Honeymoon dinner! Everything was absolutely delicious! The women working here are so kind and attentive! Cocktails are a bit pricey but overall the meal was not that bad! The 42oz porterhouse for two was totally worth it! At $110.00 I believe you got enough food for the price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Baked Potato
Linor Rokhlin
Mediocre, overpriced food
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Aanin Limbu
My family had gone to the restaurant, but the experience was incredibly disappointing. The waitress stalled them for over 30 minutes, claiming they needed a reservation. When they went online to book one, there were plenty of openings, and the restaurant itself had several empty tables. When they pointed that out, the waitress told them she could seat them at 8:30 and that the restaurant closes at 9:30. They agreed, trying to be understanding.
When it’s finally 8:30, my family called her over again, only to be told, “Sorry, we’re full… we cannot take you guys.” It was frustrating and disrespectful. If she had told them earlier that they wouldn’t be seated, they could’ve simply left instead of wasting nearly an hour waiting. When my cousin politely said, “I would’ve appreciated it if you could’ve let us know earlier,” the waitress snapped back, “I would’ve appreciated if you had a reservation.”
The whole exchange felt dismissive and unnecessary, and sadly, it was hard not to feel that her behavior was discriminatory, especially since my family is Asian. What should’ve been a simple dining experience turned into something deeply disappointing and hurtful. 0/5
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Simran Gauchan
The most racist restaurant! Me and my parents went there to eat and they told us we had to reserve online. After checking online, they still didn’t take our reservations and had us wait outside. After waiting more than 30 minutes, they told they can’t let us in but the restaurant was pretty empty. The host was very rude and she kept throwing mean looks at us. I feel worse because my parents didn’t deserve to be treated like that when all they wanted to do was eat with their daughter. Worst experience ever! Do not waste your time going here if you’re a colored person.
Kadambini Gurung
Extremely disappointing and discriminatory experience. We waited over 30 minutes while the restaurant was nearly empty, only to be told we couldn’t dine in. The staff kept hovering and watching us the entire time, which felt very uncomfortable and unwelcoming.
When I pointed out that we could have left instead of waiting so long, the staff member was rude and simply said, “It would be nice if you had a reservation,” instead of acknowledging their poor treatment.
In the end, they refused to let us dine in at all. This felt blatantly unfair and racist. No customer should ever be treated this way.
Kristina (Kris1234)
We did a catering order from Lilly's for my birthday. She was incredibly responsive, professional, and friendly. The food was great. My favorite was the grilled salmon. The roast beef was also a hit. Next time I'm in the area, I'll definitely be stopping in.
Abigail Adams
Nicole made our night so wonderful! I’ve had such a bad day but this experience completely turned my day around. The food was delicious, service was wonderful and I can’t wait to come back!
A T
One of the best steaks ive had even as a delivery order, and the whole staff was accomodating and sweet getting it to our air B&B. High reccommend if visiting the area!
Mike L
I went here for my birthday, I got the 18oz bone in ribeye and it was honestly possibly the best steak I have ever had in my life. Nice and crispy on the outside and cooked perfectly on the inside.
This restaurant was recommended to us. I have to say it was a delight. As we entered I request a boot , for my back. The hostess gladly catered to my needs. We were handed a menu and also a iPad to view how our food would look . The waitress was a lovely lady. Happy and had a laugh with us. The food was delicious. I started with the Brie and my husband had the portobello mushroom. Then he had a steak, which he loved , I had the battered fish and chips. Which was a very large portion. Could not finish as the Brie was a meal in its self. No complaints with the food. The bill came and my husband left his wallet in the car. I explained to the waitress. She said it was okay as there were plenty of dishes to wash. We had a good laugh about it . We are Irish and enjoy a good banter. While he was gone I looked at the bill. 3% added for credit card and another 3% of the bill for operating fee. I questioned it with the waitress. A new charge for POS. SERIOUSLY. We eat out a lot in manhattan and surrounding areas. I have never seen this before. I refused to pay 6% extra on top of a tip for the wonderful waitress. I had cash in my wallet, as I like to tip with cash as I have two children who work for the summer in restaurants and I tip generously for good service. I paid for the meal in cash. Overall. Food was good , service was a delight . We shall not be returning WATCH YOUR BILL
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Thurka Gnanasakthy
Our server Nicole was absolutely wonderful! It was our first time there and she was so helpful on picking the right food and getting to know us. The food was very delicious and I would highly recommend it for anyone visiting the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Raven Hughes
Really good food and service.
Lynda Molino
We all loved our meals. The service was exceptional and the atmosphere is very welcoming and pleasant. Highly recommend!
Lynda Molino
Fabulous meal! Everyone in our party of 7 raved about their meal. Portions were generous. Our server Valerie was superb, lovely personality and extremely attentive. Treat yourself to dinner at Lilly’s!
Honeymoon dinner!
Everything was absolutely delicious! The women working here are so kind and attentive! Cocktails are a bit pricey but overall the meal was not that bad!
The 42oz porterhouse for two was totally worth it! At $110.00 I believe you got enough food for the price!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak, Baked Potato
Mediocre, overpriced food
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
My family had gone to the restaurant, but the experience was incredibly disappointing. The waitress stalled them for over 30 minutes, claiming they needed a reservation. When they went online to book one, there were plenty of openings, and the restaurant itself had several empty tables. When they pointed that out, the waitress told them she could seat them at 8:30 and that the restaurant closes at 9:30. They agreed, trying to be understanding.
When it’s finally 8:30, my family called her over again, only to be told, “Sorry, we’re full… we cannot take you guys.” It was frustrating and disrespectful. If she had told them earlier that they wouldn’t be seated, they could’ve simply left instead of wasting nearly an hour waiting. When my cousin politely said, “I would’ve appreciated it if you could’ve let us know earlier,” the waitress snapped back, “I would’ve appreciated if you had a reservation.”
The whole exchange felt dismissive and unnecessary, and sadly, it was hard not to feel that her behavior was discriminatory, especially since my family is Asian. What should’ve been a simple dining experience turned into something deeply disappointing and hurtful. 0/5
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
The most racist restaurant! Me and my parents went there to eat and they told us we had to reserve online. After checking online, they still didn’t take our reservations and had us wait outside. After waiting more than 30 minutes, they told they can’t let us in but the restaurant was pretty empty. The host was very rude and she kept throwing mean looks at us. I feel worse because my parents didn’t deserve to be treated like that when all they wanted to do was eat with their daughter. Worst experience ever! Do not waste your time going here if you’re a colored person.
Extremely disappointing and discriminatory experience. We waited over 30 minutes while the restaurant was nearly empty, only to be told we couldn’t dine in. The staff kept hovering and watching us the entire time, which felt very uncomfortable and unwelcoming.
When I pointed out that we could have left instead of waiting so long, the staff member was rude and simply said, “It would be nice if you had a reservation,” instead of acknowledging their poor treatment.
In the end, they refused to let us dine in at all. This felt blatantly unfair and racist. No customer should ever be treated this way.
We did a catering order from Lilly's for my birthday. She was incredibly responsive, professional, and friendly. The food was great. My favorite was the grilled salmon. The roast beef was also a hit. Next time I'm in the area, I'll definitely be stopping in.
Nicole made our night so wonderful! I’ve had such a bad day but this experience completely turned my day around. The food was delicious, service was wonderful and I can’t wait to come back!
One of the best steaks ive had even as a delivery order, and the whole staff was accomodating and sweet getting it to our air B&B. High reccommend if visiting the area!
I went here for my birthday, I got the 18oz bone in ribeye and it was honestly possibly the best steak I have ever had in my life. Nice and crispy on the outside and cooked perfectly on the inside.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great restaurant! Great service! Great food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This restaurant was recommended to us. I have to say it was a delight. As we entered I request a boot , for my back. The hostess gladly catered to my needs. We were handed a menu and also a iPad to view how our food would look . The waitress was a lovely lady. Happy and had a laugh with us. The food was delicious. I started with the Brie and my husband had the portobello mushroom. Then he had a steak, which he loved , I had the battered fish and chips. Which was a very large portion. Could not finish as the Brie was a meal in its self. No complaints with the food. The bill came and my husband left his wallet in the car. I explained to the waitress. She said it was okay as there were plenty of dishes to wash. We had a good laugh about it . We are Irish and enjoy a good banter. While he was gone I looked at the bill. 3% added for credit card and another 3% of the bill for operating fee. I questioned it with the waitress. A new charge for POS. SERIOUSLY. We eat out a lot in manhattan and surrounding areas. I have never seen this before. I refused to pay 6% extra on top of a tip for the wonderful waitress. I had cash in my wallet, as I like to tip with cash as I have two children who work for the summer in restaurants and I tip generously for good service. I paid for the meal in cash. Overall. Food was good , service was a delight . We shall not be returning WATCH YOUR BILL
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Our server Nicole was absolutely wonderful!
It was our first time there and she was so helpful on picking the right food and getting to know us. The food was very delicious and I would highly recommend it for anyone visiting the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Really good food and service.
We all loved our meals. The service was exceptional and the atmosphere is very welcoming and pleasant. Highly recommend!
Fabulous meal! Everyone in our party of 7 raved about their meal. Portions were generous. Our server Valerie was superb, lovely personality and extremely attentive. Treat yourself to dinner at Lilly’s!
Loading...