Visit the ATM before ordering. $14.00 for a relatively skimpy pastrami sandwich? Are you kidding me? Should have ordered from the Japanese takeout next door. I'll never be back.
Matthew Buffa
Got the Manhattan Italian. The sandwich was drowned in oil and mayo. Bread was left soggy. Would not recommend.
Sami Pappas
I got the Harlem Panini & it was soooo good! Best potato salad I ever had & the quality of the food was outstanding!! Everyone was super friendly & kind & we loved the family atmosphere. 10/10 experience, we’re from out of town & wish this place was near us.
Nick Zuccarelli
Bad experience at the downtown location. I ordered the Brooklyn Bridge, a roast beef au jus. Supposed to come with roast beef, mozzarella or cheddar cheese, caramelized onion, horseradish and au jus. Sandwich and drink was north of $15. Pricey, but justifiable if the sandwich is excellent. Mine was not.Wait time was ~20 minutes. Sandwich was cold - refrigerator temperature, not room temperature. The meat was browned a bit on the edges that protruded from the bread but ~80% was uncooked. They used mayo instead of horseradish. They used raw red onions instead of caramelized onions. Did not come with au jus.Ordering system is really weird too. Entrance is near the south wall. You walk to the north wall, where the menu is posted. Then walk back to the south wall to order. Then walk back to the north wall to pick up your order. When you order they give you a receipt that you're supposed to hand to the sandwich makers so they know what to make. Idk why that would be the system in 2022, when you're punching the order into a computer to ring it up anyway. Maybe it's a "it's just like NYC!" gimmick, but if so that's very, very lame. Cashier did not tell the people ordering that they need to hand their receipt to the sandwich makers. Several people waited a long time before they discovered no one was making their order.Punchline is this: If you're going to charge $15 for a sandwich, you have to do better than this.There are 10,000 other sandwich shops to choose from. I recommend one of those.
The Lammiido
Best Deli in Cincinnati. Delicious sandwiches!!!
TableforToothpicks
Anderson’s NYC Deli is the perfect spot for lunch between stores, replete with New York classics like the Bronx Bomber and the Greenwich Special. Create your own sandwich from and assortment of hearty breads, sliced cold cuts, and crisp vegetables, or select one of Anderson’s Favorites. Paired with a side of kettle chips and a refreshing cup of sweet iced tea, the selection from this New York style deli is unmatched while perusing Kenwood Mall.
mike bergeron
Ordered Cuban and the strawberry lemonade. That sandwich is A-mazing! I should have worked my way thru the menu eventually and left that one for last. I don’t think I want to go the other way. And that strawberry lemonade! Not tart but a delicious combo of strawberry juice and lemonade. No cheap Minute Maid mix. Highly recommend. Give it a few minutes in line though. But know that each sandwich is made with your taste buds in mind
m N
Hands down one of the best sandwiches we've had in a long time. Don't let the mall food court fool you, this is bidden gem, if you ask me! Fresh, flavorful, and friendly staff! We will definitely be back, especially for the Cuban sandwich!!!
Jessica Bricking
One of my favorite places to go for lunch. The One New York Plaza is as big as my head and tastes so good. Best lemonade ever. And the workers are all friendly. Definitely recommended.
Autumn Ball
Best sandwiches I’ve EVER had!! This blows Izzy’s and Jersey Mikes out the water because there is NO competition. I’ve tried about 4 different sandwiches on the menu, and I’m amazed at how delicious they all are! Try the Bronx Bomber and add spicy mayo…you’ll thank me later! Be sure to add a slice of Juniors Cheesecake too. It’s nice to have a taste of NYC in Cincy.
First time here, the sandwich was soooo good. I'll be back
Alexis Desheers
This place is AMAZING!!!! I’m new to Cincinnati from NYC and had to try it. I ordered the Crown Heights Cuban and I was not disappointed at all! The staff is super friendly and extremely accommodating! They want you to be happy and satisfied and you will definitely leave that way! Such great customer service, great conversation, it was like being back home in NYC all over again. My husband and I will definitely be repeat customers!! Best deli in Cincinnati! Thanks for bringing us some NYC flavor!
Dana - DN
One of the best sandwiches I've ever had. I had the turkey pastrami on rye with grilled onions and mustard. DELICIOUS! Friendly and personable staff as well. Happy to see a family owned small business in the Kenwood food court ?.
Steven Kunz
Probably the best sandwich I have ever had. You have honestly not lived until you’ve had the Brooklyn Bridge. Can’t recommend enough!
Birch
I got the Greenwich Special with Mayo, its a pastrami and swiss with caramelized onions and dijon mustard. I will say its one of the best sandwiches I've had period. Its pricey but worth it.
Visit the ATM before ordering. $14.00 for a relatively skimpy pastrami sandwich? Are you kidding me? Should have ordered from the Japanese takeout next door. I'll never be back.
Got the Manhattan Italian. The sandwich was drowned in oil and mayo. Bread was left soggy. Would not recommend.
I got the Harlem Panini & it was soooo good! Best potato salad I ever had & the quality of the food was outstanding!! Everyone was super friendly & kind & we loved the family atmosphere. 10/10 experience, we’re from out of town & wish this place was near us.
Bad experience at the downtown location. I ordered the Brooklyn Bridge, a roast beef au jus. Supposed to come with roast beef, mozzarella or cheddar cheese, caramelized onion, horseradish and au jus. Sandwich and drink was north of $15. Pricey, but justifiable if the sandwich is excellent. Mine was not.Wait time was ~20 minutes. Sandwich was cold - refrigerator temperature, not room temperature. The meat was browned a bit on the edges that protruded from the bread but ~80% was uncooked. They used mayo instead of horseradish. They used raw red onions instead of caramelized onions. Did not come with au jus.Ordering system is really weird too. Entrance is near the south wall. You walk to the north wall, where the menu is posted. Then walk back to the south wall to order. Then walk back to the north wall to pick up your order. When you order they give you a receipt that you're supposed to hand to the sandwich makers so they know what to make. Idk why that would be the system in 2022, when you're punching the order into a computer to ring it up anyway. Maybe it's a "it's just like NYC!" gimmick, but if so that's very, very lame. Cashier did not tell the people ordering that they need to hand their receipt to the sandwich makers. Several people waited a long time before they discovered no one was making their order.Punchline is this: If you're going to charge $15 for a sandwich, you have to do better than this.There are 10,000 other sandwich shops to choose from. I recommend one of those.
Best Deli in Cincinnati. Delicious sandwiches!!!
Anderson’s NYC Deli is the perfect spot for lunch between stores, replete with New York classics like the Bronx Bomber and the Greenwich Special. Create your own sandwich from and assortment of hearty breads, sliced cold cuts, and crisp vegetables, or select one of Anderson’s Favorites. Paired with a side of kettle chips and a refreshing cup of sweet iced tea, the selection from this New York style deli is unmatched while perusing Kenwood Mall.
Ordered Cuban and the strawberry lemonade. That sandwich is A-mazing! I should have worked my way thru the menu eventually and left that one for last. I don’t think I want to go the other way. And that strawberry lemonade! Not tart but a delicious combo of strawberry juice and lemonade. No cheap Minute Maid mix. Highly recommend. Give it a few minutes in line though. But know that each sandwich is made with your taste buds in mind
Hands down one of the best sandwiches we've had in a long time. Don't let the mall food court fool you, this is bidden gem, if you ask me! Fresh, flavorful, and friendly staff! We will definitely be back, especially for the Cuban sandwich!!!
One of my favorite places to go for lunch. The One New York Plaza is as big as my head and tastes so good. Best lemonade ever. And the workers are all friendly. Definitely recommended.
Best sandwiches I’ve EVER had!! This blows Izzy’s and Jersey Mikes out the water because there is NO competition. I’ve tried about 4 different sandwiches on the menu, and I’m amazed at how delicious they all are! Try the Bronx Bomber and add spicy mayo…you’ll thank me later! Be sure to add a slice of Juniors Cheesecake too. It’s nice to have a taste of NYC in Cincy.
Restaurantji Recommends
First time here, the sandwich was soooo good. I'll be back
This place is AMAZING!!!! I’m new to Cincinnati from NYC and had to try it. I ordered the Crown Heights Cuban and I was not disappointed at all! The staff is super friendly and extremely accommodating! They want you to be happy and satisfied and you will definitely leave that way! Such great customer service, great conversation, it was like being back home in NYC all over again. My husband and I will definitely be repeat customers!! Best deli in Cincinnati! Thanks for bringing us some NYC flavor!
One of the best sandwiches I've ever had. I had the turkey pastrami on rye with grilled onions and mustard. DELICIOUS! Friendly and personable staff as well. Happy to see a family owned small business in the Kenwood food court ?.
Probably the best sandwich I have ever had. You have honestly not lived until you’ve had the Brooklyn Bridge. Can’t recommend enough!
I got the Greenwich Special with Mayo, its a pastrami and swiss with caramelized onions and dijon mustard. I will say its one of the best sandwiches I've had period. Its pricey but worth it.
Loading...