Now before I say too much, my wife had the clams and said they were Amazing. The service was impeccable as our server went out of her way for us. I however was not impressed with my fish, very bland. I also caught a long bone in my fish. The chef came out and apologized and they took some money off our bill. It just wasn't what we expected...I'm sorry.
Aindrea Arkwright
My food was great but rice was bland & my clams was amazing, my husband food his fish had bone in it and food was very bland..
Mary Jo Laufenberg
We had an amazing dinner last night at Hil-Mak! First visit and we were not disappointed! Sea scallops were fresh and perfectly prepared, as well as my husband’s Shrimpster platter. You must have the twice baked potatoes, simply delicious! Having chef visit our table was a such a nice touch as well. Thank you Jeff! We can’t wait to return and plan to visit the market, though I’m not sure I can compete with the delicious entrees we enjoyed!
Ann Fatter
Cute small gem seafood restaurant. Great food, lots of selections and awesome service. We will definitely be returning.
Celeste Colby
Ordered take out, got the perch. It was the BEST fish I’ve ever had. I got a side of twice baked potatoes, which were also amazing. Highly recommend!!!
DiAnna Friend
Everything was excellent!
Kim Chiesa
We drove from Erie for dinner. It took 40 minutes to get our food. It wasn’t busy and they had just opened. It started with the wrong salad dressing and didn’t get the opportunity to ask for what we ordered. Then 40 minutes later we got our food. Very small portions for the fish. I ordered the filet medium and it was so dried up and well done that I couldn’t eat it. When the waiter came back to check on it I told him I couldn’t eat it. It was much later before getting the check that I was offered a new steak by that time it was too late. I will definitely never go back
Cherub Belle Maria
From the moment we walked in it was absolutely horrible. Service, Food, Prices.
There was 5 of us celebrating a birthday.
Not one of us had a good meal and we all had something different.
I used to travel to come here to dine.
It’s become sad and lost.
Don’t waste your time or money.
James McFarland
Just went there last night and everything was fantastic there were six of us, we got appetizers, we got our meals and we got our sides. The service was amazing and the flavors fantastic with everything cooked perfectly there's not one complaint that the 6 of us could have found. We all left very full and extremely satisfied. It was quite an enjoyable evening to say the least!
mike d
Definitely the best place in Ashtabula for seafood. Way better than Red lobster always go home full with a doggy bag
Everything from the appetizer to the clam chowder, lake erie perch, and scallops were fresh and excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lake Erie Perch, Clam Chowder
Bill Smith
Had the Lake Perch dinner. Absolutely the best meal I have ever had. Do not hesitate
Parking: Parked and walked 20 feet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lake Erie Perch
Robert Halcomb
Made reservations for our family of 11 , they said they could accommodate. They were unprepared to handle a party our size . Food took over 2 ours to come to our table . Food quality was deplorable, all dishes were cold and tasted like they were thrown together . We will not return to this restaurant. This used to be our favorite place to go , but things have changed and the restaurant is not organized .
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Jim Novak
The food is fantastic, so there is no reason to try and find a fault. Service was adequate and atmosphere is what YOU make it.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Clam Chowder
Nancy Toms
The staff was friendly and attentive. The food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bisque, Haddock, Lake Erie Perch, Twice Baked Potato
Now before I say too much, my wife had the clams and said they were Amazing. The service was impeccable as our server went out of her way for us. I however was not impressed with my fish, very bland. I also caught a long bone in my fish. The chef came out and apologized and they took some money off our bill. It just wasn't what we expected...I'm sorry.
My food was great but rice was bland & my clams was amazing, my husband food his fish had bone in it and food was very bland..
We had an amazing dinner last night at Hil-Mak! First visit and we were not disappointed! Sea scallops were fresh and perfectly prepared, as well as my husband’s Shrimpster platter. You must have the twice baked potatoes, simply delicious! Having chef visit our table was a such a nice touch as well. Thank you Jeff! We can’t wait to return and plan to visit the market, though I’m not sure I can compete with the delicious entrees we enjoyed!
Cute small gem seafood restaurant. Great food, lots of selections and awesome service. We will definitely be returning.
Ordered take out, got the perch. It was the BEST fish I’ve ever had. I got a side of twice baked potatoes, which were also amazing. Highly recommend!!!
Everything was excellent!
We drove from Erie for dinner. It took 40 minutes to get our food. It wasn’t busy and they had just opened. It started with the wrong salad dressing and didn’t get the opportunity to ask for what we ordered. Then 40 minutes later we got our food. Very small portions for the fish. I ordered the filet medium and it was so dried up and well done that I couldn’t eat it. When the waiter came back to check on it I told him I couldn’t eat it. It was much later before getting the check that I was offered a new steak by that time it was too late. I will definitely never go back
From the moment we walked in it was absolutely horrible. Service, Food, Prices. There was 5 of us celebrating a birthday. Not one of us had a good meal and we all had something different. I used to travel to come here to dine. It’s become sad and lost. Don’t waste your time or money.
Just went there last night and everything was fantastic there were six of us, we got appetizers, we got our meals and we got our sides. The service was amazing and the flavors fantastic with everything cooked perfectly there's not one complaint that the 6 of us could have found. We all left very full and extremely satisfied. It was quite an enjoyable evening to say the least!
Definitely the best place in Ashtabula for seafood. Way better than Red lobster always go home full with a doggy bag
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Everything from the appetizer to the clam chowder, lake erie perch, and scallops were fresh and excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lake Erie Perch, Clam Chowder
Had the Lake Perch dinner. Absolutely the best meal I have ever had. Do not hesitate
Parking: Parked and walked 20 feet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lake Erie Perch
Made reservations for our family of 11 , they said they could accommodate. They were unprepared to handle a party our size . Food took over 2 ours to come to our table . Food quality was deplorable, all dishes were cold and tasted like they were thrown together . We will not return to this restaurant. This used to be our favorite place to go , but things have changed and the restaurant is not organized .
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
The food is fantastic, so there is no reason to try and find a fault. Service was adequate and atmosphere is what YOU make it.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Clam Chowder
The staff was friendly and attentive. The food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bisque, Haddock, Lake Erie Perch, Twice Baked Potato
Loading...