Yesterday, we had the chance to try Fat T's Cookies, which we picked up from the North Side Marketplace. My fiancée enjoyed her s'more cookie, although she wished she had chosen something else that might have been better. I had the snickerdoodle, one of my favorite cookies, but unfortunately, we both felt that the taste and flavor were lacking. You'll have to be the judge for yourself!
Robert Bell
I've tried cookies from all the leading online bakeries and have not found a better, quarter-pound treat from any of them than the cookies I enjoy from Fat T's Cookies. Always fresh, always delicious
Jack Howe
Outstanding product and service as usual
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cyndy MacIvor
Had the lemon blueberry cookie today and it was superb, worth every penny! One of the best cookies we have ever had! My fiancé and I split one, such great taste
Cyndy MacIvor Palker
Had the lemon blueberry cookie today and it was superb, worth every penny! One of the best cookies we have ever had! My fiancé and I split one, such great taste
Sara Khan
yummyyy😋🥰 perfect amount of sweetness, it was thick, soft, and delicious! Perfect to sink your teeth into and keep coming back for more!
Joe Antonucci
Fat's Cookies are the best. Shared them with friends. They all said that they were great.
Kara Long
We've ordered online for years! The cookies are excellent, and the customer service is outstanding! The Tortuga is our favorite seasonal cookie.
Excellent! Ordered some old favorites and tried the new Totes McOats. All were very very good. Huge fan of the new Totes McOats. Also the Oreo cookie one. Very big cookies and awesome taste. Fat T's cookies are a hit in our house!
Valerie Wichert
Just tried your cookies for the first time! Absolutely amazing!! As a fellow bakery owner I have to say it’s one of the best cookies I’ve had❤️
Jason Drew
By far the best cookies I've ever had. Ordering was a breeze and shipping was swift! Would absolutely order again to restock!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie
Sam Kovalchik
Amazing cookies and even better customer service! I ordered a 5-pack of cookies earlier in the week and due to a glitch on the website one of the cookies listed was not being produced at the time. I was contacted directly to inquire about a replacement for that flavor and it was then replaced with a different flavor and a second extra one that I did not know about until receiving the shipment! For that (and the excellent quality of the cookies) I will definitely be a repeat buyer and continue to support Travis and his team. I still miss being able to buy them directly from Northside Marketplace when I lived in Ohio.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
Gina C
We got the red velvet, peanut butter chocolate and cinnamon cookies and all 3 were fantastic. Taste and texture 5/5.
The GOAC! - Greatest of all cookies.
Yesterday, we had the chance to try Fat T's Cookies, which we picked up from the North Side Marketplace. My fiancée enjoyed her s'more cookie, although she wished she had chosen something else that might have been better. I had the snickerdoodle, one of my favorite cookies, but unfortunately, we both felt that the taste and flavor were lacking. You'll have to be the judge for yourself!
I've tried cookies from all the leading online bakeries and have not found a better, quarter-pound treat from any of them than the cookies I enjoy from Fat T's Cookies. Always fresh, always delicious
Outstanding product and service as usual
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the lemon blueberry cookie today and it was superb, worth every penny! One of the best cookies we have ever had! My fiancé and I split one, such great taste
Had the lemon blueberry cookie today and it was superb, worth every penny! One of the best cookies we have ever had! My fiancé and I split one, such great taste
yummyyy😋🥰 perfect amount of sweetness, it was thick, soft, and delicious! Perfect to sink your teeth into and keep coming back for more!
Fat's Cookies are the best. Shared them with friends. They all said that they were great.
We've ordered online for years! The cookies are excellent, and the customer service is outstanding! The Tortuga is our favorite seasonal cookie.
Horrible parking terrible location
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent! Ordered some old favorites and tried the new Totes McOats. All were very very good. Huge fan of the new Totes McOats. Also the Oreo cookie one. Very big cookies and awesome taste. Fat T's cookies are a hit in our house!
Just tried your cookies for the first time! Absolutely amazing!! As a fellow bakery owner I have to say it’s one of the best cookies I’ve had❤️
By far the best cookies I've ever had. Ordering was a breeze and shipping was swift! Would absolutely order again to restock!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie
Amazing cookies and even better customer service! I ordered a 5-pack of cookies earlier in the week and due to a glitch on the website one of the cookies listed was not being produced at the time. I was contacted directly to inquire about a replacement for that flavor and it was then replaced with a different flavor and a second extra one that I did not know about until receiving the shipment! For that (and the excellent quality of the cookies) I will definitely be a repeat buyer and continue to support Travis and his team. I still miss being able to buy them directly from Northside Marketplace when I lived in Ohio.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
We got the red velvet, peanut butter chocolate and cinnamon cookies and all 3 were fantastic. Taste and texture 5/5.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie
Loading...