Peter's New York Pizzeria
12013 E Main St, Wolcott
(315) 594-1507
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza
House Special Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
Garlic Knots
Sheet Pizza
BBQ Wings
Haddock
Calzone
Menu
Photos
+40 photos
+39 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I would post pictures, but the subs were gone the minute I pulled them out of the bag. The bread was so good and filling! Everyone at Peter's was very friendly and the lady who took my order, and made my subs, was a sweetheart. Thank you!
Born and raised 30 years in Brooklyn, pizza was always the one thing missing for me in WNY. Peter's New York Pizzeria is the one place I’ve found that reminds me of home. Great food, great staff.
This is my first time in NY so I had to try NY style pizza and this place did not disappoint! The gentleman and woman behind the counter were so sweet and patient as we figured out what we were all ordering. The pizza was incredible and the garlic knots were 10/10- I wish I could steal their red sauce recipe because it was delicious.
