Sayler Park Pizza Co.

6595 Gracely Dr, Cincinnati
(513) 467-7700

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Matthew Slusher

Great owner with great pizza.

James cox

Great food ordered a pep large carry out waited like 20 minutes and had some of the best crust you could imagine, the cheese was flowing and had a true texture that complemented the old world style pepperoni perfectly. A pizza well worth the price hopefully they will have expanded hours and delivery area eventually. Very very good!!!!

Trinity Smith

First experience here. Got a large half pineapple, pizza itself wasn’t bad. Taking away two stars for two reasons- 1.) the crust, I know these are handmade pizzas which is great but the pizza is wicked thin and the crust is thick, heavy and no flavor. 2.) I called at 6:32pm, kid tells me 15mins. Great! I drive 15mins to the joint, get there to pay and the same kid tells me just a few, no worries I knew it wouldn’t be done in exactly 15. Stood out front of this place for what felt like years. I’m a pretty patient person who works in customer service, I realize things take time sometime and I’m not above waiting. Finally I get agitated enough to start glaring into the kitchen and a really nice (not being cynical, he was very polite) guy who was making the food asks if I’m there for a pickup. I tell him my name and there’s my pizza..COMING OFF THE WARMER INTO MY HANDS AT 7:30. The staff themselves are nice and they aren’t at all stingy with the pineapple which is hard to find so that was nice.

Ashley Lee

I got lied to and got an attitude from the guy when I called

Theresa Jane

I tried their deep dish pizza, and it was a total win!

Jeanne Dolby

It is so much better since reopening.We like the subs and the calzones are good when they have them. I wish they would do a thin crust pizza. I have made my own using their take home kits but I'm sure they would taste better if baked in a pizza oven.

Honesty Eversole

So good! Made with care and very fresh!

Julie Moser

Ordered from them tonight for the first time. Got a Pickle Pie and That's My Jam pizza as well as an Italian salad with Italian trio. Everything was delicious. My favorite was the Pickle Pie with a great blend of dill, chicken, ranch and onion. My husband loved the That's My Jam as the sausage was spicy but not overly so and the addition of tomato, bacon and caramelized onion was awesome. The pizza sauce was also amazing. The salad was crisp, fresh, and the house Italian dressing one of the best we've had. We will not hesitate to go again and try some of the other tempting pizzas, subs, and appetizers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Cederdahl

So happy this place moved into our neighborhood. Good pizza, service and prices!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Wilhelm

Recently this little pizza shop moved away from being owned by a major company and became independent. Same friendly people, but much better quality in ingredients. The pizza is 1000% better, and now it's incredible to have this good of pizza at a great price so close to home. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Amy Seewoester Lind

Great crust and sauce! Thumbs up in our house even from the picky eaters!

Chad Montag

Excellent pizza made with great ingredients!

Shane Mitchell

Great steak hoagies available on doordash ?

Food: 5

Katelyn Schroder

My order was completely wrong, and the staff were not very friendly. There was also a weird sour taste to the sauce in the dish. I don't plan on ordering from here again.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Ethan

Soda is cheap, pizza is amazing and cheap! Service was normal they weren’t mean or overly nice Atmosphere was sort of uncomfortable as it is decently small, overall amazing pizza place 10/10 would recommend

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...