We LOVE GoodFellas Pizza!!!The pizza is fantastic!The staff is warm and friendly!The location is perfect!The price is VERY reasonable!Per slice or the whole pie --- GoodFellas rocks!When we are in Athens --- or even just passing through --- this is a regular stop for us.....just writing this makes my cravings kick in!
Thomas Wittkopf
Soooooo good and tasty! Definitely recommend when it's late out. It hits the right spot perfectly when drinking. Recommend hitting here if your doing the shuffle. Pizza is deep dish, soft and cheesy! Always git slices and pop.Parking: Metered outside. Up to 2 hours
Mike Mossburger
Great Lil Pizza Shop uptown & has been for many years. If they would only get additional toppings. However it’s still Quality Pizza made fresh!!!!!! #goodfellaspizza
Sam Ashton
An Athens tradition. As amazing now as it was ten years ago. Both locations are mouth-watering, always fresh, and super cheap.
Jack Hutter
This pizza was legitimately the best pizza I've ever had. I'm a pizza connoisseur and went last night. I will be going back again today!
Seth Graham
The pizza is GREAT it's a deep dish but the sizes they have are half sheet or full sheet or you can buy by individual slice idk if buying the half sheet or full comes half cheese and half pepperoni even though I said for entire pizza I got the half sheet which is 8 slicesBut its really really EXPENSIVE but for trying it for my first time I wasn't disappointed
GrumpyUncleNick 20
It’s pretty alright pizza. A little pricey considering it’s overall quality (it’s not bad, but not amazing). But as the only “late night pizza joint” in Athens, there’s little to complain about.
Joe Diamond
GoodFella’s Pizza is an Athens staple for a reason, and easily the best fourthmeal after an evening of Court Street debauchery.The prices are just right for the amount of pizza you get; the slices are huge. There isn’t usually a wait, and the staff are super friendly. They also deliver through DoorDash, which is a huge plus.Ignore the other oddly negative reviews. This place is amazing. You won’t be disappointed.
Mike Bolin
Rude. Will not take your order over the phone, they answer the phone but tell you to go through doordash which doubles the price, stupid
Richie Evener
If you like really hot thicker crust pizza this is a great place to try!
Great pizza, team there are awesome! Stopped in and got the last pizza of the day to take back to Logan with us
Josie Renee Jeffers
Pretty sad when you gotta cook your own pizza that you paid $30 for from good fellas pizza! If someone can tag them please do! It won't let me post to the page
Chris S.
Had a slice during a recent visit to OU. One slice is pretty filling. The sauce has a nice flavor but a bit doughy overall for my taste but ok
Chloe C.
Around 2 am we found ourselves very hungry after a long night and decided to get some pizza. Once we walked in we were warmly welcomed by Joey. After ordering out pizza we had a great conversation with him. We knew he could have been doing some of his closing work but decided to talk to us instead. Overall this was the highlight of our night. The pizza was delicious. Highly recommend the pepperoni with garlic butter!
Audrey E.
Yes; just yes. Stopped in for a slice and left with a piece of heaven. I'm drooling thinking about it...
We LOVE GoodFellas Pizza!!!The pizza is fantastic!The staff is warm and friendly!The location is perfect!The price is VERY reasonable!Per slice or the whole pie --- GoodFellas rocks!When we are in Athens --- or even just passing through --- this is a regular stop for us.....just writing this makes my cravings kick in!
Soooooo good and tasty! Definitely recommend when it's late out. It hits the right spot perfectly when drinking. Recommend hitting here if your doing the shuffle. Pizza is deep dish, soft and cheesy! Always git slices and pop.Parking: Metered outside. Up to 2 hours
Great Lil Pizza Shop uptown & has been for many years. If they would only get additional toppings. However it’s still Quality Pizza made fresh!!!!!! #goodfellaspizza
An Athens tradition. As amazing now as it was ten years ago. Both locations are mouth-watering, always fresh, and super cheap.
This pizza was legitimately the best pizza I've ever had. I'm a pizza connoisseur and went last night. I will be going back again today!
The pizza is GREAT it's a deep dish but the sizes they have are half sheet or full sheet or you can buy by individual slice idk if buying the half sheet or full comes half cheese and half pepperoni even though I said for entire pizza I got the half sheet which is 8 slicesBut its really really EXPENSIVE but for trying it for my first time I wasn't disappointed
It’s pretty alright pizza. A little pricey considering it’s overall quality (it’s not bad, but not amazing). But as the only “late night pizza joint” in Athens, there’s little to complain about.
GoodFella’s Pizza is an Athens staple for a reason, and easily the best fourthmeal after an evening of Court Street debauchery.The prices are just right for the amount of pizza you get; the slices are huge. There isn’t usually a wait, and the staff are super friendly. They also deliver through DoorDash, which is a huge plus.Ignore the other oddly negative reviews. This place is amazing. You won’t be disappointed.
Rude. Will not take your order over the phone, they answer the phone but tell you to go through doordash which doubles the price, stupid
If you like really hot thicker crust pizza this is a great place to try!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza, team there are awesome! Stopped in and got the last pizza of the day to take back to Logan with us
Pretty sad when you gotta cook your own pizza that you paid $30 for from good fellas pizza! If someone can tag them please do! It won't let me post to the page
Had a slice during a recent visit to OU. One slice is pretty filling. The sauce has a nice flavor but a bit doughy overall for my taste but ok
Around 2 am we found ourselves very hungry after a long night and decided to get some pizza. Once we walked in we were warmly welcomed by Joey. After ordering out pizza we had a great conversation with him. We knew he could have been doing some of his closing work but decided to talk to us instead. Overall this was the highlight of our night. The pizza was delicious. Highly recommend the pepperoni with garlic butter!
Yes; just yes. Stopped in for a slice and left with a piece of heaven. I'm drooling thinking about it...