We stopped by yesterday and had a GREAT lunch - the prices are really good, and the staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. The pizza was great but the real standout was actually the salad! HUGE, fresh and great house made dressing. No iceberg! We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Green Salad
jvkocian
Gina's is my go to pizza. I will regularly get the pesto with vegan cheese pizza. Really hits the spot. They can get really busy to the point it's not worth ordering. Owner is usually there and staffed by younger kids. They used to have vegan slices available every Monday but I think they discontinued that.
Update: the salads seem to have really dropped in quality. Also the vegan cheese is now an extra charge on pizzas even though it's not listed anywhere.
Updated from previous review on 2024-03-23
Dan P
Everything was very bland and had a very heavy bread
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Kelly S.
Pizza is very good. NY style. However they don't have green peppers as a topping option. Green peppers are crucial for a pizza.
Madeline gumina
The young men working here are more mature and better at custom service than most of the 35 year olds I work with. Especially the one with very dark somewhat poofy hair. The customer service somehow outshines the pizza which is the best in Ohio. Very very very well done.
Kat R.
Not as good as the previous owner. Ordered salad and a pizza. Salad is just greens, pizza is room temp like it was the one sitting out all day
Mindy C.
Ordered 2 pizzas to split - both half without cheese. No allergy just preference. When we called at 715, the team didn't seem thrilled for our order - perhaps a high schooler after their first day back to school after break? Arrived and feta was on one, they realized "oh ya" that's cheese... We asked for a remake and they forgot the sausage we had added and paid for on that pizza. The supreme was delicious - so I know it's quality! I think a bit more attention to detail would be appreciated!
Tom S.
I can confirm that this is New York style. I can not call it good New York style. Cheese, sauce and crust were below par.
James Ross
Closest thing to New York style pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holly S.
Used to come here all the time when I worked around the corner! Love that they sell pizza by the slice too. Delicious toppings and great salad as well! They have a lemon dressing that is to die for.
tastes just like "Fair Pizza ", nothing unique or special but still fills a niche I
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Matt Davis
Excellent independently-owned pizza place. Their pizza is absolutely delicious if you're looking for a break from the chain-pizza landscape.
F B
One of the best pizzas in Cleveland. In particular, the buffalo chicken and the godmother are outstanding. The medium party salad is excellent but I don’t think it’s on the menu anymore
Lynn A.
Stopped in for a quick slice after a pedi next door. I was not impressed! It was about 1:30ish and they had a couple, I think 3 pizzas ready to sell by the slice. They looked as if they were made for the lunch hour & had been sitting under heat lamps for far too long. Since I went in, I sort of didn't just want to turn around & leave, so I ordered from the one that looked the least dried out. It was $4 yikes!!! It may look big in the box, but the box was small. Totally not worth the cost especially since it was not fresh out of the oven. Will I ever go back? I don't think so :(
Mary R.
Ordered for the first time for the Bay Village Dog kennel fund raiser. It was fantastic. Minor error was made and they could not have been nicer about trying to correct it. Everything was fresh and it is our new go to pizza shop. Well done! Thank you for good food and your contribution to a great cause!
We stopped by yesterday and had a GREAT lunch - the prices are really good, and the staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. The pizza was great but the real standout was actually the salad! HUGE, fresh and great house made dressing. No iceberg! We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Green Salad
Gina's is my go to pizza. I will regularly get the pesto with vegan cheese pizza. Really hits the spot. They can get really busy to the point it's not worth ordering. Owner is usually there and staffed by younger kids. They used to have vegan slices available every Monday but I think they discontinued that. Update: the salads seem to have really dropped in quality. Also the vegan cheese is now an extra charge on pizzas even though it's not listed anywhere. Updated from previous review on 2024-03-23
Everything was very bland and had a very heavy bread
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Pizza is very good. NY style. However they don't have green peppers as a topping option. Green peppers are crucial for a pizza.
The young men working here are more mature and better at custom service than most of the 35 year olds I work with. Especially the one with very dark somewhat poofy hair. The customer service somehow outshines the pizza which is the best in Ohio. Very very very well done.
Not as good as the previous owner. Ordered salad and a pizza. Salad is just greens, pizza is room temp like it was the one sitting out all day
Ordered 2 pizzas to split - both half without cheese. No allergy just preference. When we called at 715, the team didn't seem thrilled for our order - perhaps a high schooler after their first day back to school after break? Arrived and feta was on one, they realized "oh ya" that's cheese... We asked for a remake and they forgot the sausage we had added and paid for on that pizza. The supreme was delicious - so I know it's quality! I think a bit more attention to detail would be appreciated!
I can confirm that this is New York style. I can not call it good New York style. Cheese, sauce and crust were below par.
Closest thing to New York style pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Used to come here all the time when I worked around the corner! Love that they sell pizza by the slice too. Delicious toppings and great salad as well! They have a lemon dressing that is to die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
tastes just like "Fair Pizza ", nothing unique or special but still fills a niche I
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Excellent independently-owned pizza place. Their pizza is absolutely delicious if you're looking for a break from the chain-pizza landscape.
One of the best pizzas in Cleveland. In particular, the buffalo chicken and the godmother are outstanding. The medium party salad is excellent but I don’t think it’s on the menu anymore
Stopped in for a quick slice after a pedi next door. I was not impressed! It was about 1:30ish and they had a couple, I think 3 pizzas ready to sell by the slice. They looked as if they were made for the lunch hour & had been sitting under heat lamps for far too long. Since I went in, I sort of didn't just want to turn around & leave, so I ordered from the one that looked the least dried out. It was $4 yikes!!! It may look big in the box, but the box was small. Totally not worth the cost especially since it was not fresh out of the oven. Will I ever go back? I don't think so :(
Ordered for the first time for the Bay Village Dog kennel fund raiser. It was fantastic. Minor error was made and they could not have been nicer about trying to correct it. Everything was fresh and it is our new go to pizza shop. Well done! Thank you for good food and your contribution to a great cause!