Betty Kaye Bakery

72 W Main St, Carrollton
(330) 627-2665

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brad Sciullo

Great prices and great selection and a good location. As far as getting in the middle of the Oilfield area. Very good service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Malaina Fondriest

Ordered a custom cake for my son’s 6th birthday and it came out just like I wanted, great flavor, colors, and overall an amazing experience!

Tara Foote

They knocked it out of the park with my last minute request for a graduation cake and cookies. I called only a couple of days before I needed a cake for graduation and it was absolutely perfect AND incredibly delicious.

Mikie Peters

A little small town bakery nestled in the heart of Carrollton. Wonderful service and really good prices. Get the lemon brownie with cream cheese frosting, you will NOT be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Flip Overs, Apple

Jeremy Seacrist

Excellent!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tom Newbold

I ordered a cake for my 95 year old mother for Mother's Day. I had asked for a white cake with just simple decorations, nothing elaborate, so imagine my pleasant surprise when the cake was beautifully decorated with flowers. It was super moist, just delicious. Mom was so happy, she said she had never had a cake so pretty, and she hated to cut it! (but we all ate it) This is the service we are used to at Betty Kaye Bakery, service above and beyond, employees who care about their customers, and great quality fresh food. I wouldn't consider going anywhere else locally for my sweet treats!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Jordan

Bombs were delicious, thank you

Food: 5

Yvette Carver

Grew up eating the cupcakes and brownies loved them. Bough them a few years back they were so dry I choked on them. Will not buy them again.

Melissa Sheldon

Love their baked items well worth trip.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

ReAnn ReAnn

We bought a cherry pie last week. Delicious! My daughter is in love with the brownies. It just so happened that we were coming through Carrollton county again.... So a stop at this yummy bakery was a must. My daughter loved the cupcake, today. I highly recommend and we will definitely be back! ?

Will Werling

Haven't tried there cake yet but cream horn's was good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wilbert Werling

Haven't tried there cake yet but cream horn's was

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Caleb Devitt

THE BEST! the brownies are SO addicting, and their pies and seasonal items are *always*

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Moonhunt Media, LLC

I ordered a cake a couple of weeks ago, and picked it up today: a cherry chocolate birthday cake with lilac coloured buttercream, lavender sugar sprinkles, white roses and a “happy birthday” monogram, with a dozen cupcakes to match. The lady who took my order said that she didn’t know if the baker would be willing to do all of this, and I had no idea what to expect. We had our party this afternoon. The cake(s) was delicious, delicate, beautifully elegant and just what I had imagined in my cracked noggin. The birthday girl (a middle aged woman who claims to be five) was delighted to tears; she said that she’s never received such a wonderful cake.Almost as impressive as the cake itself, was that it was $15 less than what I had budgeted.This is the third time I’ve ordered a birthday cake from Betty Kaye’s, and they never disappoint. So lovely. Thank you!

James Swaim

My work crew and I were working in the alley behind the shop, and the owners were nice enough to invite us in and get some sweets before the store even opened. Everyone was super nice and polite. Very welcoming and long-lasting business.

Loading...