect cook time and perfect amount of toppings. Their sauce (We ordered their regular sauce) was really good. Next time I'm ordering extra sauce because it was so pleasing. Keep up the good work Matty's! I HIGHLY recommend giving this establishment a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Briel Steen
Great New York Pizza 🍕 a hidden gem. Great service. Met THE Matty. Legend. Family owned business for over 30 years and you can see why. Great prices, great quality
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BJean Gammi
31 July 2025 This Pizzeria was definitely a surprise. We dropped in here for a salad order because we just got to town. The place was really busy with online and phone orders. They took our order (two salads) saying it would be about 20 minutes. After a 30 minute wait I asked about my order they said it would be another 10 minutes. We were waiting outside they said they'd bring out our order. After 15 minutes a lady yells out the door that we could come in and pick up our order. HOW RUDE! Yes, the salads were very good, but the service really is messed up. 3 August 2025 We decided to try Matty's Pizzeria again but this time we called in our order on the phone for pizza then gave a time for pickup. In this case the pizza was ready to go and the in store service was fantastic! That was definitely a plus after the first time ordering here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Mark Taber
Had pizza and a sub all were for takeout. All were very good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Thomas Foster
Excellent pizza and wings. Friendly staff. Very popular with locals apparently, as there was a steady stream of customers moving through as I waited. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carmen Bucco
Not only was the food amazing but the staff is so humble. I had to go back because I dropped my salad all over the drive way at my Airbnb. Not only did they remake it. They wouldn't let me pay not even a tip. This is not only service but goes to show what kind of establishment this is. Run by a truly amazing leader. I will be back and you would regret not trying their salads with their homemade dressings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Dishunts
The place was awesome, good ambiance, people were friendly. Recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan Gallagher
Pizza is terrible. Have tried it several times. Terrible.
Food: 1
Hector Martinez Colon
Friendly service, They have 18 inches long sub sandwiches. Reasonable prices. It was fun to watch the toy train that goes around.
Stopped in for a quick bite. Great slices and they sell homemade dog treats that our pooches can't get enough of. Hidden gem status.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
mandy tatu
Just moved to area. Food was delicious cooked perfectly and the customer service was also amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone
Tanlyn Duwe
Always allow second chances. Sadly, it's been years since I've had the food here. I was greatly surprised at the quality! Where can you get a fish fry on a Monday?! Right here and it was good! We had a steak and cheese sub over all delicious! Thinking fresh baked roll as well. Lastly, a calzone. All and and all it was delicious, yeah, a bit pricy, but tastey 😀
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hoagies, Calzone
jane lynn
Listen, I came here for the pizza, but stayed for the Keirson - the absolute heartthrob of the kitchen. I mean, sure, the pizza is chefs kiss, but the Keirson, the pizza maestro, is the real reason i'm a regular now... I'm convinced those pepperonis sizzle more when he's the one making the pie. 10/10 would recommend for both pizza lovers and admires of hot pizza makers. If you’re not ordering from here, you're missing out on the full meal deal. Wish I could order him to-go
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryson Frerichs
I was ringing on the phone for 20 minutes. They always seem like they don't want to be there
Too much going on there. Stuff all over the counter. Subs were expensive and both had a funny taste. We could not quite describe? (Pepper?old oil in dressing?) Dining area needs to be cleaned out, old and dusty. Garbage cans outside were overflowing, open and smelled awful walking up to the place. Maybe a smaller menu will help them with quality food. Wasn’t good.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
1st timer trying Matty's. Called in for a large pep, fresh mushroom, and garlic pie. We'll be back again soon. The pizza was absolutely amazing. From the dough and crust to the perfect cook time and perfect amount of toppings. Their sauce (We ordered their regular sauce) was really good. Next time I'm ordering extra sauce because it was so pleasing. Keep up the good work Matty's! I HIGHLY recommend giving this establishment a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great New York Pizza 🍕 a hidden gem. Great service. Met THE Matty. Legend. Family owned business for over 30 years and you can see why. Great prices, great quality
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
31 July 2025 This Pizzeria was definitely a surprise. We dropped in here for a salad order because we just got to town. The place was really busy with online and phone orders. They took our order (two salads) saying it would be about 20 minutes. After a 30 minute wait I asked about my order they said it would be another 10 minutes. We were waiting outside they said they'd bring out our order. After 15 minutes a lady yells out the door that we could come in and pick up our order. HOW RUDE! Yes, the salads were very good, but the service really is messed up.
3 August 2025 We decided to try Matty's Pizzeria again but this time we called in our order on the phone for pizza then gave a time for pickup. In this case the pizza was ready to go and the in store service was fantastic! That was definitely a plus after the first time ordering here.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Had pizza and a sub all were for takeout. All were very good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Excellent pizza and wings. Friendly staff. Very popular with locals apparently, as there was a steady stream of customers moving through as I waited. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not only was the food amazing but the staff is so humble. I had to go back because I dropped my salad all over the drive way at my Airbnb. Not only did they remake it. They wouldn't let me pay not even a tip. This is not only service but goes to show what kind of establishment this is. Run by a truly amazing leader. I will be back and you would regret not trying their salads with their homemade dressings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The place was awesome, good ambiance, people were friendly. Recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is terrible. Have tried it several times. Terrible.
Food: 1
Friendly service, They have 18 inches long sub sandwiches. Reasonable prices. It was fun to watch the toy train that goes around.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in for a quick bite. Great slices and they sell homemade dog treats that our pooches can't get enough of. Hidden gem status.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Just moved to area. Food was delicious cooked perfectly and the customer service was also amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone
Always allow second chances. Sadly, it's been years since I've had the food here. I was greatly surprised at the quality! Where can you get a fish fry on a Monday?! Right here and it was good! We had a steak and cheese sub over all delicious! Thinking fresh baked roll as well. Lastly, a calzone. All and and all it was delicious, yeah, a bit pricy, but tastey 😀
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hoagies, Calzone
Listen, I came here for the pizza, but stayed for the Keirson - the absolute heartthrob of the kitchen. I mean, sure, the pizza is chefs kiss, but the Keirson, the pizza maestro, is the real reason i'm a regular now... I'm convinced those pepperonis sizzle more when he's the one making the pie. 10/10 would recommend for both pizza lovers and admires of hot pizza makers. If you’re not ordering from here, you're missing out on the full meal deal.
Wish I could order him to-go
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was ringing on the phone for 20 minutes. They always seem like they don't want to be there
Loading...