Southpaw Brewing Company
501 Boulevard E, Yaphank
(631) 504-6167
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Got there and the place was packed (that maybe a good sign) we waited about 25-27 minutes even though we were told 35 minutes (another great sign). We were seated at a high top table waited a few minutes to look over the menu and our waitress came over and took our drink menus; I ordered the "Porter" she said that they were out of it (bad sign) had to choose something else 'ok no big deal', I chose the milk stout my wife asked if the could make her a lemon drop in which the did. We received our drinks toasted to each other, till my wife said that her drink was PURE alcohol her lemon drop martini was no where near lemon took a few more sips and then had to order something else because it wasn't drinkable (bad sign #2) she decided to order a margarita when it arrived at the table it was the same as the lemon drop undrinkable too ( bad sign #3) the only saving grace was the food. The place has a great atmosphere good vibes and great for friends and family. FOUR STARS only because of our drinks
Food was okay and the only reason it has 2 stars. I believe your personal experience in an establishment really influences the meal and how it's perceived as a whole. Whether you are sitting at the bar picking up to go order or dealing with the server. I called in and order to go as I travel to this area very often for work and tried it for the first time. I walked in while the hostess was on the phone with a customer for three or four minutes. So I sat on the chairs and just waited for the phone call to be done no big deal. And then once the phone call ended she left the area for a minute or two without acknowledging me. But I talked this up to maybe she needed to go do something pressing and she would be right back with me. She did come back however she didn't say a word. Didn't look at me didn't acknowledge me. I don't think it's too much to ask for to be acknowledged when somebody comes into your establishment.
I ended up having to initiate the conversation and ask if my food was ready. She didn't say a word she just turned and grabbed my food from where the bag was stored. She then rang up the food and didn't say a word. Like it was incredibly awkward. No " that'll be 18.35$" nothing. The only words this young girl in a ponytail with brown hair said to me was receipt? One word. She made me feel guilty for ordering food like she was going out of her way to help me or I was being a massive inconvenience by trying their food. Just totally put off. Doesn't take much to even fake a smile and say hi can I help you.
Food preparation sucks, no flavor. Broken and chipped glasses and bowls. Beer is terrible for a brewery! Pint glass had some trapped door on the bottom that opened and spilled all over the table! $18 for a salad and then charge extra for chicken! How about $14, and then charge for extras, over priced! Chicken had no seasoning. Peaches were supposed to be grilled, but it doesn't work well with canned peaches! The Gnocchi with short rib ragu was certainly short on the rib! Nothing but overcooked Gnocchi , $32! Overpriced! I wouldn't mind paying these prices at all, but nothing was good, even the appetizer sucked!
Everything is $20. Food and portions are fantastic. Great menu. Great staff. Great beers.
Nice place to watch sports with friends, good food and very friendly staff! Our food was tasty. The nhoque plate is huge and I couldn’t finish (it’s a “heavy meal” for me). Delicious calamari.
My food was cold it seems the food is frozen and they microwave it as the food came out quick.
Gives big portions! For 2 apps, 2 drinks and 1 entree it was $88 so a bit pricey.
Onion rings were good but HUGE portion. Cajun ranch was also good. Tater tots were great but the cheese was not that good. Wouldn’t get that type of cheese again.
Cajun chicken pasta was great and lots of leftovers.
Overall cute place and you’ll definitely have leftovers
Their doors are open and it was worth it! Great new place. The staff were attentive and friendly. The food was very good. We had the Charcuterie Pretzel, chicken and cheese steak egg roll duo, short rib nachos and the brick oven Pizzas: margherita, and suprossota and hot honey. All delicious and some of the better pizza I've had. The cocktails were good. Had the Spicy margarita, house of dragon, peach and vodka and an IPA they make on premise. The place looks amazing. Nice and big and open. Go see them. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!
Went back today. Took a while to be sat and to actually get food. The food was good. Drinks were better.
Back again for happy hour.
Back for Taco Tuesday and they soared! Awesome time. Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!
Another successful date night. Pretzel charcuterie and a peach and feta salad with a fig old fashioned. Perfection!
First time me and my husband went the food and service was amazing . This time we sat for 20 mins with no service we weren’t even offered a drink .
Food was really good tonight. Loved that you have outdoor dining now. What a beautiful night to eat outside. Great service!
Restaurantji Recommends
Southpaw has extremely large portions and could easily be shared. Service was friendly, outside patio seating at the table was comfortable. Rice pudding is absolutely delicious.
Service is mediocre. Extremely large portions, but extremely expensive. The beer is fine if the taps have been cleaned, but it tastes like butter most of the time. Have higher standards for breweries, Southpaw doesn’t meet them.
Great people awesome place.
Nice place with a nice atmosphere. It's especially nice to sit outside, it gets quite noisy inside. Good food, both burgers and various chicken dishes can be recommended. Quite good beer too, although the selection of beers could have been a little better. But all in all, recommended.
I was staying at the hotel right next door and decided to check this place out . I went back the very next night the food was so good !
I had the buffalo chicken wrap and the carne asada. They used strip steak and it was absolutely delicious !!
Highly Recommend !
Loading...