Custer's Last Stand

176 Kingston Ave, Wurtsboro
(845) 888-4761

Recent Reviews

Sort by
S

Great atmosphere very kind workers, have very good ice cream.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aaron Horn

Portions were very generous! Thanks Charleigh and morgan!

Christine S

No line. Ice cream great.

Daniel Hernandez

Always very tasty!

Lorena

On my way back from Peekamoose Blue Hole I'm happy to have found this ice cream place ? it was delicious ? and server was a very nice gentleman ? sorry I didn't asked for his name??‍♀️ but I totally recommend it. I'll definitely be back next summer to both places?

Jerry Squillante

I have had ice cream here since 1980. Place is iconic and great for a quick pit stop for ice cream.

louis baldanza

I only ever get ice cream when I'm in Sullivan county here!! its so good will always come back every summer.

ELLA Fitzgerald

I order two French fries they a bag to put in.?? I will not go back again.

Jennifer Nowinski

Way over priced. Only got food here. Burger was tiny. Gave us literally a few french fries with our order, like 5. Would definitely not recommend nor go back.

megan Demeter

Handed us soft served ice cream already melting off the cone onto the counter. And the small hard ice cream I got wasn’t even a full scoop. Awful!

Paul Gorsky

Delicious ice cream!

Anthony Schelin

Good prices, good ice cream. Covered sitting area looks freshly painted and clean

Dishant Gupta

Very nice flavored ice creams

Allen Berman

Very flavorful shake

rina valentine

Me and my family went here yesterday. The icecream was good and it was soft it didn’t taste funny. But the next day everyone literally had diarrhea. My stomach has been hurting me all day we all had to run to the bathroom a lot. I don’t know why this icecream bothered us like that but it shouldn’t have.

Loading...