We needed an ice cream cake for our daughter's birthday, and we were coming from NYC. Nancy's was accommodating, allowing me to pick up the cake even though they were closed. They arranged a time for me to pick it up once we arrived at Woodstock.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephen Kiely
From an ice cream aficionado-phenomenal!
Rick Bashkoff
This is some of the best ice cream in the world. No question. The team at Nancy's has done an unbelievable job of not only creating a very unique ice cream menu but also a very fun atmosphere. Highly recommend Tahitian Vanilla Bean and ask them to put chocolate cake crumbles on top, Salted Caramel & Creme Fraiche, or Cookies & Sweet Cream
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
R A
Nothing short of HOOKED!! If you’re a coffee lover definitely try the “coffee and stuff.”
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dalia Green
Amazing ice cream and cider donuts. Generous servings. Wish I lived closer.
Carolyn D.
I have never had better ice cream and I have sampled ice cream in every state of the U.S over time. Generous portions, a very accommodating owner and an interesting combination of ice cream parlor, book shop and gallery.In Bearsville at the Grossman complex, the home of so much of the 60's music. A must visit.
Adrienne K.
Not sure what's sad or reportable about my review - it's an honest account of my experience here: there wasn't really room to move through, as a result we broke something and then paid for it, and then were not treated with respect by the staff and subsequently the owner when attempting to voice concern. I've walked by since and noticed some rocking chairs that were contributing to the egress pinch points we struggled with have been rotated. Not sure if that's a coincidence, but it looks like there's more room to walk now.
Tessa G.
BEST ICE CREAM!!! So fresh and delicious. Also the counter staff is so nice, especially the platinum blonde!! Wonderful establishment a must if you are in Woody
Jenni Mannes
Some of the best ice cream we have ever had. My personal favorite was the peanut butter banana which had crunch and the perfect balance of sweet and salty. We went several times while visiting friends in Woodstock. Highly recommend!
ABBA'S ETERNAL GLORY
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL OPULENT CREAMERYHIGHLY RECOMMENDED ???DELICIOUS ICE CREAM AND EXCELLENT SERVICE many thanks!!!
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL OPULENT CREAMERYHIGHLY RECOMMENDED ???DELICIOUS ICE CREAM AND EXCELLENT SERVICE many thanks!!!
Angel C.
I cannot say enough wonderful things about Nancy's! The ice cream is so creamy and comes in so many unique flavors. Delicious pastries made in house. Ordered my son's custom ice cream cake for his birthday and it was a hit with the whole picky family. There is truly something for everyone here. To top it all off it's in a beautiful, clean building with a lovely staff. The owner Kathryn has a true eye for details, making sure every item coming out of her establishment is perfect.
A N.
Superb homemade ice cream with interesting flavors. I had the mish mash (vanilla with lots of crunchy things in it (cookie dough, brownie pieces, peanuts and more) and strawberry on a waffle cone. The strawberry was exceptional, too. Serving sizes are good, however if you want 2 flavors in your "single" (shown in my photo) there is a $3 upcharge. So it's $10 instead of $7. Not really sure why there is an extra charge. So for two of us having single size waffle cones with 2 flavors each we paid $22. It was expensive but also delicious. I wish it cost less but I would pay it again for the enjoyment. Photo taken after I had some of the ice cream because I couldn't wait/resist.
C. Grant
Ice cream was not great. The lattes were served cold. Buyer beware. Very overpriced. Fair effort, geared toward travelers.
Larry Kleinman
Excellent ice cream and baked goods. Sour cream cherry and chocolate yum
We needed an ice cream cake for our daughter's birthday, and we were coming from NYC. Nancy's was accommodating, allowing me to pick up the cake even though they were closed. They arranged a time for me to pick it up once we arrived at Woodstock.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From an ice cream aficionado-phenomenal!
This is some of the best ice cream in the world. No question. The team at Nancy's has done an unbelievable job of not only creating a very unique ice cream menu but also a very fun atmosphere. Highly recommend Tahitian Vanilla Bean and ask them to put chocolate cake crumbles on top, Salted Caramel & Creme Fraiche, or Cookies & Sweet Cream
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nothing short of HOOKED!! If you’re a coffee lover definitely try the “coffee and stuff.”
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing ice cream and cider donuts. Generous servings. Wish I lived closer.
I have never had better ice cream and I have sampled ice cream in every state of the U.S over time. Generous portions, a very accommodating owner and an interesting combination of ice cream parlor, book shop and gallery.In Bearsville at the Grossman complex, the home of so much of the 60's music. A must visit.
Not sure what's sad or reportable about my review - it's an honest account of my experience here: there wasn't really room to move through, as a result we broke something and then paid for it, and then were not treated with respect by the staff and subsequently the owner when attempting to voice concern. I've walked by since and noticed some rocking chairs that were contributing to the egress pinch points we struggled with have been rotated. Not sure if that's a coincidence, but it looks like there's more room to walk now.
BEST ICE CREAM!!! So fresh and delicious. Also the counter staff is so nice, especially the platinum blonde!! Wonderful establishment a must if you are in Woody
Some of the best ice cream we have ever had. My personal favorite was the peanut butter banana which had crunch and the perfect balance of sweet and salty. We went several times while visiting friends in Woodstock. Highly recommend!
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL OPULENT CREAMERYHIGHLY RECOMMENDED ???DELICIOUS ICE CREAM AND EXCELLENT SERVICE many thanks!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL OPULENT CREAMERYHIGHLY RECOMMENDED ???DELICIOUS ICE CREAM AND EXCELLENT SERVICE many thanks!!!
I cannot say enough wonderful things about Nancy's! The ice cream is so creamy and comes in so many unique flavors. Delicious pastries made in house. Ordered my son's custom ice cream cake for his birthday and it was a hit with the whole picky family. There is truly something for everyone here. To top it all off it's in a beautiful, clean building with a lovely staff. The owner Kathryn has a true eye for details, making sure every item coming out of her establishment is perfect.
Superb homemade ice cream with interesting flavors. I had the mish mash (vanilla with lots of crunchy things in it (cookie dough, brownie pieces, peanuts and more) and strawberry on a waffle cone. The strawberry was exceptional, too. Serving sizes are good, however if you want 2 flavors in your "single" (shown in my photo) there is a $3 upcharge. So it's $10 instead of $7. Not really sure why there is an extra charge. So for two of us having single size waffle cones with 2 flavors each we paid $22. It was expensive but also delicious. I wish it cost less but I would pay it again for the enjoyment. Photo taken after I had some of the ice cream because I couldn't wait/resist.
Ice cream was not great. The lattes were served cold. Buyer beware. Very overpriced. Fair effort, geared toward travelers.
Excellent ice cream and baked goods. Sour cream cherry and chocolate yum