Newfangled Kitchen

2258 E Main St, Bexley
(614) 817-1099

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Georgia Turkey Reuben Sandwich
Dill Pickle Potato Salad
Meatloaf Sandwich
Hunter S Chicken
Lucifer's Hammer
Swissshroom Melt
Barnyard Caviar
Meatloaf Reuben
Georgia Reuben
The Big Deal

Menu

Meatloaf Sandwiches
Meatloaf Reuben
Warm meatloaf, swiss cheese, fang sauce, cole slaw, marbled rye, grilled
The Fang
Meatloaf, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, american cheese, fang sauce on brioche bun
SwissShroom Melt
Meatloaf, portabellos, swiss, fang sauce, marbled rye, grilled
Southern Melt
Warm meatloaf, pimento cheese, tomato, red onion, marbled rye, grilled
Lucifer's Hammer
Meatloaf, jalapenos, pepperjack cheese, diablo sauce, lettuce, tomato on brioche bun
Joe Cool
Chilled meatloaf, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles, ketchup, white bread

Hot Sandwiches
Devil Went Down to Georgia
Turkey, pepperjack cheese, jalapenos, cole slaw, diablo sauce, marbled rye, grilled
Hunter S. Chicken
Roasted chicken, lettuce, tomato, bbq sauce, bacon, white cheddar, brioche bun
Bella Donna
Sliced portabella mushrooms, roasted red peppers, tomato, spinach, mozzarella, fang sauce, whole wheat, grilled
Shipyard Tunamelt
Tuna salad, mayo, dijon mustard, pickles, white cheddar, marbled rye, grilled
Georgia Reuben
Turkey, swiss cheese, cole slaw, fang sauce, marbled rye, grilled
Low Country Grilled Cheese
Spicy pimento cheese, american cheese, tomato, red onion, marbled rye, grilled
Cluck Old Hen
Roasted chicken, lettuce, tomato, fang sauce, brioche bun
The Big Deal
Grilled thick-cut beef bologna, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, mayo, brioche bun
Potsie
Grilled thick-cut beef bologna, red onion, mustard, mayo, white bread

Cold Sandwiches
Chatty Kathy
Chicken salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard, swiss cheese, marbled rye
High Five
Ham, turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, white cheddar, toasted white bread
Barnyard Caviar
Egg salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, marbled rye

Classic Deli Sandwiches
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken salad, lettuce, tomato, marbled rye
Turkey Sandwich
Turkey, lettuce, tomato, marbled rye
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Tuna salad, lettuce, tomato, marbled rye
Egg Salad Sandwich
Egg salad, lettuce, tomato, marbled rye
Ham Sandwich
Ham, lettuce, tomato, marbled rye

Salads
Small Pecan Dijon Salad
Spring mix and kale, bacon, spiced candied pecans, mozzarella, tomato, hard-boiled egg, honey-mustard dijon dressing
Large Pecan Dijon Salad
Spring mix and kale, bacon, spiced candied pecans, mozzarella, tomato, hard-boiled egg, honey-mustard dijon dressing
Small Asian Salad
Spring mix and kale, red cabbage, edamame, cashews, roasted red peppers, carrots, sesame ginger dressing
Small Garden Salad
Spring mix and kale, tomato, pickled green beans, roasted red peppers, red cabbage, carrots, ranch dressing
Large Asian Salad
Spring mix and kale, red cabbage, edamame, cashews, roasted red peppers, carrots, sesame ginger dressing
Large Garden Salad
Spring mix and kale, tomato, pickled green beans, roasted red peppers, red cabbage, carrots, ranch dressing
Large Tuna Nicoise Salad
Spring mix and kale, red potatoes, pickled green beans, tomato, kalamata olives, hard-boiled egg, tuna salad, house vinaigrette
Small Tuna Nicoise Salad
Spring mix and kale, red potatoes, pickled green beans, tomato, kalamata olives, hard-boiled egg, tuna salad, house vinaigrette

Sides
Dill Pickle Potato Salad
Carolina Kettle Potato Chips - Small
Pimento Cheese and Pretzels
Chocolate Kettle Chip Cookie
Carolina Kettle Potato Chips - Large
Side of Fang Sauce
Whole Shabang Chips
Scoop Egg Salad
Scoop Chicken Salad
Meatloaf Slice
Cole Slaw
Scoop Tuna Salad

Kids
Kids Chicken Fangers
Oven-roasted marinated chicken tenders (not breaded) served with fang sauce
Kids Meatloaf
Child-sized meatloaf served plain on bun
Kids Grilled Cheese
American cheese on white bread, grilled
Kids Fang
Child-sized warm meatloaf, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, fang sauce, brioche bun

Beverages
Cheerwine Soda
Wave Soda - Cucumber
Harney & Sons Lemonade
Diet Coke
Boylans Soda - Grape
Boylans Soda - Cream
Boylans Soda - Orange
Rocky Mountain Prickly Pear Soda
Harney & Sons Peach Tea
Harney & Sons Tea and Lemonade
Harney & Sons Black Tea
Bottled Water
Boylans Soda - Cola
Boylans Soda - Root Beer
Rocky Mountain Birch Beer
Diet Cheerwine Soda

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+41 photos
Photo credit: google
+40 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I had the Southern Melt, my wife got the Fang. Best meatloaf sandwich I've ever had and the price was definitely reasonable considering the serving!

Service was friendly and the atmosphere is local, cozy, and eccentric. Didn't realize there wasn't seating which was a bummer cuz I wanted to hang out. That said, this was a great find and I hope they keep on keeping on. It's the kind of place you'll be served by the owner and can buy local...
December 2025
I finally tried this place on my roommates suggested, boy was it good!! I had The Fang and the coleslaw. Both were amazing. The meatloaf is spot on and it’s clear the coleslaw is homemade, and very creamy. Sooooo good! We had delivery so I can’t rate the service or atmosphere.
October 2025
A bit pricey but overall good sammich shop.I had the Chatty Kathy which was on marbled rye with chicken salad. The girls had a turkey clubbish sammich. Near Capital University with outdoor seating.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Giuseppe's Ritrovo - 2268 E Main St
Italian, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
Graeter's Ice Cream - 2282 E Main St
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream
Khaab Indian Kitchen & Bar - 2400 E Main St
Indian, Wine Bar, Cocktail Bar

Newfangled Kitchen

2258 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209
(614) 817-1099