Peter Pratt's Inn

Celebrated our 35th anniversary at Peter Pratt's where we had our wedding reception. Enjoyed it as always!

Toughest NY Strip steak ever costing $43! Music was not welcoming but the staff did change to something better. Celebrating our anniversary was not as good as we had hoped. Especially for $75 per person!

Highly recommend Pratts. Been loooong time customers. Foods not as good since Jonathon sold but was still good. Service was very good. Ambiance sitting on deck on nice evening was very nice. Restaurant was nearly empty which is disappointing for such a great pkace

I ordered the saffron risotto with seafood. Mussels, shrimp, calamari- and canned string beans. Pretty bland for the price. The fennel arugula salad was sub-par. Great cocktails and oysters. Entrees were a big let down. Don't need to come back.

Dinner was lovely, restaurant was quiet The Scallops were delicious Our waiter was attentive

We went to Peter Pratt's for a celebratory family dinner on a Wednesday evening, and unfortunately, it fell short of expectations. There were only two servers handling a few tables inside and some outside, but despite the manageable crowd, service felt rushed and careless. No one checked in to see if our meals were okay. Dishes were dropped onto the table with no care, so the presentation suffered as everything slid around. On top of that, we got attitude instead of hospitality. For the prices they charge, you're better off going to Bird & Bottle instead.

Pretty restaurant, romantic. Excellent food. Porch and patio dining lovely in good weather.

The food, service and ambience were fantastic. The scallops with pesto mashed potatoes, superb. English cucumber martini was delicious and refreshing.

It was excellent all around great place to enjoy a wonderful evening.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place! Food is amazing! The music was two guys on a guitar playing great music. Quiet and relaxing.

We had a great meal and a walk back into history with our visit to Peter Pratt's Inn earlier this evening.
Delish food and wonderful drinks!
This was our first visit, but we are already talking about going back again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We went there for Mother's Day . It was buffet food which was cold and sitting outside and exposed to flys. It was also grossly over priced for a prefixed menu. The coffee was the best part of the meal

Over-rated and overpriced. It's just ok. Nice ambiance, tho. Cozy, Revolutionary War vibe.

The atmosphere of the restaurant was nice and the waiter's behavior was nice at the beginning. We ordered steak and asked for it to be cooked medium well, but it was served well done. Before finishing all the dishes, we told the waiter that any order that had meat in it was well done, not medium well. We said this is just for you to improve the quality of the food, so he told us that what I see in front of me is medium well and not as you claim. I told him that I want to ask the chef, and he said that he is busy. I said that I want to ask the manager, and his behavior was very bad, as if he was complaining about work. The manager came and his behavior was worse than the waiter's. Every time I told him something, he said to me that it is not you who teaches me. I told him that it was just advice. He said that I do not take advice from you nor do I take comments from you. The atmosphere was nice, the service was nice until we reached the last point, you as a manager must learn how to win the person over to your side and make him deal with you. The treatment was very rude from the waiter or the manager.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

1st time at the Inn, celebrating our anniversary. Fabulous spot, a blend of early American history and sophisticated cuisine. We can't wait to come back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5