GoodFella's Pizza

6 W Union St, Athens
(740) 592-1572

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Pearl

Saw the owner of this place putting his personal trash infront of a business.
It's sad that an owner can't even take care of his own trash. I believe he also talked down to the employees.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Slim pickings

Great pizza! Especially for the price per slice.

Food: 5

Mike Wigal

Great pizza! Friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Donald Wilson

The best pizza ever its worth driving from another town for. 😋. My Dog Loves It too. ❤️. Seen some of the reviews that says the crust is soft and gave a bad review 😆 its thick crust its supposed to be soft. Best pizza ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ethan Saffell

Called a total of 4 times. Got hung up on 3 out of those 4 times. When I asked what I wanted to ask she answered then said bye and hung the phone up. 0/5 stars, horrible customer service. Will be going to dominos from now on

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Anthony Maps

Might be the best pizza in Athens.

Nathan Reeise

Idk why people like this maybe I just had them on a bad day but the crust was.soft and chewy very little crunch and I got pepperoni there was 2 pieces of pepperoni on the slices... Jets is so much better

david lynn

the pizza was fresh out of the oven and was a great pizza.

Heath Patterson

The pizza here is mediocre. The dough is really chewy and fluffy, so if you like a crisp crust this isn't for you. It's basically like white bread, the flavor is good just texture for a pizza dough is weird. The sauce is good, but the cheese is the buffet weakness. It's the type of cheese that just congeales on top of the pizza. Texture is weird and flavor is meh. 20 bucks for a half sheet of pepperoni might not be bad if there were actually pepperoni on it lol. The pieces are huge, which is good, but a pepperoni pizza only has 4 pieces per slice. So you're mainly getting a cheese pizza in the middle with pepperoni on each end. Overall nowhere near an amazing slice, but mediocre at best. I'd probably try another place.

Kavan Lavy

This 2 am pizza has saved us many extremely hung over mornings. Can’t go wrong with bread and cheese.

Aaron Kistler (stepsisaaron)

Nice smell to the place. pizza is very good. the dough isn't like what you get at a chain pizza it gives it a nice textu and taste. and the workers are friendly

Morgan Davis

Amazing pizza! Quick service.

kate dickens

josie was the best…

Cheryl Garvin

Worst pizza in Athens, especially when it's served up partially cooked!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

M Carroll

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Loading...