Windham Pizzeria

Name: Windham Pizzeria
Address: 5339 NY-23, Windham, New York, 12496, US
Telephone: (518) 734-4011
Price range: $
Rating: 4.4

$ • Pizza

Hours:
5339 NY-23, Windham
(518) 734-4011

About Windham Pizzeria

Windham Pizzeria offers amazing pizza and rolls, with friendly staff that make customers feel welcome. A Brooklyn native was pleasantly surprised by the high quality of the pizza, deeming it "Brooklyn worthy." The restaurant serves delicious thin crust pizza, freshly made to order in a wood-fired oven. For breakfast, the food is hot, quick, and hearty, providing a nice start to the day with thorough and friendly service.

Customers recommend ordering custom pizzas, as the pre-made pies may appear dry and stale. The rolls are described as "bomb," and customers suggest asking for hot toppings on the pizza, as they are "hot." The staff is praised as "cool as hell," and the restaurant was able to accommodate a large order of vegan pizzas for a special event, which were all delicious. Garlic knots are also mentioned as phenomenal, with one customer claiming they are the second best they have ever had.

Visitors from New York City enjoyed their experience, praising the hospitable staff, who kept their pizzas warm while they were distracted across the street. Overall, Windham Pizzeria is a lovely family-run joint that consistently delivers high-quality food and service, making it a favorite for pizza lovers.