This is an unsanitary place and they charge you for things you never bought. For the 3rd time now I’ve picked up to go order with random things added. I’ll never be eating here again. I’m not going to continue to give my business to a place that doesn’t care about serving food. This place should close down. It’s one thing to make money it’s another to steal people’s money everytime they order. Go anywhere else.
Victor Cappas
The food was meh… pretty okay not the best not the worst , but it did mess me up the next morning. I asked for chimichangas, which on the menu are presented with a red sauce. They came out and had no sauce. I asked about it and the server said that’s only in the picture. I asked for a sauce to drizzle over it as it was dry… and was charged $5 for it. The stuffed clams were good tho. I won’t be returning or recommending tho.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Aaron Baughman
Bland, not impressed. Service was quite lacking. With that said. Its mexican in the Catskills. Shouldn't really expect a lot....
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Mai Hariu-Powell
“From the Charcoal” wins hands down. Comes with charred scallions and a jalapeño so it’s very legit. Their guac is also excellent and a great pairing with homemade chips.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
LMN
Absolutely superb. I've never had salsa like either of the two I just had. The tomatillo salsa had a warm spice and a velvety tone of roasted garlic. The...(I wish I'd asked how to spell the name of the other salsa) had moderate downbeat of smoky heat on a warm cloud of rich toasted sesame seed. If you like your flan dense and smooth, this will be some of the best you'll ever have. Also, and this is important, do not miss out on the crab-stuffed mushrooms.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diana Rodriguez
Absolutely delicious food! Best nachos and salsa! Everything is fresh and all 12 of us enjoyed every bite! Thank you! Gracias!
Cary K.
We had a wonderful experience dining outside on the deck. Everything was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chimichanga
Raven Hughes
This is a spot that I never get sick of. Great quality, fair prices, and a family run business I’m happy to support!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rajesh Sharma
Tried the food here and found some of these very close to Indian Food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Liz Flanagan
We eat here regularly. The food is delicious and the service very friendly. A great place to go with your family.
Chips and beans were one of the better ones had. Baja ceviche was good I felt the shrimp and salsa could have been a bit fresher. And would have definitely liked limes with it. Jalapeno poppers were awesome. Not too hot enough kick and nice gooey cheese. The mojito again was good not great. The mint was present but seemed to need to have crushed more to complement the drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Prince Shah
We were strolling through Windham and decided to try this place for dinner. Best guac, quesadilla and chimichangas hands down. Server was kind, patient and cheerful even at that late hour!
Food was phenomenal, service was also awesome. I don’t think other reviewers have actually had good Mexican food before.
Put it on your list!
D A
The best fajitas I have ever had in my life.
Timothy Robertson
I had high hopes for this place after reading the reviews but I would definitely avoid this place now. Got food to go for me and my partner and the food looked good but it was bland. After eating it my partner ended up throwing up multiple times. I currently don't feel good but haven't thrown up yet.
Yasmin Fathi
Food quality is poor, nothing seemed freshly cooked, the guacamole was old and yellow right from the fridge, the soup tasted old, the fajitas wasn’t good at all! Not sure why this place has a high review….
This is an unsanitary place and they charge you for things you never bought. For the 3rd time now I’ve picked up to go order with random things added. I’ll never be eating here again. I’m not going to continue to give my business to a place that doesn’t care about serving food. This place should close down. It’s one thing to make money it’s another to steal people’s money everytime they order. Go anywhere else.
The food was meh… pretty okay not the best not the worst , but it did mess me up the next morning. I asked for chimichangas, which on the menu are presented with a red sauce. They came out and had no sauce. I asked about it and the server said that’s only in the picture. I asked for a sauce to drizzle over it as it was dry… and was charged $5 for it. The stuffed clams were good tho. I won’t be returning or recommending tho.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Bland, not impressed. Service was quite lacking. With that said. Its mexican in the Catskills. Shouldn't really expect a lot....
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
“From the Charcoal” wins hands down. Comes with charred scallions and a jalapeño so it’s very legit. Their guac is also excellent and a great pairing with homemade chips.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Absolutely superb. I've never had salsa like either of the two I just had. The tomatillo salsa had a warm spice and a velvety tone of roasted garlic. The...(I wish I'd asked how to spell the name of the other salsa) had moderate downbeat of smoky heat on a warm cloud of rich toasted sesame seed. If you like your flan dense and smooth, this will be some of the best you'll ever have. Also, and this is important, do not miss out on the crab-stuffed mushrooms.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely delicious food! Best nachos and salsa! Everything is fresh and all 12 of us enjoyed every bite! Thank you! Gracias!
We had a wonderful experience dining outside on the deck. Everything was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chimichanga
This is a spot that I never get sick of. Great quality, fair prices, and a family run business I’m happy to support!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried the food here and found some of these very close to Indian Food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
We eat here regularly. The food is delicious and the service very friendly. A great place to go with your family.
Restaurantji Recommends
Chips and beans were one of the better ones had. Baja ceviche was good I felt the shrimp and salsa could have been a bit fresher. And would have definitely liked limes with it. Jalapeno poppers were awesome. Not too hot enough kick and nice gooey cheese. The mojito again was good not great. The mint was present but seemed to need to have crushed more to complement the drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
We were strolling through Windham and decided to try this place for dinner. Best guac, quesadilla and chimichangas hands down. Server was kind, patient and cheerful even at that late hour!
Food was phenomenal, service was also awesome. I don’t think other reviewers have actually had good Mexican food before.
Put it on your list!
The best fajitas I have ever had in my life.
I had high hopes for this place after reading the reviews but I would definitely avoid this place now. Got food to go for me and my partner and the food looked good but it was bland. After eating it my partner ended up throwing up multiple times. I currently don't feel good but haven't thrown up yet.
Food quality is poor, nothing seemed freshly cooked, the guacamole was old and yellow right from the fridge, the soup tasted old, the fajitas wasn’t good at all! Not sure why this place has a high review….
Loading...