These ladies are extremely hardworking and very kind. Their cookies taste amazing, especially the Italian ricotta cookies. Love them and their cookies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anya S
A small town cookie store with amazing tasting cookies (my favorite is the pumpkin one with the frosting on top!) Nice and caring people, smiles every time I’m in the shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peggy Teal
Adorable shop with the most delicious cookies ever! There are always a variety of flavors and all are amazing! Prices are very fair. The service is outstanding! Always friendly and smiling. I always look forward to stopping in when I pass through town. Most highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marci Weber
The cookies are delicious and so cute. Love the iced sugar cookies and that they can customize them for your occasion. The peanut butter cookies are heavenly. Call ahead for larger orders, and they can have them ready for you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Carney
Cozy little place, Lots of cookie flavors that cycle daily, mini cheesecakes and other desserts as well. Hoover's milks and beverages, and all of the nut-related cookies are separate from the rest to prevent cross contamination. Owners are super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ruth L Steinagle
The cookies are great. They’re just too busy right now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chase Rossman
Was visiting for The Weekend and it had an amazing smell the money you walked in the door! The staff was friendly and super helpful and had our order ready to go!
Julie Branch
If you ever wondered what it would smell like upon entering the gates of Heaven, stop in The Cookie Cottage! Tons of choices, tons of local goods for sale in their shop, and these ladies are the warmest, friendliest bakers in Western New York!!
Samantha Bell
The cookies turned out amazing. My daughter is really into the Avatar movies and they made these look so cute! She was over the moon and they always taste great! My family has ordered from them several times and they turn our amazing each time. If you are looking for cute cookies with really good pricing this is the place to go! We ordered 3 dozen cookies and it was the perfect amount plus they can package them individually! Very convenient for school or parties!
Christopher Srock
Great little Bakery that has Hoovers Dairy milk too
Excellent cookies with lots of fun flavors! The staff is also super nice ?
Kate
Very affordable prices and everyone is so friendly! They have different cookie flavors throughout the week. In addition to cookies, they carry other local products as well including Hoover’s milk and DiCamillo’s bread. 10/10 would recommend.
Becky
The best cookies in WNY!! So many varieties! The owners are very friendly and very accomadating. If you want the best cookies around, take a drive to Wilson! You won't be dissappointed but go early they sell out quick or call to place your order! I go as soon as they are open on Saturday morning!!
Amber Nimmo
My husband, daughter, and I have been going here since it opened. We love them - the cookies are amazing, the staff is SUPER friendly, and they’re always willing to accommodate us. They’ve done cookies for my daughter’s birthdays and my sister’s wedding. Christine and Anna have become real friends ❤️ We love them!!!
Amanda Mckernan
This is one of best places to get cookies from! Every flavor is just so amazing and they will literally bend over backwards for pre orders or special requests if they can. They do a fantastic job of communicating with their customers too, via social media, phone, etc. I've never known a business to actually put out updates daily with what they have in stock, their hours, you name it!!
These ladies are extremely hardworking and very kind. Their cookies taste amazing, especially the Italian ricotta cookies. Love them and their cookies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A small town cookie store with amazing tasting cookies (my favorite is the pumpkin one with the frosting on top!) Nice and caring people, smiles every time I’m in the shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adorable shop with the most delicious cookies ever! There are always a variety of flavors and all are amazing! Prices are very fair. The service is outstanding! Always friendly and smiling. I always look forward to stopping in when I pass through town. Most highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cookies are delicious and so cute. Love the iced sugar cookies and that they can customize them for your occasion. The peanut butter cookies are heavenly. Call ahead for larger orders, and they can have them ready for you!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cozy little place, Lots of cookie flavors that cycle daily, mini cheesecakes and other desserts as well. Hoover's milks and beverages, and all of the nut-related cookies are separate from the rest to prevent cross contamination. Owners are super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cookies are great. They’re just too busy right now.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was visiting for The Weekend and it had an amazing smell the money you walked in the door! The staff was friendly and super helpful and had our order ready to go!
If you ever wondered what it would smell like upon entering the gates of Heaven, stop in The Cookie Cottage! Tons of choices, tons of local goods for sale in their shop, and these ladies are the warmest, friendliest bakers in Western New York!!
The cookies turned out amazing. My daughter is really into the Avatar movies and they made these look so cute! She was over the moon and they always taste great! My family has ordered from them several times and they turn our amazing each time. If you are looking for cute cookies with really good pricing this is the place to go! We ordered 3 dozen cookies and it was the perfect amount plus they can package them individually! Very convenient for school or parties!
Great little Bakery that has Hoovers Dairy milk too
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent cookies with lots of fun flavors! The staff is also super nice ?
Very affordable prices and everyone is so friendly! They have different cookie flavors throughout the week. In addition to cookies, they carry other local products as well including Hoover’s milk and DiCamillo’s bread. 10/10 would recommend.
The best cookies in WNY!! So many varieties! The owners are very friendly and very accomadating. If you want the best cookies around, take a drive to Wilson! You won't be dissappointed but go early they sell out quick or call to place your order! I go as soon as they are open on Saturday morning!!
My husband, daughter, and I have been going here since it opened. We love them - the cookies are amazing, the staff is SUPER friendly, and they’re always willing to accommodate us. They’ve done cookies for my daughter’s birthdays and my sister’s wedding. Christine and Anna have become real friends ❤️ We love them!!!
This is one of best places to get cookies from! Every flavor is just so amazing and they will literally bend over backwards for pre orders or special requests if they can. They do a fantastic job of communicating with their customers too, via social media, phone, etc. I've never known a business to actually put out updates daily with what they have in stock, their hours, you name it!!