Calabria

3681 Old Yorktown Rd, Shrub Oak
(914) 556-6410

Recent Reviews

P A

The pizza is very light and there is a bread-y taste that I like. I don't feel heavy after eating it. I ordered chicken fingers and fries as well and the chicken fingers were so good, not tough and perfectly fried. My order was ready quickly and the gentleman behind the counter was nice and attentive. My new go-to.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Angelica Palmer

You will love it here. Have better orders and less great, but when looking at the general: GREAT.

Qaiser Ahmad

The owner was so cool nice pizza good food I will recommend if I ever stop

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Betti C

I had gotten two slices of specialty pizza and it was very very good.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Peter Daba

Excellent pizza and other take out includingA $29.00 Dinner for 4 take out.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Sorrentino, Chicken Club Wrap, Sicilian Slice, White Pizza

Abby C

Food and staff….. always perfect!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steve McGuire

I go here for a quick lunch while driving a small bus whenever I am in the area. It's a solid slice, not the best I've ever had in my life, but it's very far from the worst. I always ask for it extremely hot; as in burn your mouth hot. That's the way I like it. The slice folds up nice with a crisp. Good, tangy sauce, wet, and not sugary-sweet. Slices are on the small side, so if you want one, order two. A very good, solid slice of pizza.

Kristen Tutelian

Ordered catering for my sons birthday party and got so many complements on the food. Chx Francese and eggplant parm is fantastic. Delivered on time and friendly staff! Thank you Calabria.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edward D.

I believe this to be the best pizza in the area. Thin crisp crust that cracks when you fold. Friendly staff, ample parking.

Tom E.

Great Pizza and the Garlic Knots are awesome. Service is fast and friendly. No complaints.

Bryan H.

The food was enjoyable. Ordered 2 slices and the service was prompt and respectful. The pizza was hot and crunchy, can't complain there. I would definitely recommend Calabria I tried almost all other pizzerias and nothing comes close.

Mike Lafayette

Great hidden gem, there are a lot of pizza places in the area. This one is definitely the best

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ck R.

My Wife and I order from here often and their food is consistently amazing! We've ordered pizza, salads, soups and pasta dishes and all of them are exceptionally delicious. Kudos to those running this very tasty shop indeed!

S Sylvester

There’s an issue with consistency. I had a great pizza from Calabria one day, the next week it was totally different. When the owner isn’t there, the pizza is not the same. Soon as I walked in I could see it wasn’t the same and it wasn’t. Very disappointed. But if the owner is making the pizza that’s a different story. The difference was night and day unfortunately.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Nancy L.

I ordered through too good to waste. It's an app that NY have that allows a customers to check out the food, service and character of a business at a reduced price. I've used it on several occasions. Most business have various times you can pick food up. Calabria time is 30 minutes before the business closed. I went in five minutes earlier, showed my order to the man on register. He asked me to have a seat. He told the other person/worker in the store. I received a box of pizza. When I opened it, it looked like garbage, five slices of pizza they would discard. I have never went to a business, going through too good to waste, where I have felt like I had received garbage. That speaks for the character of a business. With pickup time 30 minutes before closing, there are many food that would fulfill the too good to waste category. For a reduced price, I was given old pizza slices that look like they were sitting around all day. I asked if he can warm it, and he said no. I told him that I have two orders, and he gave me basically the same thing he gave me the first time. Very, very disappointed. Again, this speaks to the character of a business, because thirty minutes before closing, they are many things that are too good to go or throw out. You do not give a customer something that you would throw out. Instead, you give a customer something that is too good to throw away.

Load More